News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by rayiner on Sunday July 27, 2014 @07:29PM (#8094352)
The article is wrong on a key point. Stingrays don't "force" your cell phone to do anything. Your cell phone reaches out and connects to it of its own accord. The Stingray doesn't reach out and collect private data from your phone. Your phone transmits your private data into the aether at the user's direction.

I think this fact has major Constitutional implications. The police should not need a warrant to access information that you carelessly broadcast onto the public airwaves. I don't think there is any privacy expectation there, any more than there would be if I took my "papers" out of my desk drawer and threw them out my car window. They're fair game at that point. Though the 11th Circuit disagrees (another example of judges not understanding technology?).

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by nitrogen on Sunday July 27, 2014 @08:31PM (#8094490)
The article is wrong on a key point. Stingrays don't "force" your cell phone to do anything. Your cell phone reaches out and connects to it of its own accord. The Stingray doesn't reach out and collect private data from your phone. Your phone transmits your private data into the aether at the user's direction.

How do you reconcile this techno-literalist interpretation of Stingray with your techno-intentionalist interpretation of the Aereo decisions[0][1]?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7945159 (referring to Aereo's "contrived" business model that is based on a strict view of the technology's function as a really long antenna cable)

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7944271 (referring to Aereo using a "technicality")

[2] Other comments abound, but I didn't want to keep searching.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by rayiner on Sunday July 27, 2014 @08:52PM (#8094553)
The intention of the statute in Aereo is to cover things that act like cable companies. Similarly, the intention of the 4th amendment is to protect information that people try to keep private. Where I think I disagree with many people on HN is whether it is reasonable to believe that information on the internet as it is structured today is private. It simply wasn't designed that way. Our protocols and services leak private data to whoever exercises a little ingenuity in listening to it. Many leak private data by design (data mining for advertising, etc).

In other words, I don't think the folks designing internet technology should get a free ride for 4th amendment purposes, that any internet technology should be considered private regardless of the technical reality. I think you have to concede that data sent in plain text, protocols that don't even try to avoid MITM attacks, services that mine user data, etc, shouldn't receive the same protection as services where real effort is taken to keep data private. I think this is educated by the technology and consistent with the intention of the 4th amendment that the expectation of privacy be objectively reasonable.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by nitrogen on Sunday July 27, 2014 @10:36PM (#8094828)
I think this is educated by the technology and consistent with the intention of the 4th amendment that the expectation of privacy be objectively reasonable.

I thought the expectation of privacy was based on a so-called "reasonable person", not an objective definition of reasonable. Is that not so?

Where I think I disagree with many people on HN is whether it is reasonable to believe that information on the internet as it is structured today is private.

That disagreement seems to be evidence that there is a widespread expectation of privacy, even if the implementation doesn't perfectly preserve privacy.

Especially with regard to the government, I think people could sanely expect privacy to be the default state (even for poorly implemented technology), with narrow exceptions for specific, targeted investigations of small numbers of individuals and well-defined groups.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by tedunangst on Monday July 28, 2014 @12:00AM (#8095103)
> That disagreement seems to be evidence that there is a widespread expectation of privacy,

I think HN at times seriously confuses the concepts of expecting privacy and wanting privacy. Everybody says "I expect this to be private" but if you ask why, it seems the answer is "because I would like it to be private".

I think it would help to sit down and explain exactly why one would expect radio waves being broadcast into space not to be picked up by anyone with a radio. (going back to aereo, was the HN consensus not "if they're transmitting their data into space, anyone with an antenna can do anything they like with it"?)

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by nitrogen on Monday July 28, 2014 @01:03AM (#8095263)
I think HN at times seriously confuses the concepts of expecting privacy and wanting privacy. Everybody says "I expect this to be private" but if you ask why, it seems the answer is "because I would like it to be private".

That should be enough.

I think it would help to sit down and explain exactly why one would expect radio waves being broadcast into space not to be picked up by anyone with a radio.

There are already laws that prohibit listening to certain wireless transmissions (e.g. satellite TV), which I'll assume for the sake this of argument is an acceptable tradeoff to society. While technology should be designed to minimize data leakage, laws should be designed to take user expectations into account.

