News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by joosters on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:26PM (#7886356)
Isn't this a bit presumptuous?

Ross William Ulbricht hasn't yet been convicted of anything. I know that they aren't selling his personal bitcoins, but in the (highly unlikely) event that he is found innocent, wouldn't that mean that the Silk Road assets need to be returned to him? How then can they sell them now?

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by ryan_j_naughton on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:28PM (#7886366)
It is presumptuous, but that is how civil forfeiture works. Its atrocious.

Take a look at this well written article by the New Yorker Taken: The Use and Abuse of Civil Forfeiture http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2013/08/12/130812fa_fact_...

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by dragonwriter on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:50PM (#7886467)
While there are real issues with civil forfeiture raised in that article, they largely don't apply here -- this isn't a case where the government said "let us seize your assets and we won't prosecute you" (using it as an extortion mechanism) or where the cost of contesting forfeiture exceeds the value of the assets.

Its a case where Ulbricht chose to assert a claim on certain seized property and not on others, either because he is not, in fact, DPR (which is what he claims) and didn't want to steal property that wasn't his, or because he is actually is DPR but admitting that he owned the Silk Road servers and bitcoins would make his conviction more likely because it would make it harder for him to deny being the guy behind Silk Road.

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by ahallock on Thursday June 12, 2014 @07:12PM (#7886566)
That's disgusting. FTA: 'Many states, facing fiscal crises, have expanded the reach of their forfeiture statutes, and made it easier for law enforcement to use the revenue however they see fit.' How are they any better than the criminals they're supposed to be protecting us from?
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by Uhhrrr on Thursday June 12, 2014 @07:32PM (#7886637)
-Their henchmen wear uniforms so you don't confuse them with normal people

-They operate from fixed headquarters

-Some of them are elected

-They have a complaints department

-Certain social services are provided

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by talmand on Friday June 13, 2014 @10:38AM (#7889052)
For the departments that choose to go down that road, they are essentially no different. Except that they have the legal might of the state supporting their actions; including use of deadly force.

Allowing forfeiture statutes of this nature likely motivates departments to increase their usage to get more revenues.

It is a disgusting practice and can only lead to something bad.

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by vacri on Thursday June 12, 2014 @07:51PM (#7886705)
Jello Biafra sang about this as far back as the late 1980s - "property seized and sold before trial", where he had assets siezed in a raid, and the sheriff was legally able to sell his gear before Biafra had seen the inside of a courtroom.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by josephschmoe on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:37PM (#7886414)
That is indeed blood boiling. I am now upset after reading this...
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by dragonwriter on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:44PM (#7886444)
> Ross William Ulbricht hasn't yet been convicted of anything. I know that they aren't selling his personal bitcoins, but in the (highly unlikely) event that he is found innocent, wouldn't that mean that the Silk Road assets need to be returned to him?

If they aren't his bitcoins, why would they return them to him? The assets they are selling aren't the ones he has claimed a property interest in, they are the ones that were unclaimed (by him or anyone else) when the forfeiture action was initiated.

http://www.justice.gov/usao/nys/pressreleases/January14/Silk...

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by danielsju6 on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:31PM (#7886380)
Actually forfeiture sucks hard, even if you are found not-guilty you don't really have a chance in hell of recovering assets seized during a drug bust—like your car for instance.

You can try to prove your innocence but it doesn't really work in practice.

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by swalkergibson on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:45PM (#7886448)
While there are certainly wanton abuses of civil forfeiture statutes, linked to even in this comment thread, applying them here is a no-brainer. Silk Road was very clearly a marketplace for illegal drugs, and the brokerage fee that DPR collected (whoever he or she is) is clearly illegal.

Again, there are obviously situations where civil forfeiture is improperly utilized. This is not one of them, in my opinion.

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by baddox on Thursday June 12, 2014 @07:04PM (#7886537)
If it's "clearly illegal," the court should have no trouble coming to the correct conclusion. It's no justification for permanent asset forfeiture without a trial.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by dragonwriter on Thursday June 12, 2014 @07:09PM (#7886559)
> If it's "clearly illegal," the court should have no trouble coming to the correct conclusion. It's no justification for permanent asset forfeiture without a trial.

You can't have a trial with only one party.

The owner of the bitcoins had an opportunity to contest the forfeiture, and didn't step forward to do that. Given the value of the bitcoins and the public nature of the seizure and forfeiture actions, its hardly likely that that was due to lack of effective notice, or it not being worth expending effort to protect the assets.

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by curun1r on Friday June 13, 2014 @01:23AM (#7887536)
They're explicitly not selling the Bitcoins seized from his personal wallet(s). They're selling the ones seized from the servers that ran Silk Road.

My bet would be that Ulbricht has denied any connection to those servers as part of his defense since claiming to own/control them would make it too easy for the government to prove its case. If, at this point, those servers belong to anyone else, they're free to come forward and claim to own them...that would stop the sale.

So if no one claims to own them, they're fair game for the government to sell.

