News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by genwin on Thursday July 31, 2014 @07:28PM (#8117597)
I reckon we're 20 years away from the overpopulation problem reaching the same level of media attention as the consequent global warming problem does now. The former is still a taboo topic. In the meantime expect things to get way worse.

There's plenty of river water available in the US West for a lesser population, which can be attained through attrition.

Downvotes predictable, tech solves everything, more people is always better, there's nothing to see here, please move along.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by Shivetya on Thursday July 31, 2014 @07:40PM (#8117635)
We are not suffering an overpopulation problem and we are far far from one world wide, so much land is locked up by governments and not used that we can continue growing for a long time, combine that with the incredible waste of food the occurs, if not water, we just need to change our management.

The water issues the West face are because of decades of mismanagement by the Bureau of Reclamation and at state levels has distorted water usage. The amount of farm land in California that only exists because of inordinately cheap water has resulted in too many water intensive farms not sucking dry the water table.

The fix is simple but not popular, start charging for water what it costs to deliver there. Building dams and supporting infrastructure to deliver water is not cheap, nor is their maintenance. So charge appropriate amounts for it.

Yeah, some farms are going to revert back to grasslands and maybe even forest over the long term. The farms themselves will simply move to where water is more readily available and cheaper. That is how things should work, but the government distorted this with water that was so cheap it encouraged the problem that exist.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by mullingitover on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:10PM (#8117732)
> The fix is simple but not popular, start charging for water what it costs to deliver there.

I think articially cheap farming is the whole idea. We subsidize our agriculture market to make us competitive as an exporter (note that we howl in protest when other countries artificially prop up their export businesses, e.g. cheap Chinese steel).

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by deciplex on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:28PM (#8117973)
It's justified for agriculture. Famine sucks, and relying on trade with other nations to feed your people is a losing proposition as well.
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by ak217 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:53PM (#8118050)
I think you're trying to say that agriculture is a national security critical industry. OK - is depleting the water table and causing a chronic regional drought good for national security, too?
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by deciplex on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:35PM (#8118148)
Yes, that's what I'm saying, and no, obviously depleting the water table is stupid - and, in the long run, harmful to national security for the same reason.

I was just pointing out what should be obvious - not disagreeing with the parent comment.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by nickff on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:41PM (#8118018)
>"relying on trade with other nations to feed your people is a losing proposition..."

Please explain the rationale behind this argument; the substance of your reasoning is not clear from this statement.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by deciplex on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:30PM (#8118137)
Well, look at how much people complain about gas prices, and the extent to which that can influence government, and try to imagine what would happen if people were starving instead of merely paying more than they are used to for transportation.

We prop up the government of Saudi Arabia, and to some extent this is true of Israel as well, and in fact most of what we do in the Middle East - at great cost diplomatically - all for oil. And food is more important than oil.

The food supply is simply too useful a lever for politics, to hand it over to a third party, i.e. a foreign country.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by nickff on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:50PM (#8118178)
You make an interesting argument, though I cannot imagine how any foreign power would have a greater influence on politics than the existing farm lobby (, as is true both in the USA and Europe).

I am also unconvinced that foreign aid (and other instruments of foreign relations) are largely being used for the purpose of obtaining oil. If one closely examines the history of OPEC, there is little evidence that it has had any significant impact on the determination of oil prices since the 1970s. Foreign aid seems to be used for all sorts of unproductive (and sometimes unintelligible) reasons, which can easily be demonstrated by looking at where the foreign aid budget is spent. A large proportion of foreign affairs spending appears to be on mercantilist ventures, which often overlap with oil extraction, but is clearly a very different motive.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by deciplex on Friday August 01, 2014 @12:46AM (#8118414)
>You make an interesting argument, though I cannot imagine how any foreign power would have a greater influence on politics than the existing farm lobby (, as is true both in the USA and Europe).

Perhaps not, at least not in modern times. However, a powerful, even corrupt, farm lobby is preferable to a suzerain, which is what any third party who you rely on to feed your people would be.

For the rest of your post, I agree most foreign aid is money not well spent, at least in the case of the US. But, that's only because most of the money spent by the US government is not well spent, because it is corrupt beyond redemption.

It's not clear that propping up Saudi Arabia decreases the price of oil for the US. It's not clear that keeping Israel around as a destabilizing presence in the Middle East, decreases the price of oil for the US. Hell, it's not even all that clear to me that the Middle East is so strategically important when it comes to oil in the first place - we get more oil from Canada than from the ME, and Latin America as well, after all. Not to mention domestic production. It figures largely into the political calculus nonetheless - I never said American leaders were smart.

