News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by Xylakant on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:15AM (#8192032)
He's trying to avoid trial. That's the issue at stake. I think we're all indebted to Assange for what he did at wikileaks, but that doesn't make him a saint. I would think higher of him if he would have stood at the trial and been acquitted or even if he were found guilty and accepted the punishment.
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by jval on Monday August 18, 2014 @07:19AM (#8192173)
Why are we all indebted to Assange? Nobody has any idea whether what he did had a net positive or negative affect on ours or other people's lives. There's doesn't appear to be a reason behind a lot of the leaks, and worst of all there has been little effort made to ensure people don't get killed as a result of what is being leaked. Overall I don't feel indebted to him at all.
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by facepalm on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:24AM (#8192046)
Didn't he offer to have the trial held in another place? I haven't followed so closely. But the assumption that it might all be a farce to get him delivered to the US doesn't sound completely far-fetched. Assuming he just avoids the trial because he is guilty is silly. If you don't trust the system, it's a good reason to try to avoid it.

Edit: since I have googled now, apparently he is not wanted in Sweden for a trial, just for a questioning.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by alkonaut on Monday August 18, 2014 @07:07AM (#8192148)
It's not even a trial, merely a questioning. And while he has offered to have the questioning take place in London, Swedish law simply doesn't permit it. While that might be ridiculous, it won't just change for this particular case (and Swedish authorities don't make the laws, they enforce them).

Next he wanted guarantees from Swedish authorities that if he were to travel to Sweden, he wouldn't be extradited to the US. Swedes tried to explain that no such guarantees can be made: authorities can only process requests for extradition once made. Giving a guarantee up front would be illegal as it completely circumvents the laws regarding extraditions.

These two things combined meant Assange complained "I can't be questioned here nor be guaranteed I won't be extradited to the US!", both of which are ridiculous complaints when you read the laws involved.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by dagw on Monday August 18, 2014 @08:58AM (#8192413)
They don't want him for "merely a questioning", they want to file charges against him so that the trail can commence. In Sweden you cannot formally file charges against someone who isn't in custody, and Swedish police obviously can't take someone into custody in a country where they don't have jurisdiction.

It's just an accident of terminology that the relevant Swedish legal phrase translates to "questioning" in English.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by xorcist on Monday August 18, 2014 @07:33AM (#8192205)
It's also a bit of a peculiar demand to make. Both Assange and his lawyer can not possibly believe they could get any extralegal guarantees.
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by contingencies on Monday August 18, 2014 @09:25PM (#8195631)
Untrue. Swedish law does permit it. See http://justice4assange.com/extraditing-assange.html
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by alkonaut on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @04:11AM (#8196381)
Government should not give preemptive assurances and forego the courts, regardless of whether it has happened in the past.

The main question is: what is there to gain for Sweden by offering any guarantees to Assange (other than having him show up sooner)? It's a matter of relations with the US (which are closer than they should be as Snowden revealed) versus the matter of human rights. A delicate decision without a given answer.

In Sweden one probably wants to keep the possibilities open and delay all investigations regarding refugee status, extradition requests etc to when they actually have Assange. If he wants to wait several years until he needs to visit a hospital, neither the US nor the Swedes really care: his whereabouts are known.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by contingencies on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @04:16AM (#8196393)
I note that when faced with the fact that they can interview him remotely (and this is entirely normal and occurs frequently in the EU) you've changed the scope of discussion and avoided conceding the point.

Your newly suggested scope is to whether Sweden should give guarantees and accept Assange's generous offer to return to Sweden physically with a guarantee he will not be handed to the US.

The fact is that Assange has not been charged with any crime, left Sweden with its blessing after responding to queries on the case (which was already thrown out of court), and as an innocent member of the global public is certainly not obliged to make such generous offers.

The Swedish prosecutor Marriane Ny's continued lack of movement on the case and media-directed table-thumping, even ignoring her own bar association, prominent international lawyers, and international organizations such as Human Rights Watch, has been extremely telling.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by Tomte on Monday August 18, 2014 @07:02AM (#8192136)
How gracious!

You might have missed that the venue of a trial is usually pre-determined, certainly not chosen at the whim of the defendant.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by facepalm on Monday August 18, 2014 @10:41AM (#8192818)
Out of curiosity, what do you think about Amanda Knox? Italy overturned her acquittal and wants another trial.

Do you think she should go to Italy? If she doesn't go, would that make you believe she is guilty?

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by Tomte on Monday August 18, 2014 @10:58AM (#8192903)
I think she'd be stupid to go there.

But the difference is: no one in their right mind expected Italy to let Ms. Knox leave for the United States when she was in custody.

Only when she was acquitted, the arrest warrant was lifted, and according to Italian law she was free to go, was she able to leave.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by facepalm on Monday August 18, 2014 @11:40AM (#8193109)
I don't remember - how did Assange get out of Sweden? I assume he wasn't in Sweden anymore when the accusations were made?

