News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by instakill on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:46PM (#8075722)
I've always found it peculiar that Americans have to pay to receive SMS's or incoming calls.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by nhaehnle on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:49PM (#8075749)
They even have to pay for incoming SMS?

I understand the justification of paying for incoming calls, since they don't have separate prefix codes for mobile (which means that the caller does not know they're calling a mobile, and therefore you cannot put the charge on the caller), but incoming SMS, where you don't even get a choice over whether you want to receive it? "Peculiar" is putting that very nicely...

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by k-mcgrady on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:51PM (#8075761)
That sounds like it could be abused really easily. Can any Americans confirm if this is true that you have to pay to receive an SMS?
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by adsfasdf23f23f on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:07PM (#8075899)
Yes. We used to get charged $0.25 per text with Verizon. Occasionally we would get included on a group text that would create 30 some replies that we would receive. I was not happy.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by Jtsummers on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:00PM (#8075843)
It's true. $0.10 or $0.15 is my cost for all texts over 200 whether I send or receive them. Usually I don't go over, on average maybe 1-3 extra messages a month over 200. Upgrading to the unlimited tier for $15/month more doesn't make sense when I can reach all my friends but a few via Facebook, Google Talk or iMessages on their mobile devices. I can reach all my friends via one of those if they're on a computer but that's not always convenient, and no one I know uses twitter except to follow people.

  * With AT&T
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by pasbesoin on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @03:04PM (#8076304)
Yes... until smartphone IM support finally offered competition that started to squash this particular aspect of price gouging.

Many people still "pay" for SMS. When we had outrageous per SMS charges (yes, also for incoming messages), carriers started to offer "bulk" -- e.g. 1000 messages per billing cycle -- plans and then "ulimited" SMS plans, typically for $30, $20, eventually $10 / month extra.

Now, more an more plans included "unlimited SMS". Not all, though, and total monthly bills that include such "unlimited SMS" vary widely. One also has to remain aware / beware of international SMS messages, where one's plan may still charge exorbitant per message fees.

P.S. Back in the days of high charges, just be so lucky as to end up on the receiving end of messages from some romantic interest who thinks your phone number is their interest's number. Obnoxious, perhaps crass messages, and to boot you're paying for the "privilege" of receiving them. (Fortunately, the carrier's limited blocking options sufficed to squelch those when he wouldn't believe I wasn't her.)

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by throwaway234 on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:41PM (#8076144)
I can confirm it can be abused really easily. Back in middle school (2006? 2007 maybe?) me and my friends used a firefox macro addon and a free anonymous text website to send a few hundred vulgar texts to a girl that one of us had recently broken up with.

The next day at school one of us got called into the office. The girl's parents had hired a private investigator to find out who sent the texts. My friend denied everything and there was no real evidence so no one got caught (turns out these types of shenanigans are NOT okay, and illegal).

We had racked up her phone bill into over-usage rates and I'm not sure if the carrier dropped the charges we had produced or whether her parents had to pay. I can't imagine that night's incoming text cost being below $200.

But now I believe most teenage girls in the US have unlimited texting.

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by ADent on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:46PM (#8076173)
Yes, I still pay by the SMS. AT&T wants $20/month for unlimited SMS ($30/for all phones on my account). They used to offer $5 & $10 plans, but dropped those options.

It is nice to be able to iMessage w/other iPhone users.

My wife is on a pay as you go (prepaid) plan and each SMS counts as a minute.

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by klipt on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:59PM (#8075837)
Yes, but it's illegal to send unsolicited texts and there's a government website where you can report spammers.

Also most plans now have unlimited texts (to send or receive). I only paid for texts when I was on the cheapest possible pay-as-you-go plan.

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by daigoba66 on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @03:19PM (#8076386)
Yes. However practically speaking no one who uses SMS really pays per message anymore. It's usually bought in packages (200 a month, 400 a month, etc), or unlimited.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by sologoub on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:58PM (#8075831)
Most cell phones come with some sort of messaging plan, but historically yes you had to pay.

