Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem...
by Abraln on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:01AM
(#7983089)
He never said the majority of tor users are criminals, just that the proportion/percentagefraction is higher than non-tor traffic.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem...
by TheCraiggers on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:06AM
(#7983115)
I don't want to get into a semantics argument here, but:
"The proportion of nefarious types (relative to the total user-base) routinely using Tor is going to be significantly higher then the proportion of such who are not..."
He is claiming that nefarious usage is significantly higher than non-nefarious usage. That's the exact meaning of majority.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem...
by whafro on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:14AM
(#7983150)
No, I think he meant "...who are not using Tor". He's saying that if 1% of normal internet traffic is nefarious, that he suspects that > 1% of Tor traffic is nefarious.
That is to say that your odds of finding a nefarious packet is greater on Tor than on the broader internet.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem...
by dspillett on Thursday July 03, 2014 @11:57AM
(#7983831)
Exactly. My wording obviously could have been clearer.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem...
by tedunangst on Thursday July 03, 2014 @11:49AM
(#7983759)
Assume 5% of Tor users are nefarious. Assume 1% of Internet at large users are nefarious. The proportion of nefarious Tor users is significantly (5x) higher. But it's not majority.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem...
by mikeash on Thursday July 03, 2014 @11:30AM
(#7983658)
I don't think it's worded very clearly, but at the end of the day there's only one reasonable interpretation. He's saying that (numbers made up and not realistic) 10% of nefarious types use Tor, while 1% of regular folk use Tor. If nefarious folk make up 1% of the general population, they'll make up about 10% of Tor users, and thus focusing on Tor users will get you a larger proportion of the nefarious.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem...
by Zigurd on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:43AM
(#7983318)
In the context of normal law enforcement that would be like searching my car only on the basis of driving down a street where drug deals are are done relatively more often than on other streets.
Re:Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extrem...
by middleclick on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:53AM
(#7983395)
It's difficult to judge that I guess. Maybe the legitimate uses of Tor are far more outreaching than the illegal things?