It's important to understand that this isn't just "Gnome 2," but actually full Gnome 3 underneath with all the benefits that contains. That's why just continuing with Gnome 2 was a non-starter.
-Taskbar cannot be resized (!)
-Systray widgets cannot be added, moved or removed
-The entire concept of a "panel" is gone.
Gnome 2 was extremely flexible. Gnome 3's "Classic Mode" is more like Microsoft Windows, although even Windows lets you resize the taskbar!
There wasn't enough time to maintain the existing Gnome 2, but there was enough time to create an entirely new desktop environment? I don't think that's possible.
The reason Gnome 2 was a non-starter was because developing a new DE is a lot of fun, and maintaining an old DE is not.
It's their choice, of course, but let's not pretend that abandoning Gnome 2 was anything other than a desire to work on something new.