Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by exDM69 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:56AM
(#8114086)
Formula 1 cars have energy recovery for kinetic energy (regenerative braking) and thermal energy (motor generator unit in turbocharger shaft). Both of these technologies have potential to be used for buses and other heavy vehicles that move in an urban environment.
As an example, my regular bus route is 50% highway at 80 km/h and 50% urban start-stop traffic. The city buses have a huge turbo diesel or natural gas engine, and the turbo takes about 3 seconds to spool up. At 80 km/h, drivers tend to be pumping on and off the throttle, purging the turbo pressure repeatedly. This is horrible for fuel efficiency.
Ideally, an electric motor should do the initial few seconds acceleration, while the turbo is being spooled up using the electric motor attached. When the turbo is spools up, the internal combustion engine should be slowly introduced by adding fuel according to the correct stoichiometric ratio. At cruise speeds, engine power could be regulated by harvesting energy off the turbine rather than pumping the gas pedal which purges the whole turbo.
A city bus should be able to operate at or near optimum stoichiometric conditions at all times, saving a ton of gas and emissions. Currently there's a huge puff of black diesel smoke every time the bus leaves a bus stop.
These are very exciting times for anyone who is interested in motor sports technologies applied to efficient transport.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by fr0sty on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:34AM
(#8114312)
>city bus should be able to operate at or near optimum stoichiometric conditions at all times
Diesel motors operate quite differently than gasoline engines in this regard, actually. A diesel motor is only operating at the correct stoichiometric ratio at full throttle and is running lean for the rest of the time because there is no throttle plate to modulate air intake and power is only modulated by the quantity of fuel injected into the cylinders.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by erjiang on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:22AM
(#8113860)
I just pulled numbers from some of the public transit buses that DoubleMap tracks. I see annual usage of 40k-50k miles on a single bus. Given 2013's diesel prices and standard diesel bus efficiency, that might be about $1/mile, so let's say $50k/yr in fuel for a single bus.
If they claim to save 20% on fuel, then a single bus would save about $10k/yr, and if the system can pay for itself in three years, then it would cost about $30k.
These mileage numbers aren't for London, so that estimate could be off by quite a bit. Still, consider than a standard diesel bus may cost $250k in the US while a hybrid 40' bus could cost $600k,[1] and this looks like a great deal.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by erjiang on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:24AM
(#8113870)
I should add that driving in dense urban areas means fewer miles, lower speed, and more frequent stopping and starting, so the savings in a smaller city would be smaller.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by wlesieutre on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:41AM
(#8113964)
More frequent stopping and starting would actually be an advantage here. If you're driving a long route between bus stops and don't brake frequently, you're only taking energy out of the flywheel when you initially get up to speed, and you're only putting it back in when you stop at the end. Regenerative braking is a lot more valuable in stop and go traffic. Every time you accelerate out of a stop light you're burning less fuel.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by bgarbiak on Thursday July 31, 2014 @01:58PM
(#8115804)
Just a note: the system was never actually used in any Grand Prix. Williams had problems with packaging and weight balance (safety was also a concern). They later followed other teams and settled on battery-based solution. Flywheel had only one significant advantage over these: lower operating costs. That's what makes it feasible for use in public transport, I guess.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by gsnedders on Thursday July 31, 2014 @07:06PM
(#8117519)
The R18 e-tron quattro, now three times winner at Le Mans, actually uses the Williams Hybrid Power flywheel system — so it might not have F1 pedigree, but it certainly has top-level motorsport pedigree.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by InclinedPlane on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:41AM
(#8114354)
Formula 1 was changed recently to encourage development of high efficiency automotive technology. That change has apparently already started to pay off.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by Gravityloss on Thursday July 31, 2014 @12:44PM
(#8115172)
Yes, that's possible. But no technical reasons are presented on why it should happen now - compared to all the false prognoses in the last fifty years or so.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by InclinedPlane on Thursday July 31, 2014 @01:09PM
(#8115400)
Technical problems tend to fall rather more rapidly when billions of dollars in R&D spending is put into play. Just the top 10 Formula 1 teams spend something like $4 billion annually, and now a significant amount of that is being funneled toward research on highly efficient vehicles.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by Guvante on Thursday July 31, 2014 @12:39PM
(#8115128)
My naive assumption would be that implementing flywheels in high performance situations without negatively impacting the engine is difficult.
