News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by eudox on Monday August 25, 2014 @08:16PM (#8224987)
The article hits rather close to home, as someone who, for better or worse, is committed to improving Common Lisp's ecosystem. I often feel this existential dread of "Is it worth it? Whose lives will it change? Will I spend years labouring in obscurity for nothing?". And while the answer to all those questions is probably not what I'd like to hear, I still do it.

This is why ecosystems are, for most people, more valuable than intrinsic language features: Tribalism along the lines of "We have X thousand people backing us up"/"X thousand devs can't go wrong". People don't care about monads or macros, they care about feeling like they're part of a large community.

Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by pnathan on Monday August 25, 2014 @09:15PM (#8225173)
As someone also invested in Common Lisp, it.... hit really close to home.
Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by seanmcdirmid on Monday August 25, 2014 @09:46PM (#8225271)
Its even worse for the PL designer inventing something new without even a small ecosystem in place; I ask myself everyday "is it worth it?"
Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by tetha on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @04:25PM (#8229329)
The important question isn't necessarily: Is it worth it, without the ecosystem? The more interesting questions is: What does this language add?

For example, I need to deal with some unix process management tasks. I'm not crazy enough to do them in straight C, so I'm using python for it's strong C bindings, so I can use system calls in C with python level control flow. However, there's a lot to be desired, because dealing with all this concurrency and inherent raciness of the system in a language like python is a royal pain in the rearside.

Similar things with java and performant programming. Some of my major programs at work don't use the java ecosystem outside of log4j, junit, apache commons lang and apache commons collections. They use java, because java is darned fast without being as brittle as C or as nuts as C++. So java adds a lot of really cheap development security.

Designing yet another language that puts the existing features together with just a tiny difference doesn't add anything. I've enjoyed looking at experimental languages, and I've enjoyed tinkering around with ideas myself some time ago. But by now, I've accepted I'm not smart or talented enough to make something worthwile, and it will be some time until an interesting new breakthrough occurs.

Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @07:35PM (#8230170)
My languages tend to be very innovative or even inventive; e.g. I recently posted this to HN: http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/people/smcdirm/managedti...

My problem is quite the opposite: when the languages are so different from what already exists, people (and even myself) have trouble thinking about how adoption would even occur, at least in the short term.

Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by tetha on Wednesday August 27, 2014 @12:54PM (#8233153)
A lot of languages have made one major mistake: It's not easy to get a development environment going, and some even wanted me to not use vim.

The first step to some kind of adoption is that I can get it running with an "aptitude install crazy-foo-language-dk", maybe after adding a repository. After that, crazy-foo or crazy-fooc should be interpreter and/or compiler, and that's that.

Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday August 27, 2014 @08:06PM (#8235328)
Ya, well, my languages include their own development environments (I see no different from language and IDE, actually). Smalltalk was great in this regard also, to the chagrin of many developers who wanted to use vim.
Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by freyrs3 on Monday August 25, 2014 @09:56PM (#8225298)
Have to figure it takes 10-20 years to grow an industrial strength language. It takes a lot of faith in an idea or stubbornness ( probably both ) to go through that struggle. I admire people with that kind of dedication and I wish exploring the language design space wasn't such an enormous investment.
Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by sitkack on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @11:51AM (#8227791)
It is worth it. And your case it isn't the language per se, but spreading the ideas. The language is an ephemeral vehicle.
Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by bainsfather on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @10:46AM (#8227339)
Hi eudox, I would love to use CL for my projects - I've read (most of) Norvig's and Graham's books, written small programs etc. I really like most of the language, especially the 'break into debugger on error'.

But, when I came to write CL for a project that needed gui, web scraping, using APIs etc (i.e. I wanted to connect it to the outside world) I was stumped. Unlike in e.g. python, there was no nice gui library that I could just use. Now maybe people will reply telling me that something exists, but compared to python, the difference in ecosystem is massive. (possibly some commercial CL environment has this, but I am unwilling to pay for something that is closed).

I really want to use CL for more than just toy programs, but I don't/can't.

So, when you are asking yourself "Is it worth it? Whose lives will it change?" - the answer is mine, but only if you think you are able to fix this.

Good luck.

Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by crazypyro on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @11:06AM (#8227468)
I've had good luck using Haskell for similar things that you are describing. Hackage has a good variety of packages that do similar things to beautifulsoup, numpy, pandas, etc. Generally, I've found them to be less built up, but they still provide a decent level of abstraction. Cabal hell is real though.
Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by codygman on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @01:47PM (#8228491)
Regarding CL with some quick googling (searched "common lisp html parser" and "common lisp http client") I found:

Html Parser: http://www.cliki.net/cl-html-parse

Http client: http://weitz.de/drakma/

I'm not sure why you are/were stumped? I could search for qt bindings for you, but I'm sure they exist and are pretty mature.

Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by bainsfather on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @02:52PM (#8228816)
Thanks for that. Maybe I will try again some time.

I'm not saying it is impossible, rather that it is hard work compared to e.g. python. I recall looking through a few promising google results and finding e.g. that the library is no longer maintained, has bits missing etc. With python, when I use e.g. beautiful soup, it just works - I lose almost no time getting setup. When doing a project that needs many external libraries, that makes a big difference.

e.g. the first item on http://www.cliki.net/GUI has its last news item from 2007, and the mailing list gives 'not found'. But there is a new(er) github page with the comment "I cleaned up the library just in case I needed GUI in Lisp, but it turned out that I did not. Hence, the primary extent of my testing is running test-gtk:gtk-demo application. Bug reports and/or patches are welcome."

Since the parent was talking about ecosystems etc, I thought my experiences were worth mentioning - "Python novice uses python to get stuff done" but "CL novice gets lost in old/unmaintained libraries, gives up and sticks with c++ & python".

I mean no disrespect to the people who write these libraries etc., I am just describing what I found as a novice in CL.

Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by lispm on Wednesday August 27, 2014 @06:05AM (#8231434)
Many people who actually write GUI software in Lisp use one of the commercial offerings, typically either LispWorks and Allegro CL. That's one of their advantages: they offer maintained and cross platform GUI libraries.

One can for example also use Clozure CL for advanced GUI stuff, but that is best on the Mac.

For example http://opusmodus.com is a composition software using Clozure CL.

Other composition environments are written with LispWorks: PWGL, OpenMusic, Symbolic Composer, ScoreCloud.

http://www2.siba.fi/PWGL/

http://repmus.ircam.fr/openmusic/home

http://www.symboliccomposer.com

http://scorecloud.com

Re:Dylan: the harsh realities of the market by bainsfather on Wednesday August 27, 2014 @04:17PM (#8234511)
Thanks for the info. I just had a quick look at Clozure CL - as you say, the main Gui library is for apple. The other gui library is labelled 'under development' but also 'last modified: 6 years ago' :(

I wonder whether the (I'm told) good commercial lisp offerings have hampered lisp adoption, in that people who use lisp a lot, pay for commercial offerings, leaving the free stuff less used and maintained? Then newcomers, who don't want to pay to do hobby projects in a new language, are discouraged by the less maintained free stuff.