News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by krisgee on Sunday June 15, 2014 @10:58AM (#7895351)
Fantastic! I remember reading this a couple of years ago and saying "huh, that's cool" but I make games now and it's much more interesting to read having had to write shaders and make similar sorts of compromises, I especially like the closest source shadows and semi-dynamic tassles on the spears.

On a less technical note it's amazing how going with the cell-shaded look has made the game age so well even the original non-HD gamecube game still looks great today.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by bane on Sunday June 15, 2014 @11:28AM (#7895428)
Also interesting is that the game is having something of a resurgence. IIR it wasn't as well met when it was first released, but it's grown on the community and is really being held up today as a classic.
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by macspoofing on Sunday June 15, 2014 @11:53AM (#7895491)
Yep. It was the wrong game for that time. Gamecube and Nintendo were fighting a "kiddie" image, and people were expecting a Ocarina of Time look especially since two years prior Nintendo showed off a great concept demo[1]. People really wanted that game.

So when Windwaker was announced it was a big let-down and had minimal cultural impact (even though it was a critical and financial success).

In fact, it seemed like the entire Gamecube era can be defined by Nintendo trying something different and kinda being punished for it due to preconceived expectations. Things like FPS Metroid instead of 3rd person Metroid. Mario Sunshine instead of Mario 64 2. Mario Kart Double Dash instead of regular Mario Kart 64 2. Donkey Kong Jungle Beat instead of proper 2D Donkey Kong Country. And of course WindWaker. It's no surprise that some of those games became cult favorites even though they didn't resonate at the time. They were good games, but wrong for the time. Sometimes it pays to give people what they want.

//

Nintendo is actually pretty clueless with market trends in general. Sometimes that's ok, but sometimes it hurts them greatly (e.g. sticking with the cartridge format one generation too long - which I think is THE reason why Sony owned the console market until the PS3 era. No DVD on Gamecube which did hurt their sales in the US. Ignoring online gaming until well into the Wii generation, and even then being clueless about it for many years. No answer to Xbox Live/PS Network. Missing the HD era by a generation - though they got really really lucky with the Wii _initially_). More recently, a Nintendo exec couldn't understand why people would want to watch streamed games[2]!)

---

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wBtAvX4Pkyk

[2] http://www.gamespot.com/articles/e3-2014-wii-u-s-lack-of-twi...

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by JoshTriplett on Sunday June 15, 2014 @02:30PM (#7895897)
> In fact, it seemed like the entire Gamecube era can be defined by Nintendo trying something different and kinda being punished for it due to preconceived expectations. Things like FPS Metroid instead of 3rd person Metroid. Mario Sunshine instead of Mario 64 2. Mario Kart Double Dash instead of regular Mario Kart 64 2. Donkey Kong Jungle Beat instead of proper 2D Donkey Kong Country. And of course WindWaker.

Don't forget launching with a Luigi title rather than a Mario title.

And the funny thing is, most of those are great games: Wind Waker, Metroid Prime, and Luigi's Mansion are all quite good because they broke the usual formula. Trying something different is a risk; you might get something much better than formula by adding some variety, or you might get an utter flop. But I'll take that over something completely formulaic.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by WWLink on Monday June 16, 2014 @04:09AM (#7897869)
The funny part for me was how after I got into windwaker, I immediately thought it was my favorite zelda game lol.

Kinda glad to see the tide turn :) OoT was pretty epic too, but WW is more fun to play. Maybe I just like the whole sailing+pirates thing too much.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by Justsignedup on Monday June 16, 2014 @12:18PM (#7899802)
The long sea voyages could have been done better. But the game felt and played fantastic. I had more fun with it than with the next one. When Twilight Princess came out, I felt "omg finally, no more cell shading" but later on I realized that the gameplay was a step backwards from Wind Waker. Except for the incredibly long traveling times of WW.
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by Tycho on Sunday June 15, 2014 @05:29PM (#7896408)
I think Windwaker was ultimately hurt more because they rushed it out for a November/December release. Allegedly they had to cut two whole dungeons from the final game, so nobody was going to say 'this is the best Zelda ever!'

