Okay. But then you shouldn't really call oneself a CEO.
"OMG look we're so HAWT, we're co-founders after all, not gutless employees, and we're only in our 20s, doing all these amazing things, and we have this cool office and all these smart, hip people working for us.. and umm, budgets? due diligence? CPAs? What are those?"
The general sense I got from the story was: We were young and stupid, but instead of doing drugs, we convinced VCs to give us $3.8 million, which made us believe that we knew what we were doing.
At least, you should.
Try not paying your Comcast or Verizon bill on time for a month or two and see what happens. The envelope only starts coming in red after quite a few fees are tacked on.
[EDIT: Don't actually try that :) ]
And if you don't have visceral awareness of this fact -- you shouldn't be hiring people, and handing out salaries.
In any company, someone's responsible for the books (whether it's the CEO, some other employee, or an outsourced accountant), and you would think that the bank statements would be reconciled with the general ledger more than once a year. At the very least, it would have been done with each fiscal year end.
That the unpaid payroll taxes weren't noticed for almost three years is mind boggling to me.
Hey, it happens, oh ye wise and holy one!
Screwing up payroll tax withholding for employees is financial catastrophe. You've taken money from your employees on behalf of the government, but then kept it. Your liability in that case can be criminal, maybe even if you didn't deliberately defraud the government.
So, those two cases are not comparable.
It happens to a lot of people but certainly not to everybody.
As a rule of thumb in the first two years you simply want to reserve 50% of your gross until you get a better handle on what your deductibles are and what it is that you exactly owe and then you can slowly home in on the correct amount to reserve. Too many variables to get closer but 50% should cover all but the most extreme cases.
Simply open a savings account and park that 50% there right after you invoice. If you're invoicing with GST/VAT/whatever it is called where you live then you get to subtract out the VAT first, then do the 50%, then add all the VAT back in and save that.
I think a lot of people assume they can put off getting an accountant until they're sure the business is serious. Which is probably why so many of the stories I've heard (and, to add to that, my own story) are about the tax screwup consequences of those first couple gigs you do before you formalize the company.
Getting an accountant is your first major purchase as a new business owner.
And getting a good one is not all that easy. I lucked out, the one I ended up with (after trying two others) was a CFO of a large company that decided he had enough of the pressure and joined his wife's fledgling accounting company.
So instead of just having an accountant I ended up with a mentor to boot, all for the price of one.
This thing about not noticing that you weren't paying payroll taxes wasn't a "mistake." It was pure head-in-assery.
How can you "miss" the fact that you weren't being subtracted for payroll taxes? One quarterly / annual review after another, for 3 years? It's like running a personal budget, and "missing" the fact that you aren't paying rent.