News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Twitter Killed My Fish by mikeash on Sunday August 10, 2014 @11:46PM (#8161837)
I wouldn't care about your negative tone if 1) you weren't talking about how bad a negative tone is and 2) if you were making any kind of decent argument.

I care about substance. Your comments have none. Thus they are irritating.

You're not inclined to "allow" me to make subjective statements as if they were objective? What do you think you are, the Internet Police? Go away before I laugh at you a second time.

Re:How Twitter Killed My Fish by wpietri on Monday August 11, 2014 @12:31PM (#8163910)
You're the one who brought up "allow", so I can't say what you mean by it. What I mean is that I'm disinclined to let your dickishness go by unchallenged.

Your "OMG hypocrisy" routine is cheap and lazy rhetoric. I'm not saying a negative tone is universally bad. I'm saying that replying dickishly to a positive novice contribution harms the dialog by reducing future novice contributions. Whereas I think negative tone in reply to a dickish comment can help the dialog by reducing future frequency of dickish replies.

If you don't like being irritated by people calling you out to being a dick to noobs, maybe you could try stopping being a dick to noobs. Then we can all be less irritated.