Re:Hyperreal numbers: infinities and infinitesimals
by noelwelsh on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @01:43AM
(#8255985)
I think you've missed the point. You're correct that one can do basic calculus using a bunch of ad-hoc shortcuts, and it is commonly taught this way. Also, as you probably know, calculus was first formalised using limits not infinitesimals.
However this theory of infinitesimals is not ad-hoc. It is a complete and rigorous alternate formulation of calculus in terms of an extension of the reals, known as the hyperreals, that includes infinitesimals. This allows computation in a principled way that matches the intuitions on which beginning calculus is often taught.
It's pretty cool stuff, and worth reading about even if you never use it in practice.
However this theory of infinitesimals is not ad-hoc. It is a complete and rigorous alternate formulation of calculus in terms of an extension of the reals, known as the hyperreals, that includes infinitesimals. This allows computation in a principled way that matches the intuitions on which beginning calculus is often taught.
It's pretty cool stuff, and worth reading about even if you never use it in practice.