These $1.5M single family homes (and those would be far lower than the median in many towns around here) tend to be owned by double-income professionals or long-standing owners paying pennies on the dollar in property taxes who have little incentive to sell. On the higher end, I've seen folks with significant liquidity events who no longer rely on income move to Palo Alto or Woodside, or perhaps Los Altos or Portola Valley, but then you're talking $5M+ and over 4,000 ft^2 and possibly a guest house or pool house too.
In my neighborhood there's a CEO at a funded sensor chip startup whose wife works at a large tech company, a physician married to another professional, an investment banker whose spouse doesn't work, some Stanford faculty married to other professionals, a partner at a major Silicon Valley law firm, and some retirees. The retirees are often paying around 1/20th what I do in property taxes -- less than what they'd pay if they were to move to Florida or Nevada, I imagine.
To try to answer your question more directly, if you're buying a $1.5M place and putting 20% down, Zillow says you can afford the resulting mortgage on a $265K/year salary: http://www.zillow.com/mortgage-calculator/house-affordabilit...
That seems like a stretch to me, but if it's accurate and banks believe it, you could get a mortgage on that $1.5M house if each person is making $140K a year or thereabouts. Hope it doesn't need repairs or remodeling!
BTW, Zillow uses 36% debt ratio which is like the absolute max that you can possibly get mortgage (i.e. worse case scenario). That kind of debt ratio only makes sense for incomes > $250K. Once you can take out $10K as your monthly expenses, rest you can pour in to mortgage. With that calculation $260K income + $500K downpayment would allow you to live in 1.5M house without cutting too many corners. The downpayment can come in from previous house ownership gains or from equity stakes. This is probably not a good idea because you are in essence investing in already overpriced assets. There is no doubt that pressure is going to continue and bubble can only blow up so much.
I'm no housing bull, but this is simply not true.
Even after NYC was established, everything north of Wall Street (where there was a wall) was farmland.
So this means a nurse and dental hygienist couple earns a family income of about 230K a year. They probably aren't buying in palo alto, but they aren't priced out of other nice suburbs. The sad thing is that most of the high salary is dumped into the housing market (and child care, which can be 25k per kid, which becomes a huge issue when you need two incomes). I guess it all depends on how much you love living here (if you have the right setup, it actually is pretty incredible, but you truly do pay).
It's not easy, but you don't have to scratch your head and wonder "who are these people". A two income middle class couple is in striking distance.
Of course this may not all be attributable to high cost of living, taking a look at the BLS page on RN wages across the country, high RN salaries and states with strong union laws seem to run hand in hand.
I can't stand dual income. I can't stand commutes now, either. That's why I left the bay area last year.
San Jose, East Palo Alto, parts of Redwood City, Pacifica, etc...
The parts of those places you listed that I can (could) afford, I wouldn't live due to various problems like crime, neglect, etc. They aren't really a good choice for normal, simple people like me.
I think most people aren't there by choice, but by necessity. I'd much rather have the people watching my kids in a spot by choice than necessity. You may ask why that would matter, but given a little thought it'll matter you as well.
What's the hierarchy of the upper-upper end neighborhoods?
It's not as much a hierarchy as different areas appealing to different types of people and families, with a big property size/walkability dividing line being I-280.
Let's say you have the nice problem of spending $10M+ on a house. If you want acreage and multiple guest houses and privacy and your own vineyard and stable, you might end up west of the 280 in Woodside off of Whiskey Hill Road. This is the Larry Ellison, Steve Jobs (Jackling House), Thomas Siebel, and Gordon Moore approach. Trivia: I was talking to a general contractor last week who said Gordon Moore's home upgrades/maintenance on his estate in a private valley on the north end of Woodside kept his business afloat during the 2008 downturn. If you want significant acreage, you'll need to budget tens of millions.
But in Woodside you don't get very much within walking or horseback distance, except Roberts Market/Bucks/Woodside Cafe. If you prefer the south bay with even less within walking distance, you might end up in Los Altos Hills or the hills overlooking Saratoga or Los Gatos. Portola Valley is another option.
If you want a 10,000+ ft^2 estate behind walls close to El Camino, you choose Atherton. If you want to be able to commute to SF and don't mind cooler weather, you choose Hillsborough. If you want to walk to a thriving downtown area with excellent restaurants, you (likely) lose the walls and gates and buy a more modest house for the same price in Palo Alto. The Palo Alto approach is what some Google and eBay executives have done, what Steve Jobs did in addition to the Jackling House, and what Tim Cook reportedly has done.
Proposition 13?
- They bought their house fifty years ago when everything was peach orchards
- Split the apartment as many ways as mattresses will fit on the floor
What about Hayward or East Palo Alto? Or Oakland? I thought there was still plenty of cheap land in the Bay Area, but people all want to live in the ritzy bits.
Maybe that's OK, I suppose, but in this case it has meant finding a place to rent is very difficult.
There's lots of vacant land on the SF peninsula, but no cheap land. There is cheaper land (not the same as cheap land), as you say, in the east bay, but the non-SF tech jobs tend to be on the peninsula or south bay.
