News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by HNJohnC on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @12:30PM (#7841165)
A quick rule of thumb: if the title or the opening of the article for any technique do not contain some form of the phrase "when to use" or "under these circumstances" and instead contain absolutes like this title then you automatically know you are in for a slog to get any kind of general benefit from reading the article.

People these days seem incredibly quick to publish articles without considering how limited their perspective might be and thus the responsible way to present the information.

Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by themodelplumber on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @12:39PM (#7841223)
A quick rule of thumb: When a headline appears on the front page at HN, that headline alone is enough of a signal for 99% of HN users. It says, "a number of people are thinking about this. We need to talk about this." Forget what the article says, just read what the headline is shouting from its highly-upvoted position. If you don't like the article, fine. But "let's talk about hamburger menus and practically invisible navigation" is a worthwhile signal.
Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by Jacqued on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:49PM (#7841686)
I actually submitted the article to initiate such a talk. The article failed to convince me completely, but it did make me think about the place of slide-in menus, since I consider hiding UI elements to be generally bad practice.
Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by pistle on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @02:41PM (#7842007)
I've seen the doppleganger of this article a number of days ago and both drag out some form of nav bar as the alt. Really???

A nav bar, let alone a sliding nav bar, is tabs or an obese hamburger. We have been around this before. Tabbed desktop apps and tabbed web interfaces a la Amazon of the 90's. You know what this UI need? MORE TABS!

The great unbundling will continue as small screens and human eyes can only deal with so much info per inch.

I don't want to artificially engage with your A/B-optimized application. I want it to get the one or very few small things done that I need done. I don't want time sinks. I don't want to aimlessly dig through ambiguous icons looking for digital delight that you decided was unworthy of special treatment. If you are playing games with tricking humans into using your app, I question the value you are creating with your app.

There's a thing in my hand and it should be about the size of half a banana. If I want to see another half a banana, I'll put this one down and pick the other one up. I have one hand, two eyes, and a hankering for bananas! Show me pretty bananas!

Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by ulisesrmzroche on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @03:23PM (#7842211)
I honestly have no clue what you said and I don't think anyone else did either.
Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by pistle on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @02:58PM (#7847428)
3 other people may have. Let me simplify for you. Hamburger hate is silly and a waste of time. The "better" alternatives have been done multiple times and keep getting ousted for their fundamental flaws. The value being espoused is "how to waste the user's time in your app." That's doubly wasteful. Stop creating artificial engagement and stop fighting the burger.
Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by ulisesrmzroche on Thursday June 05, 2014 @09:54AM (#7851950)
Doubly wasteful is making me click twice to get to what I want. and everyone, stop calling it a burger, that's a wave. This is like early-human mythology, it should be ingrained in there somewhere.
Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by 205guy on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @09:24PM (#7843592)
I've often thought that the HN submission form should support both the link and a short comment. If the submitter can frame the context of the submission, doesn't that help the discussion?
Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by personZ on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:15PM (#7841457)
A very small minority of HN readers can propel something to the front-page with ease, with relatively few votes: Right now, two hours in, this has earned the arrows of a miserly 59 users. Undoubted thousands of others have browsed it and moved on, with by most measures is the opposite of the up arrow.

I'm not speaking to the specifics of this submission, but the "it's on the front page therefore it has merit" argument is not reasonable. Topics that are particularly contentious (and feelings about UI is one of them, particularly when people are motivated by disagreements with co-workers about UI direction) tend to make the front-page with ease.

Tomorrow - Why "hamburger" menus are the bestest. Also, TDD is the best, and so is NoSQL.

Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by themodelplumber on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:40PM (#7841624)
> "it's on the front page therefore it has merit"

I didn't say that. Why the quotes?

Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by personZ on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @02:19PM (#7841872)
It is an accurate paraphrasing of what you did say. Do you disagree with that? The paraphrasing is necessary for discussion.

EDIT: I would love to see what an accurate paraphrasing is, then. I've re-read your post and what I stated is dead on with what you claimed, which is a common misunderstanding of the importance or common-agreement of a front-page appearance.

Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by themodelplumber on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @02:56PM (#7842086)
Nope, not accurate. Yes, I do disagree. No, the paraphrasing is not necessary for discussion (???). Not a biggie in the broader scheme of things though.
Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by Retric on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @03:47PM (#7842323)
As a third party "we need to talk about this" and the topic "has merit" are equivalent statements. Granted you may have intended something else, but that's not how it comes across. Anyway, as you did not clarify what did you mean?
Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by frostmatthew on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @06:45PM (#7843159)
The article contains a section titled "When Should I Use It?" as well as one titled "What Should I Use Instead?"

Also, your rule of thumb knocking the use of absolutes sounds like an absolute.....

Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus by ulisesrmzroche on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @03:21PM (#7842206)
You forgot to mention that people these days are also incredibly petty. I don't see what's such a big deal about the title. Your quick rule of thumb is precisely the behavior you're pissed about.