News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by chuckup on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:45PM (#7880339)
I can't tell if StorJ and MaidSafe are "scams" or not. I think they are. They're very handwavy about the exact algorithms they will use to solve the big problems (such as sybil attacks, etc). The StorJ "white paper" really does not explain much. Maidsafe recently made millions of dollars without having much to show for it, I get the feeling StorJ is the same thing. Pretty website, nice buzzwords, but no explanation of how it will work against greedy actors.

Now, here is another p2p storage-meets-bitcoin idea that actually has a very informative paper, Permacoin: http://cs.umd.edu/~amiller/permacoin.pdf

Compare the StorJ whitepaper to the above :)

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by herpderper on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @05:25PM (#7880535)
I'm a hacker so when I met the head of storj at texas bitcoin conference I was hammering him with technical questions... they had a sketchy front end in python but when it came down to brass tacks on storage all I got was something like "well for now we're just uploading it to box.net"
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by Taek on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @06:59PM (#7880927)
I'll go ahead and throw my cryptocurrency into the pile too: www.siacoin.com.

For both StorJ and MaidSAFE, I believe that each has a development team which is taking money and has full intentions of completing their cryptocurrency. We are the same way, have taken around $120,000 from the community and now have a handshake deal with an investor for a substantially larger sum.

Nobody has a working prototype, so there's definitely a race right now. Permacoin looks like the newest of all, only having just released a whitepaper. They also seem to have the most complete whitepaper.

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by ohazi on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:42PM (#7880318)
I may have missed it, but I didn't see any mention of data duplication. How resiliant would this system be to N nodes suddenly disappearing? What percentage of the network could go down and still allow you to reliably retrieve your data?
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by super3 on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @06:33PM (#7880835)
Whitepaper briefly goes over this. The user or application software get to decide their replication number N. The network is self healing, as in if a portion of a file misses a heartbeat(check in) the network will recover it from the other peices.

To affect a file large amount of nodes would have to go down simultaneously. Again the user has control over this N = 1 - Data failure N = 3 - Good for just average cases. Probably still Sybil attacks possible if the have 20-30% of the network. N = 100 - Are you expecting tactical nuclear strikes or acts of God?

Cool thing is if you increase redundancy to a large number Storj starts to act like a CDN or torrent network. But thats outside the scope of your question.

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by Carrok on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @11:31PM (#7881669)
>Are you expecting tactical nuclear strikes or acts of God?

Are you not?

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by pavel_lishin on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @05:19PM (#7880492)
I'm also curious to see what happens in the beginning, and if it hits the elbow, when there isn't sufficient storage space on the network to meet demand.
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by super3 on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @06:15PM (#7880742)
Already anticipated that. We can just run the Storj client on your traditional cloud VPS. If there is market need those can be booted up in a couple of seconds by our team or anyone who wants to set that up.

Because VPS providers profit margins are so high vs a typical home user, they will be eventually replaced, but it allows Storj to scale pretty quickly using the traditional cloud as network nodes.

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by dmix on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @05:52PM (#7880640)
From the whitepaper: [BitCumulus the web interface to the Storj network] "relies on clientside javascript encryption to secure the file in the client’s browser before uploading"

Also it seems to be decentralizing the file storage metadata but not the actual data?

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by super3 on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @06:06PM (#7880704)
Note the whitepaper is outdated. We are in the process of rewriting it. Its a better description of Metadisk, which is one of our front end web apps.

The metadata for the file is stored in a blockchain. The actually data may live on a centralized or decentralized source.

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by gojomo on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:39PM (#7880300)
How similar is StorJ's approach to that outlined in the 'Permacoin' paper...

http://cs.umd.edu/~amiller/permacoin.pdf

...?

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by socrates1024 on Friday June 13, 2014 @03:03PM (#7890323)
I'm not an expert on StorJ, but I'm the Permacoin author. As far as I can tell, Permacoin is a possible candidate for the "proof of resource" puzzle that StorJ opaquely says they'll need (though they don't provide any details). Permacoin is fairly conservative, in that we give a specific description of a storage-based puzzle, and argue that it satisfies exactly the same requirements that Bitcoin's current proof-of-work puzzle does. In other words we aimed for security first, useful side effect second (which is why we only claim to support archival storage, as opposed to full featured Dropbox-like functionality).

