News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by anthony_franco on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:18AM (#7821038)
You're absolutely allowed to pay for links, that's what pretty much all internet advertising is based on after all. Google just doesn't like when you pay for links that pass PageRank. So as long as you do a nofollow on the link, it's fine.
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by pdevr on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:29AM (#7821185)
Copying my previous answer here (and more explanation at the end): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7821157

Yes, and I think OP was trying to point out Google Adsense allows "paid links" to be displayed on the same website: "You own a website, I own a website, I pay $100 to Google who decides when to show my ad on your website and keep $60 for itself."

In other words, if you pay Google (30% more money)[1] to display the links on another website, you are alright. However, if you directly pay the website owners (roughly 30% less money) for them to add a paid link on the same site at the same spot, you are running afoul of Google's rules. So, as a business owner, to be in the good books of Google, you incur 30% extra expenses. I am not trying to criticize Google here (I use multiple Google services), just pointing out how many small business owners see this.

More explanation:

<a class="rhtitle" href="http://www.googleadservices.com/pagead/aclk?longurl" target="_top" title="google.com/Chromecast"><span>Online Content Now on TV</span></a>

The code above is an actual Adsense advertisement (I have removed/changed the code and id everywhere). There is no no-follow anywhere there. So, it appears as if it is alright to insert a link with no no-follow as long as you are paying Google. Correct me if I am wrong.

[1] https://support.google.com/adsense/answer/180195?hl=en

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by phpnode on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:38AM (#7821209)
These ads are pulled in via JS, in an iframe, so it's not quite the same thing - they don't pass link juice.
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by meleva on Friday May 30, 2014 @11:54AM (#7822463)
One reason to justify Google's cut is that on an advertising deal where the Advertiser gets billed for each click (CPC) on his link on someone else website, having a reliable third party to count the clicks is very important.

Click fraud is what makes Tier 2 CPC networks really risky for advertisers even if CPC are much lower than Tier 1 (Adwords, Bing).

Regarding your Adsense example, was there not a mention like "Ads by Google," "Sponsored Links," or the AdChoices icon ? In that case, it makes clear that it's not a natural link.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by sunnykgupta on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:34AM (#7821192)
Exactly my point.
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by eis on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:43AM (#7821084)
You have to distinguish between ads and links being part of the page content.

As long as you seperate ads clearly from the site content and maybe give them a rel="nofollow" attribute, there should never be negative consequences.

Paying someone for low quality content around links to increase search engine rankings lowers the quality of the overall web for everyone.

Google does a lot of questionable stuff and I personally don't like the power they weild over the web. However, in this particular instance, I can't see anything wrong with this policy.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by sunnykgupta on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:53AM (#7821102)
How do you specify ads apart from other links.

Maybe I'm talking about a product, call it spammy, but I'm all praises about the product. The visitors to my website are actually reading this article, indicating that the article is not boring, badly-written content.

At the end of the article I write the line, "If you want to try out the product head over to http://theproduct.com".

Why does a multi-millionaire company get to decide that my HTML markup is `wrong` if there is no "nofollow" in my HTML?

I know they have the right to decide who gets listed on their search engine and who does not. If that is the case, they should not call their results fair.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by adventured on Friday May 30, 2014 @09:07AM (#7821513)
What does multi-millionaire have to do with anything?

As opposed to having a wildly unsuccessful, incompetent company with six employees deciding everything.

Turns out you have to be a really, really big company to even attempt to maintain such a massive global search platform that is fast and accurate. How else would this be accomplished? By a non-profit with 30 employees? By the UN? I don't see the logical alternative.

You can block Google if you dislike their search engine. Their product is private property, it belongs to Google, it's not a public utility. So they get to decide, as is right, how it works. You could always create your own search engine, like DuckDuckGo, and specify how it works.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by quonn on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:27AM (#7821175)
> Why does a multi-millionaire company get to decide that my HTML markup is `wrong` if there is no "nofollow" in my HTML?

They don't "get to decide" anything. It's just that _you_ don't get to decide either. After all there are many others who also want to be listed at the top for a particular query.

Simply, their algorithm works in a particular way. Other tags might also affect the ranking, such as h1 tags, for example. There has to be _some_ mechanism.

Why is this so difficult to understand?

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by sunnykgupta on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:36AM (#7821202)
Indicating, that its a shortcoming in Google's search algorithm that makes anybody who wish to get listed on it's index to follow these `Rules`?
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by quonn on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:41AM (#7821220)
My point is that short of picking the search results randomly, any mechanism will have some rules (no matter how complicated) that affect how things get ranked.
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by sunnykgupta on Friday May 30, 2014 @08:00AM (#7821265)
So be open about the shortcomings in your algorithms instead of trying to show that the practice is bad, try telling people that your algorithm is not competent enough to know if the intentions are good or bad.

Hence your algorithm requires you to comply to the nofollow rule.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by tveita on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:58AM (#7821263)
If they did fix their algorithm, no one would pay for link spam any more.
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by weavie on Friday May 30, 2014 @08:45AM (#7821418)
The general point of Googles page rank algorithm is to find the best and most relevant content. It's premise is that people are more likely to want to link to good content than bad content. When people start using money rather than quality content to influence the algorithm, it destroys it's premise and thus undermines it's effectiveness.
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by meleva on Friday May 30, 2014 @11:44AM (#7822385)
Actually it goes like that:

You own a website, I own a website. I pay you $100 to show your visitors a link to my website. The link is presented as an organic, non paid link. =BAD

You own a website, I own a website. I pay you $100 to show your visitors a link to my website. The link is presented as a paid link, with a no follow attribute. =GOOD

On a side note, your breakdown of the Ad Revenue using Google as a middleman is wrong. If you pay Google 100$ (via Adwords) to decide to show ad on my site, I will get 68% of that 100$ and Google will get 32%

Adense revenue share: https://support.google.com/adsense/answer/180195?hl=en

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by lazyjones on Friday May 30, 2014 @08:30AM (#7821371)
It's not justifiable. It's just band-aid for widespread malpractice, but as it is now, this just favors paid links that are hidden better, e.g. inside articles, random texts etc.

