Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg...
by mjmahone17 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @07:44PM
(#8117647)
There's also plenty of water available in the US West if there wasn't so much water-intensive agriculture in arid regions (Yuma, Imperial Valley, etc), which uses 80% of the river.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg...
by genwin on Thursday July 31, 2014 @07:57PM
(#8117689)
Why not focus on the root cause instead of workarounds?
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg...
by aaron-lebo on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:06PM
(#8117723)
Isn't that the root cause? If we shifted agriculture to areas where water is more readily available (easier said than done), wouldn't that solve a lot of the issue?
I'm ignorant about the topic, but is there produce that can only be grown in those areas and not in other parts in the US or even Mexico, or is the concentration of agriculture there mainly due to increasing returns?
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg...
by mjmahone17 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:24PM
(#8117784)
We actually don't even necessarily have to shift agriculture itself. Right now, the agriculture is water-intensive: the only reason it's so water-intensive is because water in the West is cheap. We know how to grow produce using less water-intensive methods (see Eurofresh Farms in Willcox, AZ), it just isn't very economically viable, because water is not the expensive part of agriculture (for the producer).
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg...
by lutorm on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:03PM
(#8117711)
How is "water intensive farming in arid areas" not a root cause?
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg...
by Spooky23 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:22PM
(#8118116)
By draining the Colorado dry and making it relatively cheap to grow lettuce and celery all year in the middle of the desert, we expend a ridiculous amount of water.
Sounds like a root cause to me. Make it more expensive and food prices would rise, and we could resume doing things like growing greenhouse vegetables in Massachusetts, etc.
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg...
by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:05PM
(#8117722)
Because quite often in such cases, focusing on the real root cause would mean reducing population to 10% and basically rolling back the Industrial Revolution - which is not going to happen, so we're stuck with workarounds if we want to move forward.
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg...
by ak217 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:01PM
(#8118074)
You are mistaken about industrial and development water use in the US West. Agricultural water use in California exceeds urban water use by a factor of almost 4x, and exceeds industrial use (broadly defined, minus agricultural industry) by at least 16x. Agriculture is the elephant in the room. Residential water use (lawns!) is a distant second. Everything else is a very distant third.
Source: http://www.ppic.org/content/pubs/report/R_211EHChapter2R.pdf
Re:Satellite study reveals parched U.S. West using up underg...
by deciplex on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:32PM
(#8117992)
In this case it would just mean that various agribusinesses in the area would have to shut down, after decades of being artificially propped up by subsidized water. Naturally, a corporation has more political muscle than a reservoir, so it is likely the water will continue to be subsidized until there isn't any left, and the subsequent economic collapse will be blamed on immigrants.