Nintendo adopt puzzling strategies at times, but I'd be wary of second guessing them. Everyone criticised the decision to stick with cartridges, but let's not forget that every other vendor except Sony that tried switching to CD-ROMs basically went out of business. Likewise, the Wii was slated when people saw the Gamecube-level specs with no HD, but then it was successful beyond anyone's wildest expectations.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by macspoofing on Sunday June 15, 2014 @06:07PM (#7896504)
I think I disagree with almost every point you made :P

- The two missing dungeons were a non-factor (I didn't even know about this until just right now). The game wasn't buggy, and it felt complete. It was as good as it was going to get.

- Sure, a bunch of console-vendors bit the dust with CD-ROM, but nobody blamed CD-ROMs. They failed because of price, or because of lack of recognition, lack of games, or whatever, but not because of CD-ROMs. That's not me talking with the benefit of hindsight. I remember being in that era. There was a consensus that optical media in general, and CD-ROMs specifically, were the future. They were cheaper, and could hold huge amounts of data and FMV clips (FMV was big!). Nintendo had their reasons to go with cartridges, but they weren't good reasons for customers and publishers.

>Likewise, the Wii was slated when people saw the Gamecube-level specs with no HD, but then it was successful beyond anyone's wildest expectations.

Yeah, it was a success and let Nintendo survive that console generation, but that success didn't do anything for the Wii U and the Wii kinda lost steam near the end (didn't most 3rd party publishers abandon it mid-way through it's life?). They got really really lucky with the Wii.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by Tycho on Sunday June 15, 2014 @06:33PM (#7896572)
Didn't Windwaker only have 3 dungeons or something? The two abandoned dungeons would have kept it on par with OoT and MM, without them it seems like you're being shortchanged. Sure, the Twilight Princess style went down much better with the fanboys but you can't pay too much attention to the overly vocal minority that hated Celda.

Nobody thought to blame CD-ROMs as Sony made a big success of it, but sticking with cartridges let Nintendo differentiate themselves from everyone else and ensure they were the only genuine alternative to Playstation. In general Nintendo's business strategy can be described as: a) do something different b) never bet the house. The first ensures the potential for runaway hits like the Wii or DS, while the latter ensures they can always try again next generation.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by quote_ on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @10:50AM (#7910399)
Wind Waker has 5 main dungeons / temples - 7 if you include the fortress and final tower. It also has a 3 mini dungeons to get a few of the items [magic arrows / iron boots].
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by pyre on Sunday June 15, 2014 @08:45PM (#7896878)
> - The two missing dungeons were a non-factor (I didn't even know about this until just right now).

I enjoyed Wind Waker, but I always felt like something was missing. It felt odd that there were only two temples where the previous games had more. I also didn't know about the missing dungeons. And as another poster mentioned, apparently the dungeons were complete, but 'too hard' so they were cut. I almost wish they would have included them somehow even if it was a 'hard more' or some sort of special edition of the game.

> that success didn't do anything for the Wii U

To be fair, the Wii U didn't do much to cash in on the Wii's success other than keep the name, and confuse people as to whether or not it was a new console.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by ajmurmann on Sunday June 15, 2014 @07:19PM (#7896677)
The dungeon situation is worse than that. I actually was very unhappy with Windwaker at the time because it was too easy. I loved the sword fights against the knights towards the end, but there were only a handful of those. So I already was upset about that. However, than I read that Miyamoto had said that the two dungeons had already been completed, but they were too hard and the game got too long and he wanted everyone to finish the game. I can not overstate how I upset I was when I read that.
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by dsuth on Sunday June 15, 2014 @10:44PM (#7897157)
Yeah, this is my biggest problem with Wind Waker, and why it's not the best Zelda - it's just too easy. Adding a couple of tough dungeons would've made it much closer to OoT's difficulty. We shouldn't be aiming for games that everyone can complete - and I say this as someone who doesn't complete a lot of games.
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by deciplex on Sunday June 15, 2014 @11:08PM (#7897215)
>Nintendo is actually pretty clueless with market trends in general.

