News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme court: Warrantless cell phone searches illegal [pdf] by bruceb on Wednesday June 25, 2014 @10:52AM (#7944274)
One goes against us (Aereo), one goes for us today. The reasoning for this decision is pretty easy to understand and only takes a minute or so to read the first two pages.
Re:Supreme court: Warrantless cell phone searches illegal [pdf] by trose on Wednesday June 25, 2014 @11:12AM (#7944438)
Honestly, Aereo had it coming. You can't just take someone else's content and stream it to other people for profit. I know it was a great service and we all enjoyed it but I'm not going to sit around and pretend what they were doing was legal. If the "victim" of their service was anything else besides the big nasty cable companies I dont think anyone would be singing their praises.
Re:Supreme court: Warrantless cell phone searches illegal [pdf] by tanderson11 on Wednesday June 25, 2014 @11:42AM (#7944642)
Your comment misses the point of much of the dissent revolving around the Supreme Court's decision. Aereo may very well have secondary liability for copyright infringement enabled by its services, but that was not the question brought before the court.

The question brought to the court was whether or not Aero has direct liability for copyright infringement. This direct liability is only found if Aero "volitionally" "performs" copyrighted material.

The opinion of the court uses a "looks-like-cable-TV" justification for its treatment of Aero, as Scalia (dissenting) notes:

>"The injury claimed is not violation of a law that says operations similar to cable TV are subject to copyright liability, but violation of §106(4) of the Copyright Act. And whatever soothing reasoning the Court uses to reach its result (“this looks like cable TV”), the consequence of its holding is that someone who implements this technology “perform[s]” under that provision. That greatly disrupts settled jurisprudence which, before today, applied the straightforward, bright-line test of volitional conduct directed at the copyrighted work."

Whether or not Aero has secondary liability does not matter; the Supreme Court's vague ruling destabilizes existing jurisprudence and eliminates a concrete test in favour of the immaterial "looks-like-cable-TV" criterion.

EDIT: formatting.

Re:Supreme court: Warrantless cell phone searches illegal [pdf] by gr3yh47 on Wednesday June 25, 2014 @11:39AM (#7944624)
they were providing rental antennas and dvr for free over the air programming, that's a good service for many and there's no reason to think they can't do that
Re:Supreme court: Warrantless cell phone searches illegal [pdf] by nknighthb on Wednesday June 25, 2014 @11:13AM (#7944443)
Aereo is such a specialized case about such a specialized law for a dying ecosystem that it's hard to care at all.

This case is of actual relevance to people who won't be dead in the next 30 years, and will remain relevant long after.

Re:Supreme court: Warrantless cell phone searches illegal [pdf] by lallysingh on Wednesday June 25, 2014 @11:02AM (#7944374)
I don't really care much about Aereo. Today's a very good day.