Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o...
by jacquesm on Friday August 22, 2014 @04:10PM
(#8213720)
But in the case of Hydrogen such 'completely obvious' things are actually not all that obvious to the target audience. So it's ok to spell it out to avoid the risk of overselling a new technology and thus create a situation where it will fail to deliver due to unrealistic expectations.
Hydrogen is not exactly the easiest compound to work with and how it is generated is a huge part of equation.
Re:Scientists at Stanford develop water splitter that runs o...
by justin66 on Friday August 22, 2014 @06:49PM
(#8214298)
The article did not claim the energy used to proceed the hypothetical AAA battery was free. That certainly would oversell some things.
On the contrary, if they'd demoed the thing with a small solar panel I might have had some issues with it, and wanted to see some elaboration. The fundamentally good thing about the battery example is that everyone understands that making a battery costs something. IMO it's a better example than you give them credit for.
Certainly everyone reading here understands that it takes energy to make a battery, that the creators of the gadget haven't defeated the laws of thermodynamics, and so on. Hence my comment about trusting the reader.
At some point you have to trust the reader to understand things that are completely obvious. That's a necessary quality of good writing, even if you're adhering to the newspaper standard of targeting someone at the 8th grade reading level.