The whole Wii brand is itself perhaps the best example of it. I can not think of a more terrible name - or rather I couldn't until they released Wii U. Any success these consoles have is in spite of the branding, not because of it. (Which might go to show that branding is not terribly important after all, since the Wii was obviously very successful, and Wii U apparently did well at E3 this year.)

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by m_mueller on Sunday June 15, 2014 @10:08PM (#7897079)
> More recently, a Nintendo exec couldn't understand why people would want to watch streamed games[2]

Gahh.. that link made me seriously question Nintendo's management - are they that disconnected from their customers? just thinking one inch ahead and asking yourself "what's fun about watching [insert your country's favourite sport]" would immediately answer that question whether this is something people want.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by macspoofing on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:19AM (#7897513)
>are they that disconnected from their customers?

Kinda. It's Nintendo being Nintendo. Miss the boat on some trend, and rather than work towards fixing it, deny the trend.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by vlunkr on Monday June 16, 2014 @10:35AM (#7899245)
Yep, I remember trying to defend both Wind Waker and the Metroid Prime series to my friends but they wouldn't play them. I also remember seeing those early screenshots of that Zelda game that was never made, and looking back it's great that they went with the cel shading style. Lots of people thought it looked 'kiddie', but I've always thought it was beautiful, and it's aged so well.
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by pyre on Sunday June 15, 2014 @08:25PM (#7896846)
I got it when it came out, and while I was disappointed that it wasn't basically 'Ocarina of Time' on better hardware (which was known well in advance of release), I really enjoyed the game. I'm glad that it has held up well. I'm guessing that the only things that haven't held up well are the GameCube <=> GameBoy Advance features of the game.
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by krisgee on Sunday June 15, 2014 @08:57PM (#7896916)
The tingle tuner was a pile of junk but it did make some very interesting speed running stuff possible.
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by NDizzle on Sunday June 15, 2014 @12:52PM (#7895629)
I just started playing this for the first time last night. I'm playing the Wii U HD edition. It looks amazing, and one of the first things that stood out to me was the red cloth on the spears.

I spent about 5 minutes in a barrel last night just watching the guards swoosh around their spears. My guess was that was added for the Wii U edition - but apparently I'm way wrong.

Incredible looking game!

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by DoggettCK on Sunday June 15, 2014 @03:06PM (#7895982)
I envy you right now, getting to play it for the first time. Wind Waker is on my list of games I play once a year, up there with Grim Fandango and Mega Man 2.
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by dsuth on Monday June 16, 2014 @04:17AM (#7897886)
It always did look amazing. To be honest every new Zelda since has seemed like a downgrade in terms of graphics and animation. Just wait till you get to swaying platforms over lava lakes!
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by WWLink on Monday June 16, 2014 @04:11AM (#7897876)
Yeah those look cool, and nope those were in the gamecube version too.

fwiw you can usually pick those spears up after you beat the guards lol

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by jafaku on Sunday June 15, 2014 @11:48AM (#7895478)
Kind of offtopic: As a professional of web development and operations with ~10 years of exp... Any ideas where I should start if I want to learn game development? I want to be able to create something by myself, like the Dwarf Fortress guys. Not sure if something with better graphics is even possible as a one man project.

Where else can I ask this question without being treated like a noob or a "gimme teh code plz" beggar?

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by krisgee on Sunday June 15, 2014 @11:53AM (#7895487)
I'm almost 100% sure others will disagree but I'd say start with Unity. The most important thing is getting something small done to give you a taste of what's involved and then you can dig deeper and develop Opinions and eventually go pick a new engine/roll your own.

I definitely do not recommend trying to roll your own engine at first because you'll never get a game done.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by davedx on Sunday June 15, 2014 @12:49PM (#7895626)
As someone who started as a game developer and is now mostly in the web world, I totally agree to start with Unity - a side project I have now is using it, and it's an absolute godsend as a small/one man team for making games. You can do almost anything you can do in a AAA studio engine, but with more productivity and a gentler learning curve.

