News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft fights U.S. warrant for customer e-mails held i... by sschueller on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @02:46AM (#7876740)
A little off topic.

How does it work for companies that are separately incorporated in another country?

For example: I had a argument with someone from Goldman Sachs Switzerland. They are claiming that their data is out of reach from the US dept. of justice because they are a separate entity incorporated in Switzerland. I have also heard that as an argument from a datacenter provider (Equinix).

Don't profits from these Swiss corporation still somehow make it to the parent company?

What does the parent company do when served with an NSL for data located in the Swiss company?

BTW the funniest thing about Goldman Sachs Switzerland is that they do not accept US customers as they are considered 'toxic'.

Re:Microsoft fights U.S. warrant for customer e-mails held i... by CaptainZapp on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:57AM (#7877025)

  BTW the funniest thing about Goldman Sachs Switzerland is that they do not accept US customers as they are considered 'toxic'.
Practically no Swiss bank accepts US customers at this time. This can be quite a hardship for US citizens living in Switzerland. But they deem the risk just too high and rather forgo the business.

To clarify what your Goldman friend meant.

Swiss banks are obliged to keep customer identifiable data ring fenced and within the country. That is, it can't even be processed offshore. It has nothing to do how the entity is setup legally.

For example (I work for a Swiss bank). I can easily remote access my desktop from home, or, if I have my laptop and token with me, from any other location in Switzerland.

There is no way to access the systems from outside Switzerland.

Singapore, btw, has comparable laws and also ring fences data for use only in Singapore.

Re:Microsoft fights U.S. warrant for customer e-mails held i... by ryanjshaw on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @05:40AM (#7877125)
> For example (I work for a Swiss bank). I can easily remote access my desktop from home, or, if I have my laptop and token with me, from any other location in Switzerland. There is no way to access the systems from outside Switzerland.

Can you remote access your home desktop from outside Switzerland? :)

Re:Microsoft fights U.S. warrant for customer e-mails held i... by gtirloni on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @07:39AM (#7877432)
While I understand and accept the technical possibilities where this could be worked around, it actually misses the intent of the law.

If someone where to be caught doing that, she/he would not be able to say it was technically possible so it's OK. It's technically possible but legally forbidden. So the message is: do it at your own peril.

Reality and law don't always agree but when these things go to court, law has the upper-hand :)

Re:Microsoft fights U.S. warrant for customer e-mails held i... by zyx321 on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @07:30AM (#7877392)
He probably could, if he really really wanted to go to jail.
Re:Microsoft fights U.S. warrant for customer e-mails held i... by sschueller on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @05:17AM (#7877075)
There may be a technical restriction but what prevents a top US executive from Goldman from traveling to Switzerland an accessing the data?

What about IT people? Such companies generally bring in IT professionals for projects from other entities such as the US headquarters.

Re:Microsoft fights U.S. warrant for customer e-mails held i... by CaptainZapp on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @05:53AM (#7877150)
First of all, the role of that executive would require a business need to access the data at all. Banks are really big on compartmentalization and the most important principle is that a bank employee can only see, let alone modify, data as far as it's required to do his or her job. This also applies to top executives.

It's unlikely that an US top executive has a valid business reason to see Swiss data when visiting the country. If such a reason exists he can surely see it, but it's probably illegal to take the data out of the country in any form. (I'm guessing here, but Swiss criminal law is quite finicky on the issue of bank secrecy).

If the top executive tries to asshole his way into the data (as in: "hand over the data, or you're fired") any halfway smart employee would immediately inform compliance, where a whole cacophony of alarm bells would go off.

As for IT professionals. Sure, a lot of foreign IT professionals work for Swiss Banks. But the need to access actual customer data is very, very rare. If the need exists, they can surely see it, but only from within the country's borders.

Re:Microsoft fights U.S. warrant for customer e-mails held i... by vidarh on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @07:03AM (#7877314)
US customers are "toxic" to many banks internationally, not just the Swiss, because the IRS claims authority to access a lot of data for the prevention of tax evasion that either makes US customers wildly inconvenient, or that is actually illegal for the banks to disclose to anyone but their own authorities (if that).
Re:Microsoft fights U.S. warrant for customer e-mails held i... by colechristensen on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @03:59AM (#7876894)
The Swiss banks which have been getting in trouble and paying billions in fines have been doing so because they were conducting business in America with Americans in order to break American laws.

If Microsoft or any company does foreign business and that specific business stays out of America, the American justice system has no business at all trying to reach it's fingers into it except by established treaty and/or cooperation with foreign governments.