Re:No more ads
by asdfaoeu on Friday May 30, 2014 @03:36AM
(#7820668)
Give me a break they offered a service for free. Sure if they were an ISP I'd agree with you because your paying for the service but otherwise just don't use it?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
It's bait and switch though. They claimed they offered a DNS service, but by deliberately breaking the spec, they offered something that wasn't a DNS service. It was something, but not DNS. I don't care how much it cost, it's dishonest.
err, what would you call it then?
how about notDNS? though notDNS implies they don't serve domain names. How about, openDNS?
Actually, I don't like that one either, that implies they are open source.
How about, gimpDNS. There, I can get behind that one.
Re:No more ads
by IgorPartola on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:41AM
(#7821221)
Sure. I offer a service for free. I will back up all your email! Just forward it all to me and I will make sure you can get it back!
Does that sound like a harmless service? OpenDNS knowingly and deliberately broke the Internet for its customers. I have actually spent time debugging issues it caused just to find that the client was using their resolvers. They were not a free service, they were actively harmful. I am glad the profits are no longer there for them to keep up this malicious practice.
As davidu mentioned, you can make a free account on the site and restore normal NXDOMAIN behavior. Non-broken DNS was opt-in, but it was still a free service.