And, well, we're starting to get repetitive, but I disagree with the premise of the second paragraph. Building a service like this that relied entirely on Twitter (and the local internet provider and the local power company and whatever else) with no way to find out if it stopped working was pretty stupid. Yes, it's the sort of mistake a lot of people make, but that doesn't mean it's not-stupid. Pointing out that it was stupid conveys that the ultimate problem was not in choice of service but in the thought process in how the problem was considered and how the solution was conceived.
Maybe there are more tactful ways of pointing out "you didn't think this through very well". But hell if I know what they are (the thing I just said is not IMO any nicer than "that was dumb") and hell if I'm going to put a bunch of effort into figuring it out for a throwaway internet comment.
Unless you have some sort of objective measure, calling something "stupid" is just your way of feeling smart at somebody's expense. It's a dick move.
The more useful standard is "reasonable", as in the legal term "reasonable mistake". Here, I think he made a reasonable novice mistake. Being a dick to reasonable novices does not reduce the number of mistakes; it just decreases the number of novices who will actually ask. And also the number who will post articles like this, ones useful in educating other reasonable novices.
I'll add that if you aren't willing to put any effort into a comment, maybe you just shouldn't make it. You can just say out loud, "Boy, that was stupid," enjoy feeling superior, and move on. If you're going to the extra effort of pissing all over somebody in public, then you might as well go all the way and make a useful comment. Or even a compassionate one. That those things are hard for you is only about what you've decided to get good at, not what's actually easy or hard.
I like how you do everything you criticize. You keep saying I shouldn't say things are "stupid" because it'll hurt the poor guy's feelings and it's subjective anyway and people won't learn that way. But you have no qualms calling my comment "a dick move", as if that was somehow an objective fact, and then acting like I'm supposed to learn from your comment even though the guy who wrote the article is not supposed to learn from mine.
Honestly, lead by example or go away. You're not helping by committing every sin you accuse me of while claiming to be trying to educate me.
That an action is dickish is indeed factual. The guy attempted to make a positive contribution to our collective dialog by offering a story of his mistake. That took bravery and generosity. You admit you made a lazy negative comment, one you now seem to realize wouldn't help him. You were, in the words of Urban Dictionary, being "brash and insensitive", "put[ting] your own interests" first.
Your last paragraph is especially funny. By your own standards, my behavior is apparently fine, but still you complain. If you think it's ok to call somebody's mistakes stupid, surely I can point out your mistakes using negative tone. Funny how you think negativity is wrong when you're on the receiving end of it.
I care about substance. Your comments have none. Thus they are irritating.
You're not inclined to "allow" me to make subjective statements as if they were objective? What do you think you are, the Internet Police? Go away before I laugh at you a second time.
Your "OMG hypocrisy" routine is cheap and lazy rhetoric. I'm not saying a negative tone is universally bad. I'm saying that replying dickishly to a positive novice contribution harms the dialog by reducing future novice contributions. Whereas I think negative tone in reply to a dickish comment can help the dialog by reducing future frequency of dickish replies.
If you don't like being irritated by people calling you out to being a dick to noobs, maybe you could try stopping being a dick to noobs. Then we can all be less irritated.
The third option, one between "you're stupid" and hiding the truth, is to not be a dick about it. The only way people get to the point of being experts is by making a lot of mistakes. If you'd like somebody to listen to your wisdom, there are better approaches than starting out with "that was pretty stupid of you". Especially when it was not in fact pretty stupid of him.