BTW, this is the first time that I've heard Belmont or San Mateo or Redwood City being described as "ritzy." :)
Around here (northern European capital), salaries are lower than the US counterparts. I would say a fairly qualified job in IT earns you around $100k (yearly, before all taxation). Houses cost around $1M outside town.
Even people with less qualified jobs buys at these prices. I would have expected $1.5M to be affordable with Silicon Valley salaries. I wonder if interest rates are that much higher in the US..?
It seems like real estate prices are increasing rapidly in every major city around the world. I hear the same story from London, Sydney, SF etc.
BTW, I would take that 50 year and 30 year fixed mortgage term any day. 30 year fixed at 4.4% seems like extremely good offer from this side of the fence.
Most of the people I know who have bought real estate recently are scraping by and using their basement apartments as mortgage helpers. Another issue I have noticed is the lax standards in issuing mortgages, there are companies writing employment letters for $1-2k in order for couples to qualify for mortgages. Banks and government is wising up but the damage has already been done.
It appears to be: force the industry to move somewhere else.
Whether that's a good plan or not is moot. Decades of votes have underscored it repeatedly. That the situation is unsustainable seems to be the entire point.
I'm increasingly surprised people still insist on the region. I'd have thought more companies would have moved on by now.
It seems to me this is a cyclical issue. I'm guessing something major has to happen like the market crashes again, or the tech bubble bursts. This would make a lot of these high rent places either have to lower their rent, or go out of business.
Once they lower their rent, I'm sure more middle income people will move back into the city. This of course does not solve the affordable housing issue. As is the case in most gentrification situations, it just pushes lower income people out into the outer burbs, and this is already happening. I don't see any solution for more affordable housing. It seems this war has already been lost.
Or, multiple people sharing a place.
It's more than I wanted to pay initially, but 4k minimum seems like a bald-faced lie.
Pre tax income: 41666/month
20% Down = $300000 Borrow 1.2M @ 4.0% = $5728.98/mo
This looks quite doable.
Heck, with half that income, you could do it!
I just moved away from the Bay Area for this exact reason. I went from making $120k a year to $85k a year, but in Washington I can get a decent family home for $150k. The Bay Area can't come remotely close to matching that kind of deal, even with the ludicrous salaries.
[0] http://i.imgur.com/bdgZa.jpg, http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142412788732368960...
Neither is Manhattan. From the NYT in 2009, and prices for schools and child care and real estate have only gone up since then:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/08/fashion/08halfmill.html "Five hundred thousand dollars — the amount President Obama wants to set as the top pay for banking executives whose firms accept government bailout money — seems like a lot, and it is a lot. To many people in many places, it is a princely sum to live on. But in the neighborhoods of New York City and its suburban enclaves where successful bankers live, half a million a year can go very fast."
A lot of this is real estate and private schools, of course. You could get a 5br/5,000 ft^2 house in Green Bay, Wisconsin for 400K: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/3318-Whittier-Ct-Green-Bay...
While a 5br/5,000 ft^2 prewar apartment (not even a single-family home!) in Manhattan would be $24M, and that's with a kinda small and not very attractive kitchen: http://www.mironproperties.com/NY/NYC-Apartment-38737-Upper-...
Many folks, like you, are better off moving away from the Bay Area and taking a salary cut if they don't already own a house and would like to buy one.
(If you're willing to live outside Manhattan, in one of the "outer boroughs", prices drop dramatically.)
If you use that Corcoran link you provided and restrict your searches to townhouses in the $2.3-$2.7M range with 5br, you get only Harlem, not Manhattan: http://tinyurl.com/nvftwqm
Well back to the original question, who are these people earning $250k each? Is this common? Most people in the tech sector I know (ok not in SF) make about half that and I cant' say they are not productive or are stupid. Is that the valley of CEOs and upper management? Foreign investors buying up houses and not living in them just as a way to store their wealth...
Foreign investors buying up houses and not living in them just as a way to store their wealth...
I'd wager that this would be more the case in places like New York, or London.This :
http://www.vanityfair.com/society/2013/04/mysterious-residen...
is quite an interesting read on the subject.
Yes, if you believe that ~100 cities in the Bay Area are somehow preventing housing from being built with laws, then certainly yes.
I work in a fairly senior role in a well known South Bay tech company (you've heard of it). I live in Livermore. (For those of you not familiar with the Bay Area, Livermore is so far away from everything, it might as well be Nevada.) Why do I live in Livermore? Because I can't afford anything within a 20 mile radius of Stanford. All over the Peninsula (and the areas in Santa Clara county you'd want to live) are dotted with $1.5M single family houses and $4,000/mo apartments. Summoning the voice of Jerry Seinfeld, "Who are these people? Really, who are they?" They can't all be stock option multi-millionaires can they? I'm doing pretty well for myself, but I can't afford to live anywhere in basically two counties. What do these people do who can afford to live down there?
The Bay Area is going to eat itself soon. There's just no way this housing situation is sustainable? What is the end game? Is this going to turn into Elysium? How will normal people survive here without affordable housing?