If, for example, cellphone UX provides every indication to the user that text messages are sent to a person (not to a network), then laws should treat those messages as private until a warrant is issued, even if they are sent in the clear.

...was the HN consensus not "if they're transmitting their data into space, anyone with an antenna can do anything they like with it"?

No, it was "If I can install a very long antenna cable, and/or buy a Slingbox, and watch TV from my home market on my own device, then why can't I pay someone else to run the very long antenna cable and host the Slingbox for me?"

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by rayiner on Monday July 28, 2014 @09:36AM (#8096593)
The "reasonable person" standard is always an objective standard. In the 4th amendment context, it's not enough to have a subjective expectation of privacy--that expectation must be objectively reasonable. This has odd implications in the situation where perhaps the majority of people have a misinformed belief.

For example, 56% of people believe the U.S. spends more than 10% of its budget on foreign aid (the actual number is under 1%): http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/11/07/t.... Is that belief objectively reasonable, just because it is widely held? I think no: you have to look to the facts to determine whether that belief is reasonable.

And what do you see when you look to the facts of the architecture of the internet? Plain text protocols; data routed through untrusted third parties; data aggregated and stored in plain text; highly sensitive data accessible by system operators with often questionable controls;[1] data that's analyzed and mined for commercial purposes, etc. And in the Stingray context: apparently an architecture totally oblivious to MITM attacks. I don't think it's techno-literalist to say that all this makes having an expectation of privacy in the internet, as it is designed today, objectively unreasonable.

> Especially with regard to the government, I think people could sanely expect privacy to be the default state (even for poorly implemented technology)

The 4th amendment doesn't really admit separate standards for the government versus third parties. "Private" doesn't mean "stuff I don't want the government to see" it means "stuff I don't want other people to see." And I think it tortures the definition of "private" to encompass "me and my 500 closest network ops friends at AT&T."

[1] E.g. http://www.digitaltrends.com/computing/google-fires-employee... http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/06/25/facebook-master-pas... etc.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by bmelton on Sunday July 27, 2014 @10:33PM (#8094823)
> that any internet technology should be considered private regardless of the technical reality

I think that there's a pretty bright line distinction between "I read this message you posted on Twitter" and "I set up this fake cell phone tower to intercept the messages you thought you were sending privately through your cell phone carrier."

Similarly, physical locks on doors may be easily circumvented, but that doesn't absolve a burglar of any wrongdoing.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday July 27, 2014 @07:59PM (#8094419)
>Stingrays don't "force" your cell phone to do anything. Your cell phone reaches out and connects to it of its own accord.

A distinction without a difference. That's the nature of the prevailing wireless telephony technology. Users wouldn't be able to receive telephone calls if their equipment didn't coordinate periodically with the cellular system's base stations. Although a system that doesn't constantly leak user's data could conceivably be constructed, that is not what is currently in use. Turning one's phone off to avoid tracking isn't a good solution because then the device has ceased being a telephone.

>Your phone transmits your private data into the aether at the user's direction.

No, nobody directs their phone to 'transmit their private data into the aether' people direct their phones to place and receive telephone calls.

>I think this fact has major Constitutional implications.

I think you're inventing a business case for some group such as Aereo's engineers to form another technology company whose purpose is to engineer around weaknesses in the law.

> The police should not need a warrant to access information that you carelessly broadcast onto the public airwaves.

Telephone calls are private. Nobody would select 'carelessly broadcast my information' in their privacy options. The change in technology doesn't render privacy protections in the law moot.

>I don't think there is any privacy expectation there

I hope you're in the minority.

>(another example of judges not understanding technology?).

Perhaps they've rightly noted that a particular weakness of the technology du jour is unrelated to the individual's legal right to privacy.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by mason240 on Sunday July 27, 2014 @09:18PM (#8094634)
The article initially claims that

>Once these devices connect, the stingray can be used to actually eavesdrop on conversations, text messages, and web browser activity.

