News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by Tichy on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @03:10PM (#811659)
I think women are underrepresented in garbage collection, too (among other jobs).
Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by gaius on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @04:25PM (#811861)
Well, this is a crucial point. Feminists have tunnel vision. They look in one direction and see that CEOs and politicians are mostly male. But they don't look the other way and see those in dirty and dangerous jobs are overwhelmingly male too. And in prison. And living on the streets. 80% of people working more than 50 hours a week are male. 97% of people killed at work are male. I can't even recall a feminist calling for the retirement age of women to be increased to that of men, despite higher female life expectancy...

But this is why it's not called "equalism".

Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by aplusbi on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @04:48PM (#811932)
Many women may not be aware. I know that the feminists I know would not be surprised if you told them that and would agree that it is not fair for men.

The feminist fighting for greater rights than men is a stereotype that represents only a small (but extremely vocal) minority of feminists.

Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by Tichy on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @05:21PM (#811996)
I wouldn't suspect feminists of wanting to get an advantage, but I suspect they might be reacting to sensationalist and distorted statistics at times. Just because there are different numbers of males and females in some positions does not imply that discrimination is the cause.
Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by timr on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @04:37PM (#811898)
There's some irony in your comment: I think you're coming at this from the perspective that programming is a desirable field, and that "feminists" want to be part of it, while not wanting to be part of the dirty or dangerous jobs that other men do (those greedy feminists!)

But what if the reason that women don't take part in CS is because it isn't desirable? What if women avoid the field because it's a glorified, white-collar version of ditch-digging, without career longevity or personal growth?

Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by Tichy on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @05:13PM (#811979)
"But what if the reason that women don't take part in CS is because it isn't desirable?"

I consider that likely, actually. I am also not sure who is shouting about the women in IT issue - is it really feminists?

Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by compay on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @06:49PM (#812139)
If women simply find CS "undesirable" at a ratio much higher than men it would be interesting to try to find out why. To me there doesn't seem to be anything particularly masculine or feminine about CS.
Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by uninverted on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @04:43PM (#811914)
Yep, total old boys club; you only get in from reference counting. When will women be able to mark and sweep?
Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by compay on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @04:36PM (#811896)
Sure, society has loads of examples of jobs being divided up along gender lines, and of unfairness against men too.

But does that mean we can't even talk about why our profession in particular attracts so few women, while lots of other "knowledge worker" professions are more balanced? Do we have to resolve all other fairness issues first, before we can even talk about it?

I think it's an interesting topic and that the hostility and derisiveness that usually surrounds these articles are unjustified.

Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by Tichy on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @05:34PM (#812027)
"Do we have to resolve all other fairness issues first, before we can even talk about it"

I would be interested in why few women choose IT. However, the phrasing of the headline made it sound like more than just talking. "Lack" implies a problem that needs fixing, doesn't it?

Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by Dellort on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @04:44PM (#811918)
It's not hostility or derisiveness, it's just pointing out that it's not just our particular profession that attracts so few women.

A lot of work in all professions is needed to solve this problem and we must devote all of our time to point that out equally.

Hookers for example is another problem area, most hookers are women. Where are all the male hookers?

Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by kaitnieks on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @04:25AM (#812748)
The question about "male hookers" is fair but the reason is probably more physiological than anything else. I mean most males simply can't sleep with unattractive women (and I hope I don't have to explain the reasons for that - maybe there are medical workarounds for that but I have no idea about the efficiency) while women can. The demand is probably unbalanced, too, but I'm sure it's not completely, um, satisfied on women's side. As long as we can still acknowledge that there are differences and deal rationally with them, the humanity will be all right.
Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by compay on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @04:53PM (#811941)
So your logic is basically, "I have cancer, but it's ok, lots of other people do too. No need to see the doctor."
Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by Dellort on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @05:14PM (#811981)
No sarcasm, I really mean we have to commit ourselves to investigate and point out all areas where there is an imbalance. Not just where we would want more women or men, in this instance computer science.

I think also there is a lack of women in the fishing industry, out on the boats.

Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by drhowarddrfine on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @03:21PM (#811695)
Similarly, knitting clubs everywhere are applying for government aid to recruit more men.
Re:Computer science lacks women, minorities by petercooper on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @04:20PM (#811847)
I learned the other day that not a single man under the age of 25 works in a state run nursery in the UK: http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/men/article4... - Even counting the over 25s, there are only 56 men working in nurseries in the entire country.

If women feel unwelcome in areas of computer science (and I know that they do, and don't really judge their feelings on that), men in professions where they have to deal with kids are even more ostracized.. and we don't seem to be dealing with that problem properly either as a society (and I'd argue the men-children issue is more important to society overall).