News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Common App Rejections by stevenh on Sunday August 31, 2014 @08:11PM (#8250963)
Apple has always feigned a very strict and even preemptively cynical and condescending attitude toward developers regarding App Store approval. In their official statements, they always say things to the tune of "this isn't amateur hour. You're playing in the big leagues now. If your app doesn't have a polished feel to it, then it will simply be rejected." https://developer.apple.com/appstore/resources/approval/guid...

Despite this, they'll go ahead and approve apps which are so horrible that your middle school programming teacher would have failed you if you had created it as your first project in HyperCard. For example, have a look at this atrocious pile of garbage, which was allowed to sit at the #2 spot in the iOS free app charts for nearly three solid weeks earlier this year after Flappy Bird was pulled: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Vk1BnfJ7UM&t=1m50s

(and no, that's not a poorly recorded video; it's showing the actual gameplay frame rate.)

I don't think we can have an honest discussion about App Store rejections or approvals without discussing this elephant in the room: Overly-simple, ridiculously ugly games. In the past month, all kinds of ugly stick figure and moving rectangle-based games have reached the top 10 of the iOS free app charts. The creators weren't even reaching for an 8-bit aesthetic, the games were just simply horribly made and rushed out the door. These apps were inexplicably accepted into the App Store despite their horrendous quality. Some examples of games which reached the top 10:

https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/the-line/id880338977

https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/make-them-jump/id900211132

https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/amazing-brick/id905455244

Those games in particular were created by the same crooks (Ketchapp) infamous for being the first to port 2048 to mobile without the true creator's permission. I'm assuming everyone playing that clone of 2048 was shown ads pointing to their new games, which resulted in those games being artificially pumped to the top 10. While that is despicable in itself, what is equally as vexing is that those hideous games were ever approved for the App Store in the first place.

There is a massive disconnect between what Apple says regarding their review process and what actually happens. They can say whatever they want, but in actual reality, it's essentially random and luck-based, and dependent upon whatever mood the reviewers happen to be in. (And apparently it helps if you've already been successful on the App Store before. "Oh, your app looks absolutely terrible? Well, you made us a lot of money with your 2048 rip-off once, so it's no problem; go ahead and flood us with your worst!")

Re:Common App Rejections by qzervaas on Sunday August 31, 2014 @11:34PM (#8251417)
I recently published my first ever game, Hexiled. It has had some mild success in the first 6 weeks it's been available on the App Store.

About 2 weeks ago, a clone appeared on the App Store. It wasn't just copying the original game play, but boldly used the same game name, which Apple approved.

It's now been removed. The process was to contact Apple, who then provided us with a point of contact for the offending game. We then had to ask the developer of the offending app.

Thankfully, they took it down without any fight, but why should we have to even go through this dance?

On a side tangent, a recent update was "Metadata rejected" because the reviewer couldn't find the ads in our game when we stated there were ads.

Ads only appear after 5 games, which was clearly stated in the "Review Notes" that you can submit in iTunes Connect. I guess the reviewer didn't bother reading these though.

Re:Common App Rejections by Zaephyr on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:25PM (#8255197)
I really enjoy Hexiled. Glad you were able to take down the copycat. Wish you continued success with your apps.
Re:Common App Rejections by arrrg on Sunday August 31, 2014 @11:21PM (#8251383)
Those examples you names don’t have “horrendous quality”. They are also most certainly not ugly. I think they actually have tons of style and their aesthetics are quite consistent and straightforward. I also downloaded them and they all play fine.

I’m a bit baffled why you consider them to be so horrible …

They aren’t beautiful, they aren’t complex and they are derivative. 2048 is a disgrace, obviously, but those apps are fine.

I think Apple steers away from rejecting games because there just aren’t HIGs for those. So you can’t reject them based on those, and also not really their aesthetics. Games are explicitly allowed to have aesthetics and even UI elements different from other apps because of their very nature. They are tricky territory.

Re:Common App Rejections by threeseed on Monday September 01, 2014 @02:01AM (#8251698)
2048 is a disgrace ? I actually quite liked the design of it. It has that clean, functional UI that actually lends itself well to what type of game it is.
Re:Common App Rejections by codeka on Monday September 01, 2014 @02:47AM (#8251771)
I think he meant the clone of it that they put up before the original developer had a chance.
Re:Common App Rejections by oerhoert on Monday September 01, 2014 @03:23AM (#8251833)
I think it's worth noting that 2048 itself was a clone—or pretty much as close as you could get—of “Threes.” According to the developers, a year and a half was spent iterating on mechanics and design.

http://www.polygon.com/2014/3/28/5557840/threes-creators-exp...

Re:Common App Rejections by ctdonath on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:22AM (#8252495)
No, it isn't. This has been hashed to death. More like an idea whose time had come. 2048's author didn't know about Threes.
Re:Common App Rejections by arrrg on Monday September 01, 2014 @11:56AM (#8253450)
That’s not true. Well, strictly speaking it is, but the 2048 did know about another Threes clone. I don’t think he meant much by it and I don’t really fault the original 2048 author … but these guys … that’s not ok.
Re:Common App Rejections by clarky07 on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:42PM (#8251298)
Interestingly I mostly agree with your sentiment but I mostly disagree with your examples. There are plenty of examples of apps that are much much worse than those shown. the flappy clone isn't great but it could be worse. the other all have thousands of reviews with an average of 4 star. just because you aren't impressed with the graphics doesn't mean those shouldn't have been approved.

there are far far worse examples that could have been used, most of them never got into the top 10 in the store though. the fact that he had another popular app doesn't mean people are just going to click on the ads and automatically install their other apps. clearly you haven't advertised mobile apps before. it's not just trivial to drive that many installs even for good apps. doing it for terrible apps would be impossible unless you are using bots.