Yet further reading shows that "all" it can do is triangulate your position, something no where near actually intercepting data.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday July 27, 2014 @09:23PM (#8094657)
Someone is probably playing fast and loose with terminology. There are apparently a number of optional capabilities.

https://info.publicintelligence.net/Harris-SurveillancePrice...

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/09/meet-the-machines...

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by nitrogen on Sunday July 27, 2014 @10:41PM (#8094840)
I can see why it might be tempting for technologists to create these surveillance technologies -- a single Stingray II is quoted at $148000.
Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by rayiner on Monday July 28, 2014 @03:29PM (#8098853)
> A distinction without a difference.

There is an enormous difference between you reaching out and contacting the outside world, and the police coming into your private space.

> That's the nature of the prevailing wireless telephony technology.

Then the prevailing wireless telephony technology is inherently incompatible with privacy under the 4th amendment.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday July 30, 2014 @02:41PM (#8110153)
>There is an enormous difference between you reaching out and contacting the outside world, and the police coming into your private space.

That's an important point of debate at the moment. I'm happy to report that one state disagrees with you at least WRT e-mail. http://txepc.org/sine-die/

>Then the prevailing wireless telephony technology is inherently incompatible with privacy under the 4th amendment.

Actually it's not all that different from a POTS from the perspective that there are plenty of exploitable weaknesses in those systems as well; yet, despite despite weaknesses that would allow similar technological solutions to provide police with unencrypted telephone traffic, we've managed to keep a statutory barrier between police and our private conversations when they are held on a POTS.

If I understand you correctly, your argument basically boils down to "When it becomes physically possible for police to eavesdrop on communications, they ought to be allowed to do so at will."

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by gwillen on Sunday July 27, 2014 @07:37PM (#8094366)
If you lie to someone in order to induce them to give you valuable private information, that's fraud, not "information you carelessly broadcast". If a Stingray says "Hi, I'm a cell tower, connect to me!" that's not at all the same as mere passive recording.

(Now, mind you, mere passive recording of cellphones without a warrant is _also_ an illegal search as far as I know -- or would be if there were still unencrypted data to passively record. But that's totally unrelated to what a Stingray does.)

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by ams6110 on Sunday July 27, 2014 @09:10PM (#8094612)
Law enforcement are permitted to lie to get private information, e.g. in an interrogation. They would need to have at least probable cause if not a warrant to conduct that interrogation though.
Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by baddox on Sunday July 27, 2014 @09:26PM (#8094666)
I also don't think that law enforcement should be permitted to lie to get private information.
Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by mentat on Monday July 28, 2014 @02:30PM (#8098517)
"Should" and "are" are different in this case.
Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by bmelton on Sunday July 27, 2014 @07:38PM (#8094368)
Semantically, it could really go either way. If I 'carelessly' broadcast a letter via the US Postal Service to my grandmother in Hawaii, I have no way of ensuring that its secrets will be preserved in the long journey between my house and it destination.

Similarly, if someone forged a USPS mailbox, placed in front of the post office, and I 'carelessly' dropped my letter in, then by your interpretation, I am a damned fool.

This isn't an area where I'm particularly savvy, but if a private citizen were to stand up one of these mailboxes, it would be a federal crime. I understand that the corollary is not identical, and I agree that it's hard to parallel technologies to their real-world counterparts, but if a private citizen set up one of these towers, they too would be charged with some kind of wire fraud.

In the absence of a warrant, I see no reason the government should have any elevated privileges here.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by andylei on Sunday July 27, 2014 @07:44PM (#8094377)
the courts have usually interpreted the fourth amendment based on the effects of technology, not the mechanisms of technology. they don't have to understand how stingrays work, they only have to understand what impact stingrays have on your freedom from search.

that's why the court ruled that thermal imaging (in kyllo v us) is a search. sure, the mechanism of the technology is that you're carelessly broadcasting your heat signature through the airwaves, but the effect is the same as if the police had entered the home - they can see inside it.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by Zigurd on Sunday July 27, 2014 @07:49PM (#8094392)
It is a distinction without a difference. Stingray becomes part of the mobile network. That's what enables your phone to connect to it. Your analogy is ridiculous. Throwing your papers out your car is clearly an unusual act. Your phone is behaving to spec when connecting to a Stingray.

