Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus
by themodelplumber on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:40PM
(#7841624)
> "it's on the front page therefore it has merit"
I didn't say that. Why the quotes?
It is an accurate paraphrasing of what you did say. Do you disagree with that? The paraphrasing is necessary for discussion.
EDIT: I would love to see what an accurate paraphrasing is, then. I've re-read your post and what I stated is dead on with what you claimed, which is a common misunderstanding of the importance or common-agreement of a front-page appearance.
Re:Why and how to avoid hamburger menus
by themodelplumber on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @02:56PM
(#7842086)
Nope, not accurate. Yes, I do disagree. No, the paraphrasing is not necessary for discussion (???). Not a biggie in the broader scheme of things though.
As a third party "we need to talk about this" and the topic "has merit" are equivalent statements. Granted you may have intended something else, but that's not how it comes across. Anyway, as you did not clarify what did you mean?
I'm not speaking to the specifics of this submission, but the "it's on the front page therefore it has merit" argument is not reasonable. Topics that are particularly contentious (and feelings about UI is one of them, particularly when people are motivated by disagreements with co-workers about UI direction) tend to make the front-page with ease.
Tomorrow - Why "hamburger" menus are the bestest. Also, TDD is the best, and so is NoSQL.