The routing inbound calls you typically have to pay, but the costs are usually so negligible, most VoIP/landline provides include them for free with the overall subscription.

Cell phones are a different story all together.

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by mikestew on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:57PM (#8075822)
Pretty sure AT&T charged for incoming text messages. It's been a while since I've looked at an AT&T bill (I've since switched), so it's possible that I'm mistaken, but I'd give that statement an 85% confidence rating.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by jonknee on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:59PM (#8075834)
Yes, but unlimited SMS plans are quite common and have been so for years.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by chaosmonkey on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:58PM (#8075832)
Can confirm. When I moved to the US, had to pay for incoming SMS. My friends who did not have an unlimited SMS plan, had SMS completely blocked so that they don't receive unwanted messages.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by pkaye on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:12PM (#8075924)
Yes you do get charged for incoming calls and text. However most wireless carriers are now pushing plans with unlimited talk, text and data.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by tinbad on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:29PM (#8076063)
I don't know anyone who gets charged for receiving SMS in 2014 (and it has been like that at least since 2011 when I came to the US). All the plans I had (Verizon, AT&T, T-mobile) had free unlimited SMS (sending & receiving). I live in the bay area so maybe it's not like that in other parts of the country.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by Someone1234 on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:34PM (#8076101)
> free unlimited SMS

Free ay? So you can pay them $0/month and send/receive text messages? No? It is actually over $100/month? Is that "free?"

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by Swizec on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:51PM (#8076209)
I pay $60/month for 3gb of LTE with T-Mobile and get unlimited texting and calling on top of that. I don't particularly care about the texting or calling so I consider it free. I'd pay the $60 just for the internet.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by heywire on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:56PM (#8075812)
Most definitely. That said, most carriers have started including unlimited SMS in their packages.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by mgkimsal on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:58PM (#8075827)
by "including" you mean "charging extra", right?
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by jcurbo on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:08PM (#8075907)
Yes, is it an extra surcharge for the unlimited plans. Typically you have a few packages to choose from, e.g. 100, 250, 500, unlimited per month.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by Someone1234 on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:33PM (#8076094)
ATT charges $20/month + tax for unlimited texting alone. Which is about £12. For £12 (inc. tax) on GiffGaff in the UK you get:

- 250 minutes Calling

- Unlimited texts

- Unlimited Internet (no tethering, or £10 w/1 GB and tethering)

So Americas get massively screwed on their wireless services. The fact that tons of people on here are praising the insanely expensive "Unlimited" texting offers is just bonkers.

For the cost of just your unlimited texting in the US you can pay your entire monthly cellphone bill in the UK, consider that. And due to tax, surcharges, etc the $20/month is actually closer to $30/month.

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by Jtsummers on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:39PM (#8076134)
T-Mobile has a $30/month pre-paid plan with 100 minutes, unlimited text, unlimited data (unsure about tethering). I really wanted to like the plan and tested it out in my area with a Nexus 4 I picked up for playing around with an Android phone (only had iPhones the past few years, so wanted it for both development and to see if it was practical for me to switch). Unfortunately the coverage sucked once I left the area since they didn't offer data roaming. Great along the interstate, terrible in the country (I often take the scenic routes when traveling long distances if I'm not in a rush, I hate driving on the interstate.). If I lived in an area with really good T-mobile coverage and primarily traveled to those sorts of areas it'd be an awesome plan, and similar in cost to what you're talking about.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by mgkimsal on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @11:57PM (#8078155)
it's part of the reason i dropped out of the major player market (AT&T, etc) and have moved to a second tier provider (in my case, net10). my bill is 50% of what it was for essentially the same service (minus visual voicemail on my iPhone, but it's not worth $600+/year to me).

unlimited internet (throttled at 2.5gig/month), unlimited text, unlimited minutes. $45/month = £26. Not perfect, but livable.

