News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by rayiner on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @06:17PM (#7907375)
> Isn't the whole idea of manned fighter jets antiquated?

Probably not for quite awhile. Issues of lethality aside, the electronics aren't there yet. In Afghanistan, there were long waits to get downlink bandwidth to get video back from UAV's. We're nowhere near the point where we can maintain effective communications with a squadron of drones big enough to do real damage, and the "automated killer drone AI" isn't close yet either.

Yes, the Air Force needs to anticipate the future, but I think the future is a bit further away than you think. If they're planning on using these until 2065, they might start designing drone replacements in say 2045. That's only 30 years away, and probably not a bad ballpark estimate for how long it'll take to get this technology to the point where you can start really relying on it for offensive capability. It sounds like a long time from now, but the F-22 RFP process was started just about thirty years ago.

Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by loup-vaillant on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @03:43AM (#7908943)
Maybe we could think up a middle ground: let's have a manned "commander plane" surrounded by a swarm of drones. If the planes are closer to each other, maybe the bandwidth would be less of an issue?
Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by balakk on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @04:28AM (#7909035)
I don't think so. For combat use, the drones would have to fly low and have a range of at least a few dozen miles to be a reasonable offensive weapon.

If the "commander" plane is going to rely on satellite links, they might as well be sitting on the ground. The "commander" plane needs extensive defenses as well; pretty much similar to how AWACS aircraft are protected.

Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by VLM on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @10:14AM (#7910178)
You've just reinvented the air launched cruise missile.

A close cousin of the very popular fire -n- forget missile and the smart bomb.

Something that must be considered is pilots that aren't risking their butts might be a little more ... aggressive with drones. And drones larger than RC planes aren't any lighter or cheaper than manned craft (so you yank out 400 pounds of life support and cockpit, and replace it with 350 pounds of radios, satellite downlinks and computers. "Eh") So this agressiveness could make mission costs somewhat higher.

Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by greghinch on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @02:33AM (#7908784)
> and the "automated killer drone AI" isn't close yet either.

Now there's a terrifying prospect. Is this actually something we should expect to see any time soon? My understanding has been that, films aside, "AI" software is nowhere near the point where we might run a drone that can kill on it

Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by wodenokoto on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @03:26AM (#7908903)
We are pretty close to driving a car, we have beat human facial recognition, we have very good weapons aiming.

Tying it up to something with a very, very low false positive kill rate is the hard part, but we are very close with a lot of the components.

Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by rayiner on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @07:23AM (#7909433)
Those are things that are doable with pattern matching and big datasets. We're no closer to situational awareness than we ever were. Note we have self-driving cars that have precise databases describing the area they're driving through.
Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by akira2501 on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @04:30AM (#7909040)
It doesn't have to have weapons control, even. If it's limited to an "AI scout" role it could just loiter around, find potential targets and flag them for a human operator. If the targets are reviewed to be valuable enough you could take manual control and fly an assault mission.
Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by poof131 on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @05:21AM (#7909159)
Things like this already exist in various forms and the U.S. government isn't too happy when our 'friends' try to sell some of them: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/06...

The whole process of command and control, targeting, ROE, etc. is incredibly complex and far from easy. Drone's will do more and more, but I'm definitely not a fan of Hunter-Killers on the loose. Two of the fixed-wing losses during the opening of OIF were blue-on-blue Patriot shoot downs: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aviation_shootdowns_and...

Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by rbanffy on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @12:57PM (#7911147)
As long as they don't kill anyone outside the supposed target areas, I don't see much objection coming from the military procurement people.
[deleted]
Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by joelthelion on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @08:23AM (#7909666)
Your viewpoint is interesting, but I think you should give a few references (links) to support it.