News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by nardi on Friday August 22, 2014 @03:22PM (#8213523)
I'm amazed at the ignorance in these comments.

First, yes this is cool new science. No one imagined nickel would work as a water-splitting electrocatalyst. This is very surprising, and awesome.

Second, the point of water-splitting is obviously not power generation. It's power storage, just like a battery, but with better transport and storage characteristics.

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by crististm on Friday August 22, 2014 @03:45PM (#8213603)
I don't know about ignorance, but basically, the energy you get from splitting the water molecule (in the form of H2 and O2) is lower than the energy consumed to make the split. For storage you will also have to deeply freeze the gases unless you want to have huge tanks for storage

So what makes a hydrogen exposed freezing tank better suited for transport and storage than a chemical battery?

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by cjensen on Friday August 22, 2014 @04:01PM (#8213675)
A car which runs on hydrogen can be refueled in a few minutes. Batteries need an hour of charge or a battery swap which costs labor.
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by seanflyon on Friday August 22, 2014 @06:05PM (#8214170)
A battery swap only costs labor if you do it manually. I don't see why you would do that.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H5V0vL3nnHY

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by nardi on Friday August 22, 2014 @03:51PM (#8213640)
This is just pessimism. Yes, there are other hurdles to overcome for hydrogen. But this is a major advance in one of the primary pieces necessary for a hydrogen economy. What makes you think advances in other areas are impossible?

And to answer your question, much better energy density by mass.

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by keenerd on Friday August 22, 2014 @04:39PM (#8213828)
Who cares about mass except NASA? H2 is terrible by volume, a liter of gasoline has more hydrogen in it than a liter of liquid H2 and the gasoline is a lot more safe.

Some little PDFs about the hurdles of hydrogen from one of my favorite tech writers:

http://www.tinaja.com/glib/resbn88.pdf

http://www.tinaja.com/glib/energfun.pdf

A hydrogen economy might be possible one day, but not until we find a natural H2 source that is as "free" as crude oil. Man made hydrogen will not work on a large scale. Electrolysis is one of the worst ways to make hydrogen, though it does have the highest "gee-whiz!" factor.

If we did have unlimited hydrogen spewing out of the ground people would seriously consider first cracking the H2 into hydrocarbons to make it easier to transport.

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by waps on Friday August 22, 2014 @11:03PM (#8214853)
And if you blast coal with it ... Guess what comes out ?

(Granted you'd also need to make coal out of co2, which is so much harder. but every little bit helps)

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by digikata on Friday August 22, 2014 @05:00PM (#8213926)
It's not, but it might be interesting for electrical storage of excess renewable energy, especially in concert with a less reactive storage material. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_storage Though many places seem to want to solve the issue for cars, while to me it makes more sense to solve it for buildings before making it portable enough for cars.
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by mikexstudios on Friday August 22, 2014 @03:39PM (#8213578)
"No one imagined nickel would work as a water-splitting electrocatalyst."

Not true. It has been known since the 1950s (and likely earlier) that Ni oxides can function as water splitting catalysts (both for hydrogen evolution and oxygen evolution half reactions).

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by nardi on Friday August 22, 2014 @03:46PM (#8213612)
Of course you're right. I meant that no one thought nickel oxides would be practical compared to noble metal catalysts. I haven't read the article, but I assume they're using some kind of novel nanostructuring to increase the catalytic activity.
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by alex_duf on Friday August 22, 2014 @03:34PM (#8213561)
right, but using a AAA battery which is already storing energy doesn't serve any purpose.

But I agree with you, efficient-cheap catalyst is needed indeed. I'd like to know the efficiency of the system though...

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by petersellers on Friday August 22, 2014 @03:59PM (#8213666)
Using a AAA battery demonstrates that the process can be done using low voltage.
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by alex_duf on Friday August 22, 2014 @04:10PM (#8213717)
ooh, alright, now it makes sense to me. Thanks.
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by kazinator on Friday August 22, 2014 @04:27PM (#8213780)
Even if we imagine ourselves in a crazy world in which banks of actual AAA batteries are used for water splitting (not only to demonstrate the low voltage) there can still be an advantage.

A cylinder full of compressed hydrogen weighs less than a trunk full of AAA batteries, which cuts into economy.

The clunky bank of AAA batteries can be stationary in some water-splitting plant, whereas the hydrogen is light and portable.

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by lutorm on Friday August 22, 2014 @04:20PM (#8213757)
Give me a break. Did you read the article?

Although touted as zero-emissions vehicles, most of the cars will run on hydrogen made from natural gas, a fossil fuel that contributes to global warming. Now scientists at Stanford University have developed a low-cost, emissions-free device that uses an ordinary AAA battery to produce hydrogen by water electrolysis.

You don't agree the juxtaposition gives the impression that the latter alternative won't contribute to global warming?

Edit: just to be clear, I'm not saying the research isn't useful. My issue is with the article.

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by dang on Friday August 22, 2014 @04:52PM (#8213892)
> Give me a break. Did you read the article?

Please don't be personally rude on Hacker News. This comment would be fine without the first two sentences.

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by jack-r-abbit on Friday August 22, 2014 @05:39PM (#8214091)
No disrespect... but nardi did, in fact, NOT read the article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8213612
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by nardi on Friday August 22, 2014 @07:22PM (#8214382)
I meant I hadn't read the paper. I had of course read the linked article, which is light on details of how they created the catalyst.
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by jack-r-abbit on Friday August 22, 2014 @07:29PM (#8214398)
My bad. When you said article, I thought you meant the linked article. I don't see any reference to a paper so clearly I have no idea what you are talking about. I'll just go about my day. :)
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by lutorm on Friday August 22, 2014 @05:44PM (#8214103)
Guilty, though I responded to the OPs "I'm amazed at the ignorance in these comments". You don't think that warrants the same comment?
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by dang on Friday August 22, 2014 @07:49PM (#8214456)
No, because it wasn't personal. I agree with you that that phrase was irritating, in an otherwise fine comment. But that's not enough to pass the moderator-speaking-up threshold. Imagine how many moderator comments there would be in that case. :(

I wish there were a way for users to suggest edits to each other's comments. My bet is that most of us have no idea when our comments include superfluous stuff that could easily be edited out. Suppose there were an easy way to send pull requests on comments. One could look at the diff and, if it improved the signal/noise ratio, simply accept the changes.

HN needs more sober second thought.

Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by lutorm on Saturday August 23, 2014 @02:49AM (#8215214)
Well, as the author of one of the comments being accused of ignorance, I took it quite personally. Little comments like that start the slide and it's all downhill from there...
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o... by dang on Saturday August 23, 2014 @12:55PM (#8216227)
That is sadly true.

We're still interested in whatever might be done to curtail such downhill slides.