Perhaps our actions in the ME are more about denying resources to others, than securing them for ourselves. Perhaps, more than anything, they are the result of a world power being run into decline by a pack of short-sighted fanatical xenophobic fools (and here, I am not referring to the American political establishment).

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by fchollet on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:16PM (#8117757)
It is impossible to talk about overpopulation without defining some context first.

- what lifestyle do you want for your population?

- what processes do you have in place to achieve this lifestyle?

It is often mentioned that the US lifestyle cannot be sustained for 7 billion people and that therefore Earth has an overpopulation problem. Of course, given how insanely wasteful the US lifestyle and its underlying processes are, this is ridiculous. The problem lies not with the number of people, but with waste, mismanagement, and general consumerist insanity.

Worth noting is that Japan has ten times the population density of the US (while having a mostly inhabitable country due to its mountainous geography) while sustaining higher levels of comforts for its citizens than the US. One glaring difference is that Japan recycles most of its trash. In the US, everything is disposable and essentially no recycling ever occurs. The same level of complete waste applies to water management, energy management, and so on.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by genwin on Friday August 01, 2014 @12:29AM (#8118379)
Good points. The lifestyle I'd want for my kids would be more resources available per kid (whether they use them or not) and less effort expended to attain a resource, not the current situation where there are ever less resources that are ever more expensive in today's dollars to attain.

For example if they want wild salmon for dinner I'd like the rivers to be teeming with salmon, like they used to, and for a salmon to always cost $1 in today's dollars, instead of $15 a pound today and $30 a decade from now and so on.

And yes I'd like everything to be recyclable and recycled to the maximum extent, whatever is needed to keep the good life sustainable until the Sun becomes a red giant.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by mjmahone17 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @07:44PM (#8117647)
There's also plenty of water available in the US West if there wasn't so much water-intensive agriculture in arid regions (Yuma, Imperial Valley, etc), which uses 80% of the river.
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by genwin on Thursday July 31, 2014 @07:57PM (#8117689)
Why not focus on the root cause instead of workarounds?
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by aaron-lebo on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:06PM (#8117723)
Isn't that the root cause? If we shifted agriculture to areas where water is more readily available (easier said than done), wouldn't that solve a lot of the issue?

I'm ignorant about the topic, but is there produce that can only be grown in those areas and not in other parts in the US or even Mexico, or is the concentration of agriculture there mainly due to increasing returns?

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by mjmahone17 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:24PM (#8117784)
We actually don't even necessarily have to shift agriculture itself. Right now, the agriculture is water-intensive: the only reason it's so water-intensive is because water in the West is cheap. We know how to grow produce using less water-intensive methods (see Eurofresh Farms in Willcox, AZ), it just isn't very economically viable, because water is not the expensive part of agriculture (for the producer).
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by lutorm on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:03PM (#8117711)
How is "water intensive farming in arid areas" not a root cause?
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by Spooky23 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:22PM (#8118116)
By draining the Colorado dry and making it relatively cheap to grow lettuce and celery all year in the middle of the desert, we expend a ridiculous amount of water.

Sounds like a root cause to me. Make it more expensive and food prices would rise, and we could resume doing things like growing greenhouse vegetables in Massachusetts, etc.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:05PM (#8117722)
Because quite often in such cases, focusing on the real root cause would mean reducing population to 10% and basically rolling back the Industrial Revolution - which is not going to happen, so we're stuck with workarounds if we want to move forward.
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by ak217 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:01PM (#8118074)
You are mistaken about industrial and development water use in the US West. Agricultural water use in California exceeds urban water use by a factor of almost 4x, and exceeds industrial use (broadly defined, minus agricultural industry) by at least 16x. Agriculture is the elephant in the room. Residential water use (lawns!) is a distant second. Everything else is a very distant third.

Source: http://www.ppic.org/content/pubs/report/R_211EHChapter2R.pdf

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by deciplex on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:32PM (#8117992)
In this case it would just mean that various agribusinesses in the area would have to shut down, after decades of being artificially propped up by subsidized water. Naturally, a corporation has more political muscle than a reservoir, so it is likely the water will continue to be subsidized until there isn't any left, and the subsequent economic collapse will be blamed on immigrants.
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by josephschmoe on Thursday July 31, 2014 @07:38PM (#8117628)
The U.S. fertility rate is 1.880. We are only experiencing a population increase currently because our total population was so much lower 80 years ago.

