Classic mode sucks. I'm using it right now because I can't arsed tinkering with this particular Ubuntu install, but here's what I found in 30 seconds:
-Taskbar cannot be resized (!)
-Systray widgets cannot be added, moved or removed
-The entire concept of a "panel" is gone.
Gnome 2 was extremely flexible. Gnome 3's "Classic Mode" is more like Microsoft Windows, although even Windows lets you resize the taskbar!
> That's why just continuing with Gnome 2 was a non-starter.
There wasn't enough time to maintain the existing Gnome 2, but there was enough time to create an entirely new desktop environment? I don't think that's possible.
The reason Gnome 2 was a non-starter was because developing a new DE is a lot of fun, and maintaining an old DE is not.
It's their choice, of course, but let's not pretend that abandoning Gnome 2 was anything other than a desire to work on something new.
It's important to understand that this isn't just "Gnome 2," but actually full Gnome 3 underneath with all the benefits that contains. That's why just continuing with Gnome 2 was a non-starter.