So I am really not sure what you are saying? WOuld you have said Amanda Knox should have gone to Italy, had she already been in the US before the first trial?

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by Tomte on Monday August 18, 2014 @11:56AM (#8193181)
He is in the UK and is wanted for arrest in the UK. What's difficult to understand?
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by facepalm on Monday August 18, 2014 @12:27PM (#8193308)
I think technically he is in Ecuador.

I don't understand the distinction you make between the two cases. Both people are wanted for trial in another country.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by Tomte on Monday August 18, 2014 @02:55PM (#8193968)
No, he isn't. Can the old urban legend about exteritoriality please already die?

The difference is that noone forces Ms. Knox to Italy, because the USA don't extraditre their citizens, I guess.

Assange isn't in Australia. He's in the UK, and the UK forces him to Sweden.

If you don't see the difference, then there's nothing more I can do or say.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by facepalm on Monday August 18, 2014 @04:38PM (#8194529)
Well if they force him, I expect he will go. That's the definition of forcing somebody to do something. So what was your problem again?
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by aragot on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:29AM (#8192055)
Not sure you understand that he might also be guilty of trahison against US. Should he be intercepted by US authorities, he would be given a hard time. That's what he's fleeing against. Had it been the two alleged assaults alone, I'm confident anyone would have faced the trial.
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by Xylakant on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:36AM (#8192069)
Well, as others have pointed out: Being in the UK actually makes is _more_ likely to be extradited to the US, since when he's in Sweden, both Sweden and the UK would have to agree to an extradition request. The UK is also not particularly well known for fighting US extradition requests. That's certainly not accounting for extralegal extradition, but that's a different pair of shoes. I don't think that being in Ecuador helps against that any better than being in Sweden.

Given that, I have the feeling that he was actually trying to avoid the trial and using the fear of extradition to the US as a convenient excuse. I may quite well be wrong on that, but that's how I currently feel.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by antimagic on Monday August 18, 2014 @07:33AM (#8192203)
Why would they need UK agreement to extradition if he's in Sweden???
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by Tomte on Monday August 18, 2014 @07:44AM (#8192231)
Because European law says so.

Read the New Statesman article linked somewhere in this thread. You'll find that most of what people on the Internet say about the legal issues is factually wrong.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by contingencies on Monday August 18, 2014 @09:27PM (#8195636)
The New Statesman article and its author David Allen Green have been extensively debunked. If you do choose to read it, read it in conjunction with http://justice4assange.com/extraditing-assange.html to get the full picture.
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by idlewan on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:35AM (#8192066)
It's not possible to be guilty of treason against a country that is not your own.
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by shiven on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:26AM (#8192051)
Only, the Swedes would have had a quick/sham trial and extradited him promptly to the US regardless of the outcome of the rape case.

Not everything is as black and white as you appear to make it.

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by legulere on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:38AM (#8192074)
That doesn't make any sense. Why would the US try to get him to Sweden first and not get him extradited directly from the UK? The UK is a way closer partner to the US than Sweden.
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by Xylakant on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:37AM (#8192071)
But it's as black and white as you appear to make it. Just a different kind of black, eh? Why don't we let the court figure that out? Under public scrutiny?
Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by facepalm on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:49AM (#8192099)
What would the public do, how would they help (in stopping his extraction to the US)? How much "truth" do you think you receive everyday about the state of the world, through our "public" channels?

Apparently you trust the system, so maybe you can not understand how it feels if you don't trust the system. I hope you'll never have issue to worry about it.

Edit: answering here because HN won't let me reply - The issue is not that you trust the system and want him on trial, that's a fair attitude. The issue is that you assume he is guilty because he avoids the trial (or rather, questioning).

Perhaps it makes logical sense if you assume everybody would trust the system. But perhaps you can accept that not everybody trusts the system, and that therefore their avoiding it doesn't prove guilt.

In fact I think your attitude demonstrates a typical failure of the system. Most people (who represent the system) are prone to jumping to conclusions and illogical assumptions (he runs so he must be guilty).

Re:Assange 'to leave' Ecuador embassy by Xylakant on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:57AM (#8192123)
Yes, I do trust the system in general. There's a need for public scrutiny, but in general - while imperfect and certainly in need of some fixing - it's the best system we have had for the last couple of hundred years.

It's understandable that Assange might not trust the system, but that does not mean that I have to support that. It's obviously not a better system if everybody on his own gets to decide which parts of the legal system apply to him or not. It's not an opt-out system.

Given that, even if that were not the case: I trust the UK less than Sweden. The alleged scheme makes no sense: It would be the same for the UK and Sweden could only loose. Unless somebody gives me a credible reason what Sweden has to gain from allowing extralegal action of the US under its legal system, I'm sticking with my opinion.