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by nknighthb on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @03:22PM (#8076407)
No, all four major providers have included unlimited text in their standard post-paid plans for a while now. If you're still on a legacy plan, you might not be aware of this.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by rogerbinns on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:58PM (#8075829)
There are very good reasons (for calls anyway), and arguably the rest of the world is broken. I wrote about it here http://www.rogerbinns.com/blog/paying-for-incoming-calls.htm...

In short it is to with termination rates, area codes, and how people in the rest of the world get screwed but don't realise it.

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by Someone1234 on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:46PM (#8076171)
In the UK if it starts with 07 it is to a mobile and if it starts with 01-03 it is to a landline. How very complicated!

Plus doesn't the US have hidden rates too? If I call someone on a landline and they're in the same city I pay less than if I call someone two cities over even though the two MIGHT have the same exact area code ("long distance").

> Cellular was easily rolled out without disruption. An existing number could switch to cellular and no one else would have to know or care. If you were a business (eg a plumber) you didn't have to worry about people calling you fretting over getting charged more for the call than your competitors.

> Numbers are easily portable. You can switch any number to use cellular. Countries using the other scheme can have portability but usually it is limited to cellular area codes only.

That's a non-issue. Call forwarding exists outside the US too(!). You can buy generic numbers, or a landline that forwards to your cellphone (or rings at both).

But ultimately your entire argument is defeated by one fact: In the US when a telemarketer calls you YOU pay for the pleasure. You're literally paying for people to spam or hassle you.

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by rogerbinns on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @03:32PM (#8076460)
(BTW I am a Brit, but have lived in the US for ~15 years).

The UK is also complicated - eg if a number starts with 08.

There aren't hidden rates. You are applying a British mentality - that the area code defines an area. In the US it is the exchange numbers (next 3 digits after the area code). It used to be normal to not dial area codes. I got bitten by this exact issue the first time I made a "local" call from a hotel, arguing with the front desk that a call to the same area code is by definition the same (local) area.

There are actually 3 distances - local, local toll, and long distance. You can actually have a different carrier for each one! For example local is a few miles around, local toll would be 20-100 miles away, and long distance after that. (Americans like things complicated.) When I had a land line it was about 5 times as much to call San Francisco (~60 miles away) than New York (~2,000 miles away)!

Local calls are included with your service price, also called "free" by people. However the base service price was about four times what I paid in the UK. There was a wonderful paper I saw years ago and haven't been able to find again, where they showed that Americans preferred fixed pricing - ie you know in advance what your bill will be - versus a pay as you go model. Not only that they are willing to pay more for the certainty of those future bills.

The issue you are thinking of is that the termination rates in some rural areas are very high in order to subsidise providing the service there. Consequently various "free" conference calls and similar services are sourced out of those areas. The rural telco then shares the revenue. The caller's telco ends up paying for the increased rates - it isn't visible to the caller. This is why there is some weasel language in various phone contracts saying they won't connect you to those numbers/services.

Call forwarding isn't a perfect solution. It still requires the cooperation of two companies - the one with the number, and the one where the number is forwarded to.

The argument isn't defeated as such - rather the US had no option than to go the way it did. Call prices are very cheap when adding together what the caller and recipient pay, compared to the rest of the world where some of it is hidden and regulators have stepped in setting rates rather than there being meaningful competition.

Telemarketers aren't allowed to call cell phones. Obviously that won't just stop them, but since they are actually trying to sell something and they need to contact a reasonable volume of people to have success, it is a lot easier for them to be detected and blocked by the carriers. I get about one telemarketer call a year. I could also contact my carrier and they would remove charges for telemarketing calls.

The majority of cellular and landline plans now are unlimited voice calls in any direction, so most of the earlier issues aren't present any more.

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by MichaelGG on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @03:02PM (#8076282)
The US is FULL of hidden rates! In fact, you can make a huge killing exploiting these things, and a lot people do exactly that. Some areas in the US cost multiple cents per minute. There is no such such as a flat rate to the US. People sell it, but they're just hoping you call cheap places, and if you don't, they cut you off. It surprises me how few people can do that math and love paying a flat rate.