Our fertility rate went below 2.0 in 1994, so we'll see noticeable natural decreases in population in the second half of the century unless life expectancy increases by more than 20 years.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by genwin on Thursday July 31, 2014 @07:50PM (#8117665)
Local < 2 fertility rates are swamped by global > 2 rates. Overpopulation is a global problem affecting the US, same as global warming. The US is fast growing in population.
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by CapitalistCartr on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:16PM (#8117760)
This is completely wrong. World population is about 7.2 billion people and growth is slowing. The UN projects it will peak at about 9.1 billion in about 2050, then decline slightly. And the US population isn't fast growing, its projected to reach 438 million by 2050. Most of the US growth will be immigration, which is completely under our control.

As for being swamped, lately, in spite of the recent economic downturn, global population growth rates have been lessening by more than demographers expected. All of this can be read with a cursory Google search. My numbers are from the UN, US Census Dept., and Pew Research.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by kourt on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:10PM (#8117935)
immigration, which is completely under our control.

And yet media reports consistently imply that restricting immigration is both impossible and unethical.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by genwin on Friday August 01, 2014 @12:12AM (#8118338)
> And the US population isn't fast growing, its projected to reach 438 million by 2050.

That's fast growing to me.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by bequanna on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:05PM (#8117719)
>The US is fast growing in population.

No.

Google: 'US births per woman'. In the US, that is ~1.7. 2.1 is considered the replacement rate in developed countries.

After that, check out: 'world births per woman' Currently (2011) @ 2.41 down from 2.67 in 2000, 3.23 in 1990. Do you expect this trend to suddenly flatten or reverse?

In the future, longer life expectancy will likely have a larger impact on population numbers than birth rates. In specific developed countries, I would also expect immigration to be part a large part of growth.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by bane on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:14PM (#8117750)
The U.S. population growth rate is ~.75% per year. Even though the fertility rate is lower than some other industrialized countries, the immigration rate is very high.

Global average population growth rate is 1.1%.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by aurelian on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:16PM (#8117756)
The US population grew by almost 10%, over 27 million, between 2000 to 2010.
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by shakethemonkey on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:31PM (#8117807)
Yes, but not from the birth rate. The US receives well over 1M immigrants per year[1]

[1] http://www.pewhispanic.org/files/2005/09/2005-immigration-tr...

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by anigbrowl on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:23PM (#8117781)
No they aren't. Global population is levelling off faster than people anticiapted and is likely to plateau at 9b in 2050 - a lot of people, to be sure, but far from the Malthusian scenario you seem to be suggesting.
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by cscurmudgeon on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:41PM (#8117846)
Would you rather scores of others die than give up on irrational habits like eating beef?

Would you rather be counted amount the attrition?

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by wyager on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:02PM (#8117908)
>Would you rather scores of others die than give up on irrational habits like eating beef?

That's a completely false dichotomy.

There's nothing irrational about eating beef from a resource standpoint. For example, if we were to allow the Market to act efficiently (which we might not (which would actually be irrational, from my standpoint)), the resource requirements of raising beef would 100% guaranteed make it impractically expensive to eat, and there would be no issue. As it stands, beef is already rising in cost much faster than other forms of meat! See http://www.buedelmeatup.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/chart...

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by Spooky23 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:25PM (#8118126)
Beef isn't irrational. Ranching in Nevada probably is.

It's a market problem. Because of the way water rights were allocated, it's cheap to do wacky things like farm the desert. You can very easily farm beef cattle in places where water is abundant... Places like New York, Kentucky, etc, just not at the scale as on massive plots of empty land.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by cscurmudgeon on Friday August 01, 2014 @10:32AM (#8120001)
Pasting mmanfrin's comment:

It's specifically Beef that is the massive drain. Chicken/Pork/other meats are magnitudes of orders more water-conscious per calorie. (Pork uses 75% less, and is yet the most wasteful of water outside of cows/bovine)[1]. Beef is astoundingly wasteful of water. You could take an hour-long shower and it would use about the same amount of water needed for a pound of beef. [2] and [3]. [1] http://gracelinks.org/blog/1143/beef-the-king-of-the-big-wat.... [2] http://www.wsscwater.com/home/jsp/content/water-usagechart.f.... [3] http://blog.epa.gov/healthywaters/2012/03/virtual-water-real....

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8117761

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by Spooky23 on Friday August 01, 2014 @11:31PM (#8123911)
Beef used to be more expensive as compared to chicken. It's cheap now because you can buy near worthless land and turn it into feedlots and ranches.

Those scale that you can operate on with modern, subsidized agriculture is unstoppable. A farm in upstate NY is 50-500 acres. A ranch in the high desert may be 50 miles^2. Also, the land isn't empty in the east, and people won't put up with the smell of thousands of cattle.

Stop giving away water to desert farmers. Prices will rise, and demand will shift to places where water is plentiful.

Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg... by genwin on Thursday July 31, 2014 @11:59PM (#8118308)
> Would you rather be counted amount the attrition?

Do I have a choice?