News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by rayiner on Monday August 18, 2014 @04:31PM (#8194485)
The various sides of the immigration debate are talking past each other. This article describes a German program that takes high skill people like the architect profiled in the article, while those opposed to immigration are mainly concerned about the large numbers of low-skill people who are not interested in assimilating. The anti-immigrant folks in Britain and France aren't worried about Mr. Pinol. They're worried about the people who want to self-govern according to Sharia law inside a western country.

As for the U.S., the key difference with Germany is that our fertility rate is 1.89 (over 2.1 during the boom). Theirs is 1.36 (under 1.4 since 1990).

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by freehunter on Monday August 18, 2014 @04:47PM (#8194586)
The article does talk about African laborers and Bulgarian demolition crews. Not high-skilled work. Also "Angela Merkel... has spoken out against immigrants relocating here merely to tap generous domestic welfare benefits."

You're right that masses of low-skill immigrants is a problem, especially when they are not integrating with society. It seems Germany has this problem too ("And many Germans still call the lack of assimilation among Turkish immigrants a leading national problem.").

Your score is bouncing quite heavily, indicating that this is a controversial comment. You're not wrong though. The question I still have after reading the article is, how is Germany dealing with the low-skill immigration (or how effective is their vocation training and welfare system)? Can the US or UK implement similar plans with any success?

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by _delirium on Monday August 18, 2014 @04:56PM (#8194628)
The Turkish "problem" is longstanding and kind on both sides as well. Many Turks are not that sure if they want to integrate into German society, and many Germans are not sure if they want them to either (though this sentiment is weaker than it once was). That produces a self-reinforcing situation.

Many of the current Turkish residents came during the 1960s as part of a guest-worker program [1], or are descended from those who did. The expectation was that they would be temporary workers (no path to citizenship) and eventually go home again. The program was closed in 1973, and the government spent much of the late '70s and '80s trying to encourage them to leave, more than encouraging them to integrate. There are many kids who've grown up 100% in Germany (some grandkids too) who aren't German citizens, and until very recently, were not encouraged to become citizens. (Germany does not have jus soli citizenship, and before a reform in 1999, it was also very difficult for someone not of German descent to naturalize.)

The fact that many Turks in Germany come from poor and highly conservative regions of Turkey (generally not Istanbul) doesn't help assimilation, of course. But it also doesn't help that the message for decades was that they aren't German and can't become German. And non-integration is complex, too. When Americans think of unintegrated Mexican immigrants, for example, they think first and foremost of Spanish speakers who can't speak English. But almost all the Turks considered unintegrated do speak German. Some (especially younger generations) don't even speak Turkish fluently (or at all), but only German.

Lots of these aren't German-specific problems, though. Since at least the late 19th century, European counties have been based on the ethnic nation-state, and transitioning to some idea that people can change nationalities, or even have more than one (and what that means) is slow and produces opposition.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gastarbeiter

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by enraged_camel on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:24PM (#8194779)
As a Turk, I don't see the "Turkish problem" as being Germany's fault at all. These people went to Germany on a temporary basis, and decided to just not leave when the guest-worker program ended. In other words, they overstayed their welcome.

Imagine inviting a guest to your house for dinner, and them liking your house a lot and deciding to just move in permanently. Are you then expected to encourage them to put their name on the lease (i.e. become a citizen)? I don't think so.

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by _delirium on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:29PM (#8194808)
If it were literally a 3-year temporary visa or something, I'd agree (and they wouldn't be there anymore, because overstaying would lead to deportation). But they didn't illegally overstay. They simply worked in Germany long enough to became German nationals. Partly, because in the EU (formerly European Community), the concept of a long-term "guest" with no rights is just not recognized: if someone lives in your country for years at your invitation, is able to support themselves and not engaged in criminality, and has learned some language/civics basics, they have a right to apply for permanent residency after some period.

I don't think I support the concept of a long-term "guest" with no rights, so I don't think it's wrong that such rights exist. That's what countries like Kuwait or Dubai do, with long-term "guest workers" who don't have legal rights. If someone has lived and worked here (Denmark) for 5 or 8 or 10 years or whatever, I think they should have legal rights on that basis. Much more so if they were born in Denmark; and doubly that if their parents were born in Denmark too, so that it's been two generations since they were immigrants. What is the alternative in that case, deport someone who was born and raised in Denmark to a country only their grandparents were actually from, and whose language they don't even speak?

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by krebby on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:29PM (#8194805)
Can you blame them? As I've heard it told, many of the German employers wanted to hold onto the employees they'd already poured training resources into (and enjoyed working with). Many of the Turks had established families and livelihoods in Germany by the time the guest worker program ended.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by coldtea on Monday August 18, 2014 @10:41PM (#8195792)
>As a Turk, I don't see the "Turkish problem" as being Germany's fault at all. These people went to Germany on a temporary basis, and decided to just not leave when the guest-worker program ended. In other words, they overstayed their welcome.*

Here's how it went down. First, Germany slaughtered and exterminated millions of people, invaded tons of countries, destroyed their infrastructure, commited heinous crimes, etc. What we know as World War II.