So yeah, to parent poster: Go download Unity and do the tutorials.

It's also worth working through some OpenGL tutorials to get a feel for how the lower level stuff works.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by eloisant on Sunday June 15, 2014 @12:14PM (#7895541)
Actually as someone who also did mostly web development professionally before starting games as a hobby, I think it's better to start by coding a small game without any engine (like a shooter or a platformer) to fully understand the concepts like game loop, FPS, sprites, etc. Then only you can move to using an engine and you'll understand better what's going on.

That's especially true for someone who already knows programming, the answer would be different for someone who had no programming experience.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by krapp on Sunday June 15, 2014 @12:26PM (#7895570)
I'm taking tutorials for game making in SDL2 to expand my knowledge of C++, and because i've had an interest in game design for a while. I'm certainly learning a lot more than I ever did playing around with Game Maker..
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by girvo on Sunday June 15, 2014 @10:05PM (#7897070)
Hey, don't knock it. I learnt to program in GML; to the point where I built a 3D game out of Game Maker, pretty much using the UI as a glorified level editor, rather than using its proper actions. Taught me heaps :)

Nowadays, I'm a web dev, but I build games in my spare time, and have lately been doing it with Canvas/Javascript. Just like SDL it takes some of the finicky bits out of your way, but is still pretty low level somewhat.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by krapp on Sunday June 15, 2014 @11:13PM (#7897229)
Game Maker is actually pretty nice now that it comes with a physics engine (although I was annoyed when it took me like an hour to reimplement a project it took me weeks to do in an older version because everything was just there) ... I just wish it used something other than GML for its scripting language.
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by benihana on Sunday June 15, 2014 @01:58PM (#7895810)
I'm working through Unity tutorials now and this is what I did, and I'd agree. Being a web developer and knowing JavaScript is awesome for this - HTML5 games are really fun and easy. I started with a Galaga clone[1] that taught me about game loops, input, rendering, and the state of the game world and how they interact and are separate. I think this has made working through Unity, where things are kind of magical, much easier.

1. https://github.com/hoorayimhelping/Galaga5

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by fmax30 on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:49AM (#7897590)
Well Unity is not bad for learning , What i would do would be somthing like this .

- Learn Unity make a couple of small 3D games.

- Learn some basic OpenGL , learn to write your own shaders and understand how it all works.

- After Unity try working with other engines ( work with something like the CryEngine[1] , it costs like 9.90$ / month royalty free)

- As you make games start making your own game engine as a side project.

ProTip: Open Source it to speed up development.

[1]http://cryengine.com/news/crytek-announces-its-cryengine-as-... edit:formatting

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by JoshTriplett on Sunday June 15, 2014 @02:33PM (#7895909)
Given that you've already worked on web development, I'd recommend starting with HTML5 technologies. Don't sweat the graphics right away; many people get away with very rough graphics as long as they have a fun premise. Work on game logic, a graphics engine, that kind of thing.

If you like JavaScript as a language, use that; if you don't, then either try a language that compiles to JavaScript via emscripten or similar, or try a language that works with Chrome Native Client.

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by lgieron on Sunday June 15, 2014 @01:44PM (#7895780)
That's what's possible as a one man project: http://www.shiningrocksoftware.com/game/

AFAIK he did all the game design, coding and assets (models, textures, sounds etc.)

Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by PhasmaFelis on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:28PM (#7900280)
For advice and support on getting started with game design, The Independent Gaming Source forums (http://forums.tigsource.com/) are the best resource I know of.
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by Eric_WVGG on Sunday June 15, 2014 @01:45PM (#7895784)
What kind of web development do you do? Dwarf Fortress could totes be accomplished in Angular.js
Re:Zelda: The Wind Waker – Tech and Texture Analysis by otikik on Thursday June 26, 2014 @09:09AM (#7949377)
http://love2d.org - see you there.