That's why so many free conference call places were in Iowa. They were exploiting the 5 cent tariffs Iowa had published in combination with people expecting all of the US to cost the same. Big carriers stopped terminating the calls, but the FCC slapped them back and insisted they had to terminate such calls.

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by rogerbinns on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @03:51PM (#8076576)
This is called traffic pumping. Wikipedia has the details https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_pumping
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by Jtsummers on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @03:10PM (#8076333)
> Plus doesn't the US have hidden rates too? If I call someone on a landline and they're in the same city I pay less than if I call someone two cities over even though the two MIGHT have the same exact area code ("long distance").

Landline to landline, yes. This got me when we moved back to Georgia 14 years ago. Friends in the 229 area code that lived 50 miles away in one direction, local, 50 miles in another, long distance.

However, for cellular (now) you pay by minutes, and, as far as I can tell, unless you're hitting 900 numbers or similar, a minute is a minute, local or long distance. I have never had my own landline so I don't know the current status there, and most people I know with one only use it for security systems (so they can get away with the cheapest $10 or $20/month plan with no long distance).

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by tzs on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @08:30PM (#8077699)
> That's a non-issue. Call forwarding exists outside the US too(!). You can buy generic numbers, or a landline that forwards to your cellphone (or rings at both)

How does that work from the caller's point of view in caller-pays systems? Does the caller pay the landline rate (because he called a landline), and then the owner of the landline pays the cellphone rate for the forwarding from the landline to the cellphone?

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by techsupporter on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @04:04PM (#8076655)
I think that "get screwed" is a bit harsh. Mobile operators in Europe (and in Ireland, specifically, where I have the most experience) cheerfully sell you unlimited voice and SMS bundles, just like in the States. I have a Meteor number ("area code" 085) that can call any other mobile Irish number for exactly 0.00EUR/minute and it costs me 20EUR/month, or 10EUR if all I want to do is talk and use pay-per-use rates for data and text. Heck, 30EUR will get me all of the above for a zero-rate.

It all comes down to the system you're used to. I'm used to the US system so it seems "odd" that I pay to make a call in Europe. Then again, with a mobile phone in the States that doesn't have unlimited SMS or voice, I pay to originate the voice or text contact all the same, _and_ the recipient pays, too. Know what numbers plumbers advertise on the side of their vans in Ireland? Mobile numbers, readily identified when starting with 083-089.

Number portability is, simply, what it is. Initially, number portability in the States was only allowed between wireless numbers until years later when WLNP was allowed. Even then, you could only port numbers between carriers with facilities in the same area/local code. It's only been in the past six years or so that nationwide, wireless number porting has been a reliable thing and only really because cellular systems in the States have grown so large with so many regional ratecenter connections. Landline number porting still takes almost two weeks with some carriers, if it even works.

Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by rogerbinns on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @04:43PM (#8076847)
By "get screwed" I meant the total charges for a call - ie adding together what the callers and recipients pay. The callers can't avoid the charges, and aren't a customer of the recipient's carrier. This means there is little competitive pressure to lower the termination rates, and ultimately regulators have stepped in. It is far preferable that rates automatically dropped as a result of competition.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by meritt on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @01:51PM (#8075766)
It's not all carriers and the vast majority of people simply pay for unlimited plans so it's a non-issue.
Re:Announcing Free Incoming SMS For All by richardw on Thursday July 24, 2014 @02:09AM (#8078352)
It might be a holdover from "car phones", where incoming calls were charged for. Very few had them and it could be assumed that the owner had enough cash to pay for the privilege.

IIRC the US had some version of cell phones before e.g. Europe, so probably kept the same business models. The rest of the world was able to rethink the model and with the benefits of hindsight, created cell-specific phone numbers and were able to charge callers rather than phone owners the extra portion.