Amazon has for decades been one of the most pro-consumer companies out there. The publishers have been slapped in court for trying to collude to raise prices. In fact, the whole source of this dispute is that Hachette wants the option to charge more for its books on Amazon.
So on the one hand, we have a company that wants us to pay more for the same product. And on the other hand we have a company that, while large in the ecosystem, is by no means a monopoly (maybe it is a monopsony, but even that is someone questionable considering they only have a 65% share of the market), and wants to charge us less. You can always buy the publishers' books from a different store if Amazon won't sell them. Well, if it weren't for the DRM the publishers originally insisted on, you could.
Hrm. Well, I know where I stand on this.
65% of distribution volume is more than enough to practice monopolistic practices, especially if the industry is hurting.
I'm not necessarily against traditional publishers disappearing, but it would be nice to have a more diversified spread when it comes to the surviving distribution channels
This is why free software like Apache and Linux is so important. However big Amazon gets, as long as other companies, however small, have the necessary technology to provide similar services and the option to scale operations with increased business, Amazon has to offer superior services and prices to stay competitive. Book publishers, on the other hand, use specialized factories and distribution networks to throw their power around. With commoditized servers, free software, and an open Internet, Amazon can't leverage those same unique advantages.
On top of that, you need a way to reach customers online. The brand is sticky enough that many people start their book search directly on Amazon. To get a chance to compete for that search (presumably on Google) you'll need to hope that they find the price outrageous enough to overcome the promise of a convenient and reliable next-day delivery, pre-configured shipping and billing, etc.
Lastly Amazon is working hard to move the battle away from the open web: once a customer has a Kindle, the bar is even higher to compete for their future purchases.
With digital distribution, you can guarantee that everything you're selling is always available for free (with the risk of legal fines) from other channels. Companies like Spotify, Netflix, and Amazon's digital distribution are aware that they are competing with free and tailor their services to be worth the cost. Physical goods that require factories and distribution centers will be a barrier to entry for a long time, at least until commodity 3d printers can compete with large-scale factories, which will take some time.
I want to live in a world where the creators set their own prices and reap the most benefits.
By silicon valley computer-nerd salary standards, advances are... very small amounts of money. Like not even a nice car amounts of money.
the same goes for printing a few thousand copies of a book. And amazon will ship for you, if that's what you want.
Advertising is hard - and getting it into stores that aren't online-only is also hard
but discounting those two aspects? your average silicon-valley computer nerd could drive an older ford rather than a new car that is more appropriate to his or her station and use the difference to publish a book. It's not something that requires a huge amount of money.
My point, though, is that if you really feel strongly that the publishing houses aren't adding value, you can do this right now. If you are a silicon valley computer nerd, you don't even need investors or other people's permission. Hell, you don't even have to come up with more than the advance until the book is done.
i find it hard to believe that 1) amazon would violate contracts on something like that or 2) if they did, hachette would somehow suffer financially, but not notice, or be unable to do anything about it.
The hurdle, as always, is layer 8.
No it isn't. It's like demanding a copy of master for a CD or DVD.
The correct future is many printing businesses competing with each other, many logistics and shipping companies competing with each other, all separate and competing amongst themselves for the business of both content creators and content consumers. It doesn't work right if authors are 'vendor locked' into Amazon's printing and distribution network, it needs to be a many-to-many printers-to-distributors network with healthy competition for the "right future".
If you want to buy a book they publish, you are a click away from bying it from http://www.barnesandnoble.com/ or from Apple if you want it on your ipad.
But if Amazon wants to sell it they have no choice but to get it from the conglomerate Hachette.
My favorite comment on this so far comes from Hugh Howey (author of the WOOL series)at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/hugh-howey/winning-at-monopoly...
From that article.
“The real monopoly, once you start examining business practices and attitudes, is Big Publishing itself,”
"Where is the outcry for Amazon-published authors who are blocked from sale by practically every brick and mortar store? It doesn't exist. The response is simply: That's what those authors get for signing with Amazon. Imagine an observer today saying, "That's what those authors get for signing with Hachette." The hypocrisy astounds."