If StorJ uses a different puzzle construction, and are not rigorous about its security, then there are two possible mistakes to make: 1. it does not correct incentivize the incentivized storage behavior - it may be possible to game their system and avoid storing useful data 2. it does not satisfy important security requirements from Bitcoin - it may be possible to game their system and make off with a lot of storjcoins using less work

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by spolu on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @07:15PM (#7880992)
Is there a permacoin blockchain running right now?
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by gojomo on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @08:27PM (#7881211)
I believe Permacoin is just a concept; but it seems more rigorously described than the Storj white-paper, which has a lot of hand-waving on the important/tough details.
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by Xcelerate on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:32PM (#7880263)
Very interesting. I knew there was a race for this kind of thing. Incidentally, I've been working on a very similar idea except I was calling mine Scatter haha.

The whitepaper is lacking on technical details so it's hard to tell exactly how they're going to implement everything. It's a little disappointing to see yet another cryptocurrency invented though. I guess there's a lot of competition in this area. I suppose the first group to get a functional, secure, easy-to-use network like this up and running will be the one that acquires a critical mass of users.

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by super3 on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @06:22PM (#7880782)
I'd take a look at some of my writings for meta transactions and templates here: https://github.com/Storj/Metadisk/wiki

Bitcoin only supports up to 80 byte of data per transaction, our model uses 1 kb or more, which makes unusable for our current platform. We are not creating another cryptocurrency just for the sake of doing so. There are many technical reasons why we can't do this yet.

So we already have a long term plan to implement sidechains or treechains. Currently this is only concept/vaporware, so we are not waiting around until it happens.

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by deftnerd on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @07:16PM (#7880997)
I'm writing a system for my OpenID provider servicewith background checks (blockauth.com - BitAngels.co backed project launching in 20 days) that has to store a lot of data in a decentralized system.

Since MaidSafe and all the others don't have a working product yet, I've had to make my own system. Each user is assigned a transaction ID and the 80 bytes on the blockchain simply store a DHT hash for the document, so the system can download the encrypted user dossier through bittorrent. It's working pretty well so far.

The system isn't able to pay users for helping seed the file, but all of the franchised Identity Registrars that'll use my system will be required by contract to seed all of those files.

It doesn't totally solve your problem, but 80 bytes is enough space for a DHT hash and that might be helpful.

Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by nijiko on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @09:43PM (#7881413)
The encryption part would be trivial (to a certain degree), but then thousands of people could potentially store incriminating chains on their computers, should they be seized, it would be for the worst.
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by chatmasta on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @10:18PM (#7881488)
Is there any particular software solution that has traction for implementing BitCoin protocol cryptocurrencies? I've seen Ethereum... is that the most popular right now? Any other options?
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by u124556 on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @05:13PM (#7880472)
With all these blockchain based permanent storage service the question that always comes to me is: What happens when someone uploads Cheese Pizza? What about copyrighted content?
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by super3 on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @06:23PM (#7880786)
Data is not stored on the blockchain in our system. Simply "file pointers".
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by ceejayoz on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @09:27PM (#7881365)
That argument hasn't worked well for torrent sites.
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by gk1 on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @05:28PM (#7880553)
That ran through my mind too. Getting paid for your unused storage sounds nice, but what happens when illegal content ends up on your drive?
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by kibibu on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @11:04PM (#7881598)
Presumably "Cheese Pizza" is slang for child exploitation material?
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by martindale on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @06:01PM (#7880685)
The idea of "illegal" content will fade, replaced by methods that introduce scarcity to digital assets.
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by xhrpost on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:28PM (#7880242)
Been waiting to see this happen, though it's not the first attempt at decentralized storage. Interested to see if someone can pull this off with WebRTC.
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by spolu on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @07:20PM (#7881005)
Am I mistaken or is Storj just a frontend to the Datacoin blockchain?
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by duplexer on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @08:09PM (#7881164)
Our web application, Metadisk, is being prototyped on the Datacoin blockchain, because it is the only cryptocurrecy that supports data transactions over 80 bytes.
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by spolu on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @08:37PM (#7881227)
So this just a web app running on a blockchain that does not yet exist, right?
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by 3pt14159 on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @07:46PM (#7881084)
You are severely mistaken. Read the paper.
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by spolu on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @07:51PM (#7881101)
reading the paper is one thing... having a look at the code is another. And all I see is client code.
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by mef51 on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:43PM (#7880322)
what happens if a big harddrive on the network storing lots of people's data crashes or gets wiped? I guess you could deal with that by putting copies on other drives
Re:Storj – Blockchain-based decentralized storage network by jradd on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @08:47PM (#7881249)
+1 for the coinage of “BitCumulus” in the context of data.