Re:Common App Rejections by chvid on Sunday August 31, 2014 @09:38PM (#8251154)
I don't quite understand what the problem is with the apps you have listed. Is it that because they are "primitive" and the graphics is "ugly" that they should not be popular?

Or is that the rankings have been frauded in some way? And exactly how is that done? Is there anything wrong with using an existing popular game to market a new game?

Re:Common App Rejections by djur on Sunday August 31, 2014 @09:15PM (#8251111)
I went to go see if they actually did say "amateur hour" (they do, amazingly) and in the process noticed this: "If you run to the press and trash us, it never helps." It blows my mind that they're willing to say that so explicitly.
Re:Common App Rejections by mikeash on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:24PM (#8251266)
Especially since it is so very, obviously wrong. Running to the press to trash the review process can help quite a bit when other avenues fail.
Re:Common App Rejections by cachvico on Sunday August 31, 2014 @11:21PM (#8251381)
Running to the press implies a kneejerk reaction. It could equally be argued that they're saying you should engage them in meaningful discussion about the problems they have with your submission. When an app is rejected I believe there is always the possibility of a two-way discussion with the submission team.

The larger subtext is that this is their platform, and they want to keep the quality bar high. Therefore, publication of your app is their perogative, not your right.

On that note, yes it is not amateur hour. If you want to publish an app, Apple provide all the resources to help you do it - but if for example your app is buggy, it's amateur and will be rejected - seems fair enough to me.

Re:Common App Rejections by djur on Monday September 01, 2014 @04:15AM (#8251954)
It makes perfect sense for Apple to have standards for publishing software on their store. What complicates the discussion is that they prevent users from installing software from other sources than their store. This is different than most other popular computing platforms except for game consoles.
Re:Common App Rejections by beaner on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:31PM (#8251276)
It also kind of hints that they're vindictive and unprofessional.
Re:Common App Rejections by fenomas on Monday September 01, 2014 @12:29AM (#8251550)
Metaphorically speaking, I think every app store has slider in its settings panel, with "lots of crappy/derivative apps" at one end, and "subjective/random curation" at the other. You can't decrease one without increasing the other.

Of course Google leaves their slider pushed to zero curation, treating apps like web pages (index them all and bury the crappy ones low in search results). But Apple seems to like their slider in the middle, which is why it seems so random to developers. After all, even when applied consistently, subjective rules appear random once you modulo by the difference between the observer's and the reviewers subjective viewpoints.

Personally I much prefer the Google approach, but then that's probably because I'd like for app stores to become commoditized. Apple probably doesn't agree. ;) Their slider does seem to have moved over the past few years though - perhaps it's post-Jobs drift; perhaps pressure from Google?

Re:Common App Rejections by eloisant on Monday September 01, 2014 @03:50AM (#8251888)
It's not "zero curation" with Google, they let anyone publish any app but they remove apps afterwards. For example they recently cleaned up all swing copter clones.

If a developer account makes too many apps that end up suspended, they can ban the user account. Then they're pretty good at detecting same physical persons using multiple accounts (credit card, IP address, etc.)

Re:Common App Rejections by fenomas on Monday September 01, 2014 @05:27AM (#8252117)
I don't think that qualifies as curation. Google's market policy is basically identical to YouTube, right? They resolve disputes and enforce the ToS, and that's about it. But one would be hard-pressed to call YouTube curated..
Re:Common App Rejections by 6cxs2hd6 on Monday September 01, 2014 @10:23AM (#8252952)
Yes. Also: this recent blog post claims Google is willing to remove apps that increase privacy (not just ad-blocking) in a way that undermines Google's business model: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8240450
Re:Common App Rejections by Geee on Monday September 01, 2014 @02:18AM (#8251721)
Those aren't particularly bad games, they seem to be functional and somewhat entertaining. Actually bad game would be one that has only one level, is impossible, etc. i.e. unplayable as an actual game.
Re:Common App Rejections by hrabago on Monday September 01, 2014 @04:41PM (#8254607)
So the original Swing Copters?
Re:Common App Rejections by moeedm on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:21PM (#8251260)
They set an extremely high standard, but some do get through the cracks. The upside of that is we get to see some really fantastic apps being made, that meet Apple's expectations, which simply can't be done on other platforms.

If they didn't set the bar that high, a lot more junk would be getting through.

Re:Common App Rejections by zak_mc_kracken on Monday September 01, 2014 @03:12AM (#8251815)
The junk is already there, as all the articles above yours are showing.

The bottom line is that the App Store has about the same distribution of crap/average/great applications as Google's Play Store, except that at least, submitting an app to the Play Store is instantaneous.

Re:Common App Rejections by djur on Monday September 01, 2014 @04:17AM (#8251959)
Which apps are available on the iOS platform that can't be done on other platforms?
Re:Common App Rejections by ryan-allen on Monday September 01, 2014 @02:17AM (#8251719)
You hit the nail on the head. This is why I download on average 0.2 apps per month, and why I've switched to Android.
Re:Common App Rejections by gress on Sunday August 31, 2014 @09:05PM (#8251091)
Presumably you are going simply by blogosphere opinions and never actually worked with app review yourself.
Re:Common App Rejections by gngaman on Sunday August 31, 2014 @09:02PM (#8251080)
The process isn't perfect, but it isn't nearly as bad as you are ranting about.
Re:Common App Rejections by zak_mc_kracken on Monday September 01, 2014 @03:13AM (#8251819)
It's not perfect, it just leads to the same distribution of crappy/average/great apps as Google's Play Store, except that submitting apps to the Play Store is instantaneous.