News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by scarygliders on Monday June 09, 2014 @06:02AM (#7867687)
This makes me sad.

I lived and worked in Japan for 6 years, returning to my native Scotland almost 2 years ago, after struggling for the few years after the M9 quake (lived in Koriyama, Fukushima prefecture and lost my job after the quake).

We bought a new Suzuki Wagon R Limited back then, and I loved that car. Its apparently small outward appearance is deceptive; inside, there was loads of space - a high roof height, and when you folded down the rear seats you could comfortably fit items such as chests of drawers, fridges, and the like.

The engine; 0.6 litre - but that was augmented by a turbo, so there was plenty of power available, plus it sipped fuel. The automatic gearbox provided 4WD in first gear, which was awesome during winter - we lived in rural parts of Fukushima and the roads frequently iced over. Once during winter we went for a drive up a mountain road covered in about 3 inches of fresh snow and made it to the top of the Katasoniyama mountain because of the 4WD+studless tyres. Our Wagon R Limited also had niceties such as aircon, electric windows, and a minidisc(!)/radio.

All in all, a fantastic vehicle, and I wish we had sent it over to Scotland when we moved as the equivalent Wagon R's available here are made in Europe and just aren't the same standard of equipment and features, sadly.

The silly thing about the move by the Japanese government is that these Kei cars are an ideal solution to crowded cities as they require less space on roads and for parking, as well as being (or were) an extremely economical choice.

As others here have commented, I suspect there has been lobbying by the makers of large gas-guzzlers to make Kei cars less desirable. I think this decision by Abe's government will inevitably impact Japan's struggling economy - crony politics is notorious in Japan, something which contributed to the design and layout flaws of the Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear plant.

Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by richardwhiuk on Monday June 09, 2014 @08:11AM (#7868022)
Realistically all they are doing is removing a bizarre tax benefit which doesn't exist for any practical reason.
Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by scarygliders on Monday June 09, 2014 @08:27AM (#7868069)
Hmmm, I thought in this day and age, where a lot of people are hyper-ventilating about the environment, that usage of such vehicles would be encouraged, and that would be at least one practical reason for the tax benefit.
Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by richardwhiuk on Monday June 09, 2014 @09:53AM (#7868425)
If you were doing that, you would base the tax on miles per gallon, or CO2 per mile, rather than on engine capacity, which is a poor indicator of environmental concerns.
Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by gambiting on Monday June 09, 2014 @06:57AM (#7867816)
>>All in all, a fantastic vehicle, and I wish we had sent it over to Scotland when we moved as the equivalent Wagon R's available here are made in Europe and just aren't the same standard of equipment and features, sadly.

Well, I am glad you enjoyed it in Japan, but I am very happy that cars which do not meet basic NCAP safety standards are not allowed to be sold in the EU.

Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by shiven on Monday June 09, 2014 @08:28AM (#7868074)
Now if only those "safe" cars were as fuel-efficient as the kei cars, no one would have to pick one vs the other.

I feel Tesla is the only trailblazer doing the right thing in terms of evolving cars further. Granted, they are astronomically priced and hence designed to appeal to the "looks"-concisous buyers who want not just a no-emission vehicle, but also a status symbol of sorts. Eventually, the advances in technology ("fuel" efficiency) and material science (safety) pioneered by Tesla's high-priced cars today, will result in consumer-grade, common-as-mud, family schlepping four wheels, to be accessible to a much larger swath of the population. Then, this discussion will be moot!

Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by gambiting on Monday June 09, 2014 @08:57AM (#7868198)
There are cars which are safe and offer very similar fuel-efficiency. For example - VW Polo with a 1.2TDi Bluemotion engine. One of the safest cars around, and in real-life tests the fuel consumption stays above 80mpg(that's UK gallons). I honestly doubt that those Kei cars can do better than 80mpg.

The problem here, I imagine, is price - a new Polo will cost a lot more than a Kei car.

Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by scarygliders on Monday June 09, 2014 @08:30AM (#7868082)
Can you cite somewhere that mentions that Wagon R Limited doesn't meet NCAP safety standards? I'd be interested in reading that.

I forgot to mention my car also had driver and passenger airbags fitted as standard - not that those would prevent death in the event the vehicle accordianed in a head-on collision, I admit. But I'd be interested in reading something which confirmed your assertion.

Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by gambiting on Monday June 09, 2014 @08:40AM (#7868137)
Hmmm there is plenty of links on google saying that the Wagon R is not sold anymore in the EU due to the failed NCAP tests, but I can't find a link to the actual test...which is weird.

"However, the original Wagon R+ was still offered in Europe after December 2000, but made by Magyar Suzuki in Esztergom, Hungary. This was because it was too difficult for either the Wagon R-Solio or Solio to meet with Euro NCAP crash safety ratings. As a result, the Wagon R+ continued in Europe until late 2008, when replaced by the Splash." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suzuki_Wagon_R

Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by 1stop on Monday June 09, 2014 @07:24AM (#7867874)
Because you need the government to decide what is safe for you or not?

I've never understood safety standards for consumer goods. If you want to drive around in a horrible death trap of a car... why should the government stop you?

(Admittedly I guess you don't want driving time bombs, but the majority of NCAP standards are related to occupancy safety).

Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by gambiting on Monday June 09, 2014 @08:12AM (#7868023)
Because as a EU citizen I want to know for certain that something that is on the market here is not dangerous to drive around.

The same as you can trust that the carrots sold at a local supermarket do not contain arsenic - there are regulations against that. But according to your logic, it would be better if there were no regulations, surely a producer of arsenic-containing carrots will naturally go out of market after sufficient number of people die, because no one will buy their carrots anymore,right?

I believe that a car with a cabin that folds like origami in a crash should not be allowed to be sold in the EU(or in fact, anywhere).

Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by 1stop on Monday June 09, 2014 @09:01AM (#7868220)
So I guess you can't buy a knife in europe? (by your own logic).
Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by gambiting on Monday June 09, 2014 @09:42AM (#7868384)
You can't buy a knife that would be dangerous to use by being badly made, or which material would contaminate food. So for example,a knife containing phthalates would not be allowed to be sold in stores. This is my logic - I do not want equipment which is unsafe to use to be sold in the EU - a car that has a cabin which folds like origami in a crash[1] should NOT be allowed on the market.

Guess what happens to the passengers of this car? I imagine their consistency is somewhere between peanut butter and freshly squeezed orange juice: [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRU__x5UAo0

Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by hcho on Monday June 09, 2014 @07:46AM (#7867943)
Because the governments in Europe pay for health care and social security too. The less wheelchair bound 19 year olds, the better.
Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by richardwhiuk on Monday June 09, 2014 @08:09AM (#7868014)
Largely because when you hit somebody, or they hit you, instead of a minor injuries claim, what you'll have is a death on the road.

Realistically, you'd have thought the insurance on them ought to be huge due to the huge decrease in safety features.

Re:Japan Seeks to Squelch Its Tiny Cars by scarygliders on Monday June 09, 2014 @08:32AM (#7868093)
Can you cite what safety features aren't present on that Wagon R Limited?