It's why brands say "we're #1 in X", "we're the most popular Y", "more people buy our product than any other".
It's why sitcoms have laugh tracks.
And I am not confident on "disrupting" human nature. Most "disruptions" follow the grooves laid out millions of years ago; what changes is the environment, not the subjects.
It's also important to understand that in any high stakes game sniffing out the bad actors is always going to be a never ending cat and mouse game, so no one solution will put an end to it.
There are many similar websites who focus on low quality content optimized for search engines.
OTOH StackOverflow employs similar tactics but it is legit and usually useful content.
Should Google discriminate between these two? If, yes based on what criteria? (Remember, wikihow pages look like they're user generated, legit content) Is there any objective criteria?
I personally would like wikihow to take its place in hell, ehm I mean obscurity. Right next to w3schools.
Or maybe you can and I'm missing a business opportunity. A TAOCP+OraclePropaganda bot sounds like something that might make bags and bags of money.
Because the quality of the top voted answers speaks for themselves in 99% of the ocassions.
You can't use popularity metrics to mean anything substantive.
A ratings service that relies on the person being rated to pay results in conflicts of interest. You will also find it hard to have anyone want to pay for anything that might be critical of them.
A service that did this would require a strong guiding mission, because it's cheaper to shill blog spam than to actually dig in and do accurate research while citing sources.
Is this fact correct? or Does this statement seem correct?
Then present a phrase: "There are less than 10,000 troops in Afghanistan."
When I think about credibility though it quickly appears to be a bit of a mine-field, highly context dependent. If PG writes an article people are going to attribute a huge amount of weight to it. Obviously he is very credible when it comes to a lot of subjects, but context can tell all.
I'd say if he wrote about how paste engagement rings were going to be the next big thing there'd be one or two embarrassing proposals on Youtube within the month. But if he wrote on why paste jewelry is the next big thing in fashion businesses there is obvious weight (whether or not it's correct) to that opinion. So I'd say matching context with popularity, and figuring out transferability of credibility are where this can be disrupted.
"on social media it is easy to mistake popularity for credibility"
I wouldn't say this is limited to social media. This flaw is present in search engines as well, which is why link farms work (and search engines are in a constant, futile battle against them). In politics, it's why astroturfing works and why the more you spend on saturation advertising, the better your chances are. It's really a flaw in human nature--to confuse popularity for credibility.
I'm convinced that anything out there, online or off, with a ranking system that relies on popularity (counts of links, likes, eyeballs, votes, etc.) is ripe for disruption. What's the alternative way to separate genuine credibility from fake (purchased) credibility? Figure it out and you'll be a billionaire.