At least that would be my assumption given the trend of hybrid vehicles and lack of comparable change in larger ones. F1 uses much stronger engines so maybe the tech is more directly usable.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by adolph on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:42AM
(#8113969)
The emergence of kinetic energy storage in the shadow of chemical storage is pretty interesting. Oftentimes I think of progress as moving away from mechanical things and toward electrical solid state things.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by epochwolf on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:52AM
(#8114044)
Jet engines are lined with kevlar to contain engine failures. It usually works. Uncontained engine failures are extremely rare. I'd hope they are using similar technology to prevent flywheel bits from flying outside the bus. Parts around the flywheel container will probably be damaged or destroyed but the container should survive intact.
There's two types of flywheels I'm aware of that are failsafe. The first is a tape flywheel. On failure it unwinds inside the container. The other type is a system where the disk is made of powdered ceramic. In the event of overload it turns to dust.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by valarauca1 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:24AM
(#8113871)
A standard engine is a ~300lb block of iron containing 8-10 fuel air explosions per second. If so much as a piston rod gets over stressed its capable of destructively disassembling itself in a blink of an eye.
A jet turbine rotate at speed in excess of 50k rpm. In the event a blade broke off, it could sale though the outer casing, your body, a cement wall, before you could hear the engine exploding.
Yet... that's perfectly safe. All I'm saying is mechanical engineers are VERY good at their jobs.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by yread on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:07AM
(#8114150)
Sure it's reasonably safe, not perfectly safe.
In diesel engines, if there is a runaway and it isn't stopped the shaft can get overstressed and literally explode.
Jet engines are specially armored not to let any part of the turbine escape the casing in case things go wrong (yet it still happens
http://www.avherald.com/h?search_term=uncontained&opt=0&dose...
quite a lot one might say). And quite a lot of R&D was put into it not happening.
Is there enough R&D being put into the flywheel not failing?
EDIT: my point is that stuff that is OK in a racing car might not necessarily be safe enough to put on a bus or a tram
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by valarauca1 on Thursday July 31, 2014 @11:55AM
(#8114839)
The R&D for a race car (especially an F1) is often far more advanced then that of a buss. In F1 it literally pays to have the best testing equipment, the best labs, etc. F1 prides itself on being as close to the cutting edge as their rules lets them.
The famous saying, "To earn a small fortune in F1 racing, you must first spend a large one." Is very telling of this. F1 isn't done to make F1 go fast, its done to make other cars go.
:.:.:
A standard durability cell for engine testing for a production engine component will typically have a ~20-30 year old sensors, and 15-20 year old data acquisition system.
Motorsport is arguably a latecomer to mechanical batteries, which have been used in vehicular, transport, industrial, and aerospace applications for a long, long time.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by mkohlmyr on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:36AM
(#8114323)
As a personal anecdote I can say that the last few times my home town have upgraded (or attempted to) their fleets of buses and light rail they have quite consistently ended up buying vehicles that cant cope with the harsher winter conditions (I believe the manufacturers were in southern Europe in both cases) and break down.
Add incompetence of local politicians and the far higher cost of renewing together and upgrading existing fleets is probably often a better move. Obviously it isn't an extreme long term solution though.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by NickPollard on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:21AM
(#8113859)
It probably would help, but is also more expensive, and I would expect the bus companies to be quite careful planning their upgrade cycles and end-of-lifing for buses.