The whole concept of "link juice" is no longer useful. Google should identify and count real humans visiting web pages via GA and Chrome and rank search results based on actual website usage, and not on how well they can cheat in SEO.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by DanBC on Friday May 30, 2014 @12:30PM (#7822658)
Doesn't that just mean there'll be an underground AmazonTurk for people happy to visit websites to noodle around for a few minutes / hours?
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by phpnode on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:34AM (#7821195)
I don't think it is justifiable. Google's policies are a bandage for gaps in their algorithms, rather than fix their algorithms (admittedly, this is hard and it's not like they aren't trying) they have reached a point where they can use their monopoly power to dictate how websites act. They punish behaviour which hurts their main business - adwords.

I would expect an anti-trust case in the coming few years.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by PauloManrique on Friday May 30, 2014 @11:39AM (#7822355)
My 2 cents: if you pay for Adwords, you'll be on the top of the page, so you can buy from Google your way to the top of search results. Sure some people realize the first results are paid, but still, get a decent title on your campaign and you're on the top of the page.

We should also mention that Google tells people to "merge" adsense on the website, so it doesn't appear to be an ad, inducing people to think that it's part of the website. Have you ever been on a download website with ads with graphics saying "Download" right next to the button just to make confusion and make you click on them? Yeah, I see plenty of those using adsense.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by DanBC on Friday May 30, 2014 @12:28PM (#7822634)
I would have though Google would be strongly against ads like that. Do you (or anyone) have screenshots?
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by WriteYourRep on Friday May 30, 2014 @11:54AM (#7822460)
If google allowed paid links that passed on page rank, SEO instantly becomes pay to play. Preventing a situation where it only takes money to rank is in Google's best interest because it promotes a healthy internet ecosystem.
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by onion2k on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:46AM (#7821234)
Buying links is fine.

Buying links in order to 'cheat' your way to the top of Google's search page, thereby skewing the accuracy of their results, isn't fine.

I'd liken it to Ford paying 500,000 people to drive a Ford car and then claiming to be the #1 best selling car in the country. If they did that publicly it'd be ok (and compilers of car sales listings would ignore them). If they did it secretly then it really wouldn't. Tagging a link with 'nofollow' essentially makes it public that the link isn't trying to cheat the listings.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by arikrak on Friday May 30, 2014 @09:20AM (#7821573)
It's dishonest to your users to display a paid link and and not tell them. Google feels the same way about displaying paid links that they look at. What does that have to do with ads, which you can display from anyone on your site?

Also, Google only keeps 32% of the ad revenue not 60%: https://support.google.com/adsense/answer/180195?hl=en

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by nl on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:10AM (#7821138)
You are completely free to pay for links.

Google is completely free to have their algorithm work however they want to provide the best possible results.

(Personally I think using paid links as a signal for good websites is unlikely to improve results. You may not agree with this, but that is separate to the issue as to if they should be free to implement their algorithm however they like)

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by bowlofpetunias on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:43AM (#7821227)
Leaving ethics aside for a second, neither of these statements are "completely" true in the real world.

In the real world, you have to deal with lots of rules and regulations regarding advertising (which is what paid links are) and companies with significant market power.

The real world is not some libertarian wet dream.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by pdevr on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:20AM (#7821157)
Yes, and I think OP was trying to point out Google Adsense allows "paid links" to be displayed on the same website: "You own a website, I own a website, I pay $100 to Google who decides when to show my ad on your website and keep $60 for itself."

In other words, if you pay Google (30% more money) to display the links on another website, you are alright. However, if you directly pay the website owners (roughly 30% less money) for them to add a paid link on the same site at the same spot, you are running afoul of Google's rules. So, as a business owner, to be in the good books of Google, you incur 30% extra expenses.

I am not trying to criticize Google here (I use multiple Google services), just pointing out how many small business owners see this.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by colinbartlett on Friday May 30, 2014 @08:36AM (#7821392)
I think the biggest difference between the two is that one looks like ads and the other looks like natural links. I'm pretty sure Google wouldn't penalize you for having your own advertisements on your site when they are clearly marked as such.
Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by pdevr on Friday May 30, 2014 @12:46PM (#7822747)
Even when they were marked as sponsored links, they were penalized, according to this post[1].

On a sidenote, my post was downvoted by someone even though it was on-topic. I disagree with you, but have upvoted so we can discuss this rationally.

[1] http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/why-did-my-pagerank-go-down/

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by annacarthy on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:34AM (#7821194)
Paid Ads = OK Paid links that look organic = bad.

You are not allowed to pay to increase your ranking. You can buy ads on Google or another site and that's ok as long as they are marked as ads.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by sunnykgupta on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:42AM (#7821223)
That is what I'm trying to ask, how do you define marking as an Advert?

Does every advertisement necessarily carry a 'Advert' banner?

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by lauradhamilton on Friday May 30, 2014 @10:08AM (#7821856)
The definition of "advert" is something that you paid for.

If you're asking how does Google know if a link was paid? It has some algorithmic ways, and it also relies on paid link reports from competing webmasters.

Re:Ask HN: How do you justify Google’s SEO policy of not all... by hadoukenio on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:58AM (#7821109)
Google doesn't like it when you cut out the middle man.