Re:Helmhurts: Placing a WiFi router with the Helmholtz equa...
by sitkack on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @11:13AM
(#8227526)
Given a 2.4Ghz pure sine wave and a couple signal strength detectors couldn't one iteratively modify the frequency dependent values for the various walls?
Re:Helmhurts: Placing a WiFi router with the Helmholtz equa...
by Stwerp on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @01:41PM
(#8228466)
Not for any practical measurements. This would work in say an anechoic environment – save for the wall under test – but you'd end up sampling multipath constructive/destrictuve interference instead of the wall reflections.
Re:Helmhurts: Placing a WiFi router with the Helmholtz equa...
by fennecfoxen on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @12:15PM
(#8227960)
> - Ignoring the 3D nature of antenna placement ...
A real antenna won't be an isotropic radiator, either. Got any antenna-pattern plots?
- Ignoring the 3D nature of antenna placement, you need to model the concrete walls properly to get an answer that is semi reliable. All materials have frequency dependent reflection and transmission (attentuation) coefficients. Its pretty easy to extend a toy FDTD sim to include these.
- For the reasons above, inferring 2.4Ghz behaviour from ~1GHz (30cm) signal isn't really a good thing to do (even in a "hand waving" manner).
- When displaying E-fields, you usually want to plot the ||E||^2 averaged over one complete wave cycle -- the nodes shouldn't jump around. If they do, it means the simulation hasn't reached a steady state.
Cheers!