It's disturbing how some educated people can excuse a police state. It worse than the police themselves because they ought to know better what the dangers are.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by girvo on Sunday July 27, 2014 @09:30PM (#8094678)
> They're fair game at that point. Though the 11th Circuit disagrees (another example of judges not understanding technology?).

While I respect the fact that you have a different opinion of a lot of those here on HN, I think that perhaps the 11th Circuit disagreeing isn't a case of them not understand technology, but understand the implications of the technology and the law surrounding it. The 4th amendment as written probably doesn't cover things like phone-calls, and I agree that the internet as it stands isn't particularly conducive to keeping your private information private. However, with the fact that our entire lives are lived online at this point in 2014, I think it's a good thing that the 11th Circuit is looking at this holistically, as frankly I'd rather the spirit of privacy is kept. I'm also a big believer in building technology so that privacy isn't even a question, but merely a consequence of using it -- but as it stands today, everyone in the country is leaking their information everywhere and don't have much of a choice in the matter unless they're willing to leave society entirely, or join the Amish.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by ceejayoz on Sunday July 27, 2014 @07:36PM (#8094364)
> I don't think there is any privacy expectation there, any more than there would be if I took my "papers" out of my desk drawer and threw them out my car window.

Isn't this a bit more like the cops replacing your trash can with a scanner, though?

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by harryh on Sunday July 27, 2014 @09:05PM (#8094596)
Collecting your trash can and inspecting the contents isn't a 4th amendment violation.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_v._Greenwood

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by mikeash on Sunday July 27, 2014 @09:23PM (#8094656)
This implies that private use of a system like Stingray should be legal and completely fair game. I somehow doubt the government would agree with that.
Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by larrys on Sunday July 27, 2014 @07:52PM (#8094400)
"I don't think there is any privacy expectation there"

I think the expectation of a typical cell phone user would be that there are not people other than phone companies for the purpose of providing service slurping up data from their cell phones. Same way I don't expect the kitchen at a restaurant to tell the world what meal I have ordered.

"The police should not need a warrant to access information that you carelessly broadcast onto the public airwaves."

Isn't this similar to the problems that people have with being tracked in retail stores? And for that matter what is the legal difference between the police collecting certain data and, say, a business person collecting that data? And perhaps selling it to the police? (Question not a statement).

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by rhino369 on Sunday July 27, 2014 @10:59PM (#8094923)
Your definition of privacy expectation isn't accurate. For example, you have absolutely no expectation of privacy in what meal you ordered at a restaurant.

>Isn't this similar to the problems that people have with being tracked in retail stores?

You can be tracked in a retail store too.

>And for that matter what is the legal difference between the police collecting certain data and, say, a business person collecting that data? And perhaps selling it to the police? (Question not a statement).

Anything you willfully disclose to a third party is no longer private, with very few exceptions like medical records.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by DSMan195276 on Sunday July 27, 2014 @07:57PM (#8094415)
I agree with you on most of it, but I'm not convinced it's as clear as you say it is. Depending on how this works it may be much more like handing your 'papers' to someone dressed up like a Verizon representative with all the proper paper-work to prove it, but actually happens to be a police officer undercover who isn't going to deliver your papers at all.

IMO, the difference in my opinion depends on whether it's just collecting data you were sending out anyway, or if it's pretending to be a cell tower from a specific company and attempting to get your phone to send-out data it normally wouldn't have done.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by maxlybbert on Monday July 28, 2014 @12:04AM (#8095115)
Based on the discussion in Kyllo v the United States ( http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyllo_v._United_States ), (1) the justices appear to ask "is this sportsmanlike behavior?" when deciding whether a warrant is needed, and (2) the official line is "does the general public believe the police have the power in question?"

It seems to me that this currently would be struck down under Kyllo, but that if the police make a big deal about their new tool, they could eventually use it without a warrant.

Re:Stingray, the fake cell phone tower by indrax on Sunday July 27, 2014 @08:37PM (#8094516)
Then they are sending signals to my computer system (phone) in order to gain access to information without authorization.

Do you think you are free to do that?