News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hyperreal numbers: infinities and infinitesimals by doctorpangloss on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @01:22AM (#8255938)
From his article:

You can calculate the derivative, or rate of change, of a function f by doing

(f(x+ε) - f(x)) / ε

and then at the end throwing out terms involving ε

---

To be clear, this formula is typically introduced as the finite difference formula in calculus instruction.

But differentiation of polynomials is straightforward, so don't be too impressed that a simple formula finds the derivative of x-squared in his example. A bunch of simple procedures find the derivatives of polynomials.

For more complicated algebraic functions, like rational functions, nearly every calculus student is taught a collection of shortcuts that are fundamentally taking the limit of the finite difference formula as epsilon (or "h" commonly) approaches zero.

Re:Hyperreal numbers: infinities and infinitesimals by noelwelsh on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @01:43AM (#8255985)
I think you've missed the point. You're correct that one can do basic calculus using a bunch of ad-hoc shortcuts, and it is commonly taught this way. Also, as you probably know, calculus was first formalised using limits not infinitesimals.

However this theory of infinitesimals is not ad-hoc. It is a complete and rigorous alternate formulation of calculus in terms of an extension of the reals, known as the hyperreals, that includes infinitesimals. This allows computation in a principled way that matches the intuitions on which beginning calculus is often taught.

It's pretty cool stuff, and worth reading about even if you never use it in practice.