After the end of the war, West Germany, as a valueable ally of the West against USSR, got all kinds of help and special treatment to rebuilt its economy. And they started a program for bringing in workers from places they invaded and decimated, like Greece. Those workers, like the involuntary "arbeit mach frei" workers before, were brought to serve as cheap immigrant labor, under exploitative conditions, to assist the very people that had unprovoked invaded their countries and killed their relatives and fellow citizens a decade or so ago. The guest-workers, besides being exploited with lesser wages than Germans and fewer opportunities for advancment (like b-rate citizens) they were also treated with extreme racism and prejudice.

Now, the problem of the Germans (the "they overstayed their welcome") was that these people didn't just disperse when they were done with them, but instead felt that those hard working years in Germany gave them a right to stay and be integrated as full citizens.

Such nerve, huh?

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by CmonDev on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @04:15AM (#8196389)
"a program for bringing in workers from places they invaded and decimated" - against their will?
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by coldtea on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @05:04AM (#8196498)
I don't really understand this notion -- I usually get this kind of question from Americans: that if you consent to something, it makes it OK, regardless of the circumstances under which you gave your consent. I think this ideas usually comes from people playing life in "easy mode" (white, well educated, middle or upper middle class), that have never been forced to consent to humilliating or exploitative demands of the kind billions of people often have.

If I burn down your house (and kill your cousin and your Jew neighbors), and you or your kid, starving, accepts to come work for my company, and I treat you like shit on top, that doesn't make it OK in my book.

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by CmonDev on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @11:43AM (#8197923)
Maybe my knowledge of history in this area is not sufficient.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by hcho on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @05:21AM (#8196537)
Well, Germany never invaded Turkey. If anything, they were way too cosy during WW2.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by mschuster91 on Monday August 18, 2014 @07:29PM (#8195255)
> You're right that masses of low-skill immigrants is a problem, especially when they are not integrating with society.

Turks aren't that much of a problem anymore. These days, the massive influx of refugees (unanticipated by our stupid politicians) are the biggest problem. We lock 'em in overcrowded camps, prohibit them from working for 9 months and then wonder why trouble arises.

Fuck our politicians. The way the entire EU treats refugees is disgusting.

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by xrange on Monday August 18, 2014 @08:27PM (#8195436)
>unanticipated by our stupid politicians

...how sure are you about the whole "unanticipated" thing?

http://nationalinterest.org/print/article/dead-souls-the-den...

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by mschuster91 on Monday August 18, 2014 @09:49PM (#8195687)
That's US stuff, I don't deal much with US politics. Our (German) politicians chose to ignore the growing numbers and problems, instead opting to mistreat refugees in order to deter others from coming.

Brave New World.

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by legulere on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:15PM (#8194727)
The "issue" with the turkish really cooled down in the last maybe 20 years. Over 50% of young people in Germany already say that Islam belongs to Germany.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by learc83 on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:31PM (#8194823)
>Over 50% of young people in Germany already say that Islam belongs to Germany.

What does that mean?

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by danohuiginn on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:40PM (#8194866)
the phrase in German is "Der Islam gehört zu Deutschland" -- which means something like Islam has a place in Germany.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by willthames on Monday August 18, 2014 @09:19PM (#8195606)
The above translation should probably just be "belongs in" rather than "belongs to" then. Your clarification helped, thanks.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by xpolitix on Monday August 18, 2014 @08:03PM (#8195364)
That's not true, I did a Ph.D in France, I was an assistant professor, and was stopped and fully body searched by the police at the train station for the only reason I am dark skinned. Not only did it end there, even after they saw my papers and called the university, I was let go, but the pack leader had to yell at me that France is not a place for me.

Affraid of Low skilled ppl ? No! Affraid of difference, definetly yes! But again this is France. Don't know about Germany, but Canada is way more warm hearted than France.

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by younes0 on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @05:18AM (#8201630)
I don't see link between your comment and the main topic. Plus this is typical french bashing: we french people financially contributed to your PHD, and you're basically saying that we are racist like some policemen who are just fed up with the problematic mass low-skilled immigration consequences.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by xpolitix on Wednesday August 27, 2014 @07:55PM (#8235291)
Maybe you should go see an optometrician. France did indeed contribute to my Ph.D: mistreatement and exploitation. FYI, like most of the "immigrants", I have done research for free (yes, free with no scholarship), paid more taxes than you are probably doing now and contributed to your retirement (not mentioning the contributed research). So please, don't spill what you've just heard from your far right politicians who have nothing to do than bashing anything that relates to africans: Like bashing the French education minister because her parents are north-african immigrants.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by gioele on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:07PM (#8194678)
> As for the U.S., the key difference with Germany is that our fertility rate is 1.89 (over 2.1 during the boom). Theirs is 1.36 (under 1.4 since 1990).

