With hydrogen, the issue issue is that (at least to my understanding) if you have electricity, we already have a far more efficient solution: put the electricity directly into a battery and use it to power a motor. Going the route over electrolysis->hydrogen storage->fuel cell imposes such efficiency penalties that it would need extremely compelling other advantages to be competitive, and I don't see them.
If we're going to have a rational discussion about various forms of emission, we need to talk about total fuel cycle emissions, otherwise it's meaningless. Touting one small section of a fuel cycle as emissions free is at best confusing, at worst misleading.
With gasoline, the use of stored energy requires emissions.
With batteries, the use of stored energy does not require emissions.
You are creating false equivalencies, the only purpose of which is to drag down the discussion and stop the discussion.
You want to talk about fuel cycle, talk about the fuel cycle, don't say things that are blatantly false.
With gasoline, the use of stored energy requires emissions.
With batteries, the production of stored energy required emissions.
True, the analogy isn't perfect, because maybe the batteries were charged from a PV system (though in practice chances are they were not) but to call it "incredibly dishonest" and "blatantly false" seems a bit excessive, don't you think?
The point is, while using power from a battery doesn't cause any emissions, you need to know where the energy came from to make any meaningful comparisons.
Hydrogen fuel cells also tend to be highly efficient.
The long-term performance question is interesting, though. Any idea how long the time scale would have to be before the fuel cell wins?
Sadly this is not the case. Fuel cells have similar lifespans as batteries.
Agree that hydrogen isn't an ideal fuel though. They're overselling that point. But the science is about how to split water efficiently. It's outside the scope of this research to address how to handle and use hydrogen after that.
If it is a chore to use the stuff for rocket science, I don't see it becoming a reasonable power source in more casual applications.
If I am factually incorrect about anything here, I honestly do want to be told so.
At some point you have to trust the reader to understand things that are completely obvious. That's a necessary quality of good writing, even if you're adhering to the newspaper standard of targeting someone at the 8th grade reading level.
Hydrogen is not exactly the easiest compound to work with and how it is generated is a huge part of equation.
On the contrary, if they'd demoed the thing with a small solar panel I might have had some issues with it, and wanted to see some elaboration. The fundamentally good thing about the battery example is that everyone understands that making a battery costs something. IMO it's a better example than you give them credit for.
Certainly everyone reading here understands that it takes energy to make a battery, that the creators of the gadget haven't defeated the laws of thermodynamics, and so on. Hence my comment about trusting the reader.
Plus, all I know about hydrogen points to it not being anything close to "an ideal fuel for powering vehicles, buildings and storing renewable energy". It has very low density, requires cryogenic storage or very heavy pressure vessels, migrates through materials, and is explosive when mixed with air.