As jblow said the whole "no more ads" post reads as PR spin, same goes for your reply to him:
- growth numbers don't tell any story apart maybe from «many people read the "Open" part of the OpenDNS name and turn their brains off» [2].
- DNS nerds run their own DNS and keep away from openDNS for breaking DNS and invading privacy.
- not causing issues for most people doesn't disprove that it did cause issue for many people.
I do remember the browser landscape before openDNS and I'm quite happy to debunk your boasting attempt at being significant. The "search from the address bar" functionality has been around long before google chrome came to existence, actually it was in opera before openDNS existed and even better it allows to choose the search engine and use several with the use of a keyword. This was then added to firefox back in firefox 3. Again don't take my word for it and look a this 2008 post[3].
[1]: http://www.bortzmeyer.org/opendns-non-merci.html
[2]: http://beta.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=1297613&cid=2864072...
[3]: http://googlesystem.blogspot.fr/2008/06/searching-from-addre...
how about notDNS? though notDNS implies they don't serve domain names. How about, openDNS?
Actually, I don't like that one either, that implies they are open source.
How about, gimpDNS. There, I can get behind that one.
Does that sound like a harmless service? OpenDNS knowingly and deliberately broke the Internet for its customers. I have actually spent time debugging issues it caused just to find that the client was using their resolvers. They were not a free service, they were actively harmful. I am glad the profits are no longer there for them to keep up this malicious practice.
Two weeks ago, I had to swap my company's network over to OpenDNS because Google DNS was having an outage. And then a day later, I spent 2 hours trying to chase down a problem running something that turned out was a result of OpenDNS feeding a page full of ads to something that was expecting JSON.
You might not have broken things for all the people that continued to use your service, but you broke things for people like me. And this is a place where people like me hang out....
However robust an application is it can't handle being fed html ads instead if application spesific json.
When you are finished rethinking this you can go on to think a second time about censoring your wifes Internet access. Do onto others etc....
I also don't think OpenDNS is a tool of censorship, as it is so easily circumvented. I hope my children learn how to circumvent tools of censorship and this can be their first practice... Until then it reduces the risk of accidentally going to phishing websites.
Was the first version of Great Firewall also no censorship since it was easily circumventable?
> I hope my children learn how to circumvent tools of censorship and this can be their first practice.
Children, yes. I didn't comment on them.
I'm only pointing out that in this spesific case it had nothing to do with the robustness of the application.
More specifically: A better application might have warned you about the failing part so that you won't have to go looking for it. Fixing the problem would still include either replacing OpenDNS or working around it.
In the era before the omnibox, I personally can't see much in the way of "breaking things" on account of OpenDNS. Doesn't mean you and others can't disagree with that, but it's not as cut and dried as your statement seems to imply.
It's ridiculous to say we broke things for many people. Our growth numbers tell a different story. Doesn't mean DNS nerds didn't like creating an account to re-enable standard nxdomain behavior, but it didn't cause issues for most people.
We made real money from ads, enough to be profitable with a decent-sized (20+) team. But we never saw a way to go from 5m to 50m or 500m with ads though. And we never loved the ads. I just never thought it aligned our interests with our customers in the right way. I get that Google has figured it out, and Facebook and Twitter sort of have, but we couldn't, and didn't want to.
Plus, at the time, you have to recall the browser landscape was wildly different. In fact, it's very possible that we may have created the eventuality of today by doing what we did. Chrome didn't even exist when we started. There was no omnibus. I demo'ed our service to Sundar Pichai back in 2007.