Please, when online (but also offline) do not use "ours" or "theirs". What is "ours" in this case? Germany or US? It is not clear from the context.

Also, if a person born in Germany goes to the US, what is "ours", what is "theirs" to s/he?

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by josephschmoe on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:10PM (#8194696)
American is 1.89.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by mappu on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:22PM (#8195042)
For all America, or just the USA?
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by deciplex on Monday August 18, 2014 @09:25PM (#8195629)
You will never reverse this oddity of English vocabulary, no matter how much you bellyache about it on the Internet. Sorry that basic lingual fact contradicts your sense of fairness or whatever.

If it helps, you can think of "American" as shorthand for "American of the United States". If that doesn't help, I suggest you just get over it.

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by guyzero on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:36PM (#8195091)
Nobody from Canada or Mexico would say they are "an American." Americans are residents/citizens of the USA.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by DevoAKA on Monday August 18, 2014 @08:15PM (#8195393)
Not totally true. I went to school with a lot of Mexicans and they would get verbally upset when I referred to the US as "America". As a Canadian, I could care less but they were very adamant about it.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by josephschmoe on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @01:56PM (#8198780)
I feel bad for people from Tijuana, as they are Californian and American but reside in neither California nor America.

The titles come from culturally distinct regions.

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by mc32 on Monday August 18, 2014 @09:09PM (#8195579)
For the most part they say "North American," South American or "Latin American" even "Anglo Saxon America" for North America not including Mexico, go figure.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by arethuza on Monday August 18, 2014 @04:46PM (#8194575)
I think you might want to have a look at the opinion of UKIP - who mostly certainly do want to restrict immigration from EU countries to the UK:

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/comment/despite-what-uki...

NB Personally I regard the right to live and work anywhere in the EU as a wonderful thing.

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by jiggy2011 on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:40PM (#8194867)
In the UK there are definitely worries about low-skill migrants , mainly because of EU right to work rules which allow workers from any EU member country to live and work in the UK. Most of the concern is about migrants from poor countries which are recent EU entries like Romania taking low paying jobs and exerting downward pressure on the wage market.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by mkaziz on Monday August 18, 2014 @04:57PM (#8194638)
Is there something wrong with self-governance, as long as your rules don't violate the laws of the land?
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by arethuza on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:03PM (#8194665)
We get a lot of daft Muslim scare stories in some parts of the press here in the UK, "sharia law" being one of the favourites - this article in the Guardian tries to point out the reality:

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/may/12/muslim-scare-st...

On closer inspection, it is clear sharia courts only have jurisdiction on civil matters and everyone must opt in to a sharia court. They only have an advisory capacity and address mainly property and financial matters, and rulings are then only enforceable by civil courts. In many cases, they are understaffed affairs, where one official settles petty disputes and draws up rudimentary documents.

So just like any other kind of alternative dispute resolution - mediation, adjudication, expert-determination, arbitration etc.

Edit - I'm actually over-stating this last bit, "sharia" law isn't nearly as strong as these formal ADR mechanisms.

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by kghose on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:34PM (#8194831)
There are important issues that crop up when the dispute resolution claims a higher authority. The societal pressure to accept such judgements are a lot higher and the arbitrariness and biases (against women, for example) of such judgements are also higher.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by rayiner on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:41PM (#8194873)
The judgments of arbitration proceedings, etc, are enforceable in regular courts. Its not purely independent of the state.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by jiggy2011 on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:48PM (#8194909)
The problem with these stories tends to be that some native people in the UK don't really seem to understand the legal system and use these headlines to come to the conclusion that muslims aren't subject to UK criminal law, which is obviously false. Thus the tabloids like to print them because they generate outrage.
Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by sedachv on Monday August 18, 2014 @08:03PM (#8195365)
Why do you think it's acceptable to have a civil court based on religious principles? The idea is wrong and is the start of a slippery slope.

Opting out of these courts may not be an option for women pressured by their families and communities.

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by arethuza on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @04:23AM (#8196412)
As far as I know, they aren't "courts" - they have no legal power. They are just people trying to resolve disputes outside of the courts - which is actually pretty common.

I'm not trying to say that there won't be problems with these kinds of mechanisms, but if UK citizens want to get together and try and work through a dispute based on some religious principles and all parties agree then I don't think we should be trying to stop it.

Re:The new land of opportunity for immigrants is Germany by learc83 on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:39PM (#8194863)
I think the fear is that having seen the countries these immigrants come from--in many cases, not liberal democracies--the native population is afraid that the immigrants want to make the country more like the old country, and local sharia courts are just the first step.