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by talmand on Friday June 13, 2014 @10:33AM (#7889026)
Somehow I doubt that's how it works, or at least I really hope it doesn't work that way. The government seizes something and attempts to sell it off before identifying who it belongs to? Sure, sounds the right way to handle things.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by swalkergibson on Friday June 13, 2014 @01:21PM (#7889882)
The forfeiture action is a civil proceeding against the asset itself. If somebody has a claim to the asset, they can come forward and contest the proceeding, and potentially win. However, in a case like this, coming forward would essentially identify yourself as a co-conspirator in a clearly illegal enterprise. As such, nobody came forward, so a default judgment in favor of the plaintiff was granted because nobody was there to represent themselves as the owner of the asset.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by aidenn0 on Thursday June 12, 2014 @07:02PM (#7886531)
What about due process?
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by dragonwriter on Thursday June 12, 2014 @07:07PM (#7886549)
> What about due process?

The process here was that government announced forfeiture action, people were given a chance to claim a property interest and fight the forfeiture, and no one chose to do so.

Ulbricht was clearly aware of it, and did assert a claim to other property that was the subject of the same forfeiture action. The seizure was a default judgement because there was no property owner to contest the forfeiture.

What additional process is due, and to whom is it due?

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by maerF0x0 on Thursday June 12, 2014 @08:04PM (#7886749)
My guess is no one has stepped forward because it would make the party guilty. It'd be like an officer saying "Whose backpack is this?" and it has a bomb in it. The owner is in big trouble if they step up.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by GigabyteCoin on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:47PM (#7886453)
I am under the impression that they are auctioning off bitcoins that belonged to "The Silk Road" and not "Ross Ulbricht".

There is no doubt in anyone's mind that the bitcoin sitting inside the silkroad wallets was free for the taking by U.S. authorities.

Whether or not Ross Ulbricht's wealth is owed to the U.S. government they're not sure, so they're keeping them until the trial has completed.

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by waterlesscloud on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:53PM (#7886477)
I'm not sure they really belonged to The Silk Road. Didn't they really belong to the users, who had them on deposit on The Silk Road?

I guess the law would see that as belonging to the business holding them, but I'm not sure that's morally correct.

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by PeterisP on Thursday June 12, 2014 @08:00PM (#7886737)
First, this is explicitly unclaimed stuff; any who had a (in their mind) legitimate claim on those bitcoins had an option to claim [part of] them as their property; apparently noone did.

And if it's the property of Silk Road, then no matter what their deal was with the users, when it closes shop then the due process generally doesn't involve giving parts of their assets to users or creditors - the due process is to auction off those assets (as they're doing now) and settle those liabilities with US dollars; so again, people can claim that Silk Road owes them bitcoins, and they can get paid an appropriate share of this sale.

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by brasky on Thursday June 12, 2014 @08:33PM (#7886859)
I think there was one guy who was trying to get his coins back.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by swalkergibson on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:38PM (#7886419)
I thought the same thing.

However, if he is found not guilty, then the presumption is that he was not involved and therefore would not be the "rightful owner" of the seized property anyway.

Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by meowface on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:40PM (#7886428)
I agree. These coins were the property of the Silk Road website/enterprise.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by landryraccoon on Saturday June 14, 2014 @10:13PM (#7894170)
As others have pointed out, Ulbricht has not claimed that they are his bitcoins. In fact he would be undermining his own legal defense if he claimed the bitcoins were his, so the government is taking them unopposed. So if he were found innocent, probably part of the basis for finding him innocent would be that he successfully convinced the government that those were NOT his bitcoins.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by grondilu on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:30PM (#7886379)
If this happens (though it is very unlikely indeed), the bitcoins could be bought back or Ulbricht could receive an indemnity in US dollars.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by dragonwriter on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:52PM (#7886474)
No, if Ulbricht had claimed the bitcoins were his (which would be kind of hard when he is also claiming that he isn't the guy behind the Silk Road), they would have remained seized as evidence but would not have been forfeited without further proceedings. They were forfeited because no one, including Ulbricht, claimed them (unlike the bitcoins that were seized from his personal computer that he did claim.)
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by Cthulhu_ on Friday June 13, 2014 @08:57AM (#7888538)
Well no, because it's been proven already that Silk Road was a drug exchange, and thus the money is dirty drug money and confiscated by the government. Whether Ulbricht was the mastermind behind the exchange and should be incarcerated is yet to be determined (I believe), that takes a longer lawsuit than a court order to shut SR down and seize its assets.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by ars on Thursday June 12, 2014 @06:27PM (#7886361)
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by mscman on Friday June 13, 2014 @09:59AM (#7888850)
I don't think so. Since the assets were on SR servers, which weren't technically Ross's personal property, and the business was used for selling drugs (admittedly along with other things), civil forfeiture laws allow the government to take those assets. Doesn't matter what happens with the lawsuit.
Re:For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins by rbobby on Thursday June 12, 2014 @08:58PM (#7886918)
Meh... a bitcoin is a bitcoin is a bitcoin. If in the future the gov't is ordered to return X number of bitcoins they can simply go to the marketplace and buy them.