Re:F1 Tech Is About to Make Buses More Efficient
by gsnedders on Thursday July 31, 2014 @07:10PM
(#8117532)
And while they often disappear from major cities after about 15 years, they just get handed down to more rural routes where they'll keep going till they die.
As an example, my regular bus route is 50% highway at 80 km/h and 50% urban start-stop traffic. The city buses have a huge turbo diesel or natural gas engine, and the turbo takes about 3 seconds to spool up. At 80 km/h, drivers tend to be pumping on and off the throttle, purging the turbo pressure repeatedly. This is horrible for fuel efficiency.
Ideally, an electric motor should do the initial few seconds acceleration, while the turbo is being spooled up using the electric motor attached. When the turbo is spools up, the internal combustion engine should be slowly introduced by adding fuel according to the correct stoichiometric ratio. At cruise speeds, engine power could be regulated by harvesting energy off the turbine rather than pumping the gas pedal which purges the whole turbo.
A city bus should be able to operate at or near optimum stoichiometric conditions at all times, saving a ton of gas and emissions. Currently there's a huge puff of black diesel smoke every time the bus leaves a bus stop.
These are very exciting times for anyone who is interested in motor sports technologies applied to efficient transport.
Diesel motors operate quite differently than gasoline engines in this regard, actually. A diesel motor is only operating at the correct stoichiometric ratio at full throttle and is running lean for the rest of the time because there is no throttle plate to modulate air intake and power is only modulated by the quantity of fuel injected into the cylinders.
If they claim to save 20% on fuel, then a single bus would save about $10k/yr, and if the system can pay for itself in three years, then it would cost about $30k.
These mileage numbers aren't for London, so that estimate could be off by quite a bit. Still, consider than a standard diesel bus may cost $250k in the US while a hybrid 40' bus could cost $600k,[1] and this looks like a great deal.
[1] http://www.intercitytransit.com/SiteCollectionDocuments/hybr...
There have been long articles about flywheels every now and then, yet you never see them in buses.
http://discovermagazine.com/1996/aug/reinventingthewh842
At least that would be my assumption given the trend of hybrid vehicles and lack of comparable change in larger ones. F1 uses much stronger engines so maybe the tech is more directly usable.
There's two types of flywheels I'm aware of that are failsafe. The first is a tape flywheel. On failure it unwinds inside the container. The other type is a system where the disk is made of powdered ceramic. In the event of overload it turns to dust.
A paper I found online suggests the F1 system uses a powdered ceramic disk: http://136.142.82.187/eng12/Author/data/2097.docx
A jet turbine rotate at speed in excess of 50k rpm. In the event a blade broke off, it could sale though the outer casing, your body, a cement wall, before you could hear the engine exploding.
Yet... that's perfectly safe. All I'm saying is mechanical engineers are VERY good at their jobs.
In diesel engines, if there is a runaway and it isn't stopped the shaft can get overstressed and literally explode.
Jet engines are specially armored not to let any part of the turbine escape the casing in case things go wrong (yet it still happens http://www.avherald.com/h?search_term=uncontained&opt=0&dose... quite a lot one might say). And quite a lot of R&D was put into it not happening.
Is there enough R&D being put into the flywheel not failing?
EDIT: my point is that stuff that is OK in a racing car might not necessarily be safe enough to put on a bus or a tram
The famous saying, "To earn a small fortune in F1 racing, you must first spend a large one." Is very telling of this. F1 isn't done to make F1 go fast, its done to make other cars go.
:.:.:
A standard durability cell for engine testing for a production engine component will typically have a ~20-30 year old sensors, and 15-20 year old data acquisition system.
F1 all components will likely be <5 years.
Motorsport is arguably a latecomer to mechanical batteries, which have been used in vehicular, transport, industrial, and aerospace applications for a long, long time.
Add incompetence of local politicians and the far higher cost of renewing together and upgrading existing fleets is probably often a better move. Obviously it isn't an extreme long term solution though.