News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by TheCraiggers on Thursday July 03, 2014 @09:43AM (#7982979)
I'd hate to be one of those people, but I'd enjoy some kind of citation on that claim that the majority of Tor users are using it for nefarious purposes.

I may be stretching here, but I think most of us would probably agree that monitoring or outright shutting down Tor would be OK if the nefarious usage was 100%. More interesting is, at which point do we consider monitoring morally wrong as that percentage approaches zero?

Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by Abraln on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:01AM (#7983089)
He never said the majority of tor users are criminals, just that the proportion/percentagefraction is higher than non-tor traffic.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by TheCraiggers on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:06AM (#7983115)
I don't want to get into a semantics argument here, but:

"The proportion of nefarious types (relative to the total user-base) routinely using Tor is going to be significantly higher then the proportion of such who are not..."

He is claiming that nefarious usage is significantly higher than non-nefarious usage. That's the exact meaning of majority.

Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by whafro on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:14AM (#7983150)
No, I think he meant "...who are not using Tor". He's saying that if 1% of normal internet traffic is nefarious, that he suspects that > 1% of Tor traffic is nefarious.

That is to say that your odds of finding a nefarious packet is greater on Tor than on the broader internet.

Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by dspillett on Thursday July 03, 2014 @11:57AM (#7983831)
Exactly. My wording obviously could have been clearer.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by tedunangst on Thursday July 03, 2014 @11:49AM (#7983759)
Assume 5% of Tor users are nefarious. Assume 1% of Internet at large users are nefarious. The proportion of nefarious Tor users is significantly (5x) higher. But it's not majority.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by mikeash on Thursday July 03, 2014 @11:30AM (#7983658)
I don't think it's worded very clearly, but at the end of the day there's only one reasonable interpretation. He's saying that (numbers made up and not realistic) 10% of nefarious types use Tor, while 1% of regular folk use Tor. If nefarious folk make up 1% of the general population, they'll make up about 10% of Tor users, and thus focusing on Tor users will get you a larger proportion of the nefarious.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by Zigurd on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:43AM (#7983318)
In the context of normal law enforcement that would be like searching my car only on the basis of driving down a street where drug deals are are done relatively more often than on other streets.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by middleclick on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:53AM (#7983395)
It's difficult to judge that I guess. Maybe the legitimate uses of Tor are far more outreaching than the illegal things?
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by bcl on Thursday July 03, 2014 @09:50AM (#7983015)
All you need to do is look at the hidden services listed on any of the .onion directories. This is why I stopped running a node -- I just can't justify helping criminals, even if I have no way to know which data passes through my system.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by middleclick on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:52AM (#7983382)
I am not disagreeing with your point of view, but how is Tor different from anything else that can be used by criminals, which includes pretty much ... everything? By that analogy, and again I am not being dense, the use of any encryption can be justified as helping criminals?
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by dspillett on Thursday July 03, 2014 @11:54AM (#7983803)
> By that analogy the use of any encryption can be justified as helping criminals?

That is certainly the view of the security services: anyone using encryption we can't break is a potential enemy hiding something we want to know.

That is why there were export restrictions on encryption technology until it became obvious that was detrimental (crypto developed elsewhere wan't covered, so the restrictions put allied commercial users at a disadvantage to other countries in the industrial espionage stakes without actually affecting the people the restrictions were aimed at at all).

It is also why services that offer encryption are pressured into giving authorities access to the private keys, and those that refuse (or can't due to the design meaning the keys are only in their users hands) tend to get shut down.

Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by bcl on Thursday July 03, 2014 @12:55PM (#7984210)
The difference here is that with Tor it is me who is providing the bandwidth for them to use. I want to see Tor succeed, but I just can't get past the fact that the people running .onion directories seem to feel that since it can be used for anything that everything should be promoted equally.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by nitrogen on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:35AM (#7983268)
Maybe one could run an exit node or .onion proxy that only allows connections to critical sites for political dissidents like gmail, twitter, etc.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by Houshalter on Thursday July 03, 2014 @01:18PM (#7984358)
Websites hosted on tor are, but aren't the majority of users connecting to the external internet?
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by gwern on Thursday July 03, 2014 @11:52AM (#7983792)
> but I'd enjoy some kind of citation on that claim that the majority of Tor users are using it for nefarious purposes.

I don't know about exit nodes, but at least for hidden services that seems to be true (assuming you count torrents and drugs as 'nefarious'). See http://www.verisigninc.com/assets/labs/Measuring-the-Leakage... / http://www.ieee-security.org/TC/SP2013/papers/4977a080.pdf / http://donncha.is/2013/05/trawling-tor-hidden-services/

Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem... by cryptophile on Thursday July 03, 2014 @11:28AM (#7983649)
It does not even matter that "the majority of Tor users are using it for nefarious purposes". Any attempt at intimidation will work out exactly the other way around.

Doing anything that the NSA do not like, is "cool"; even more so in the global scene.

Seriously, if you want to get people to use Tor, all you have to say is that the NSA do not like it.