News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by jzwinck on Thursday May 29, 2014 @10:43AM (#7816430)
This article is ridiculous. While there are certain areas (e.g. pattern matching) where a typical English major is likely to do well, rigorous logical thinking of the sort needed when we program computers is simply not developed as well as it is in CS, EE, and various other programs.

As a third-year undergrad I took a 400-level course on logic from the humanities department. I remember being blown away by how inept the average students there seemed at first. They were simply unprepared for the torrent of proofs, deductions, tautologies, De Morgan's laws, etc. The way of thinking required to get through that class easily was one which most second-year CS students had, but not the student body at large. I came to realize I had been groomed for this class for years already.

In a 200-level CS course we learned to use Karnaugh Maps. This was not optional. There is a difference between analyzing digital logic and writing papers outside CS. Not that one is better than the other, but you don't hear CS folks claiming they're well suited for writing poetry.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by gr3yh47 on Thursday May 29, 2014 @10:59AM (#7816533)
in fact, the author attempt to tear down an argument completely of his own invention:

'But then I read Bock’s rationale, and that’s when I nearly lose a mouthful of Cheerios: Unlike English—and presumably other non-STEM fields—computer science “signals a rigor in your thinking,” an ability “to think in a formal and logical and structured way.” He said what?'

from this the author decided to read that ONLY CS majors can learn logical thinking, but Bock's statement was really that CS inherently signals this because CS is entirely predicated on this type of thinking no matter where you learn it.

I'm getting sick of these whiny stupid articles popping up on the front page, like there is a decline of logic in the site votership itself. The amazon tantrum yesterday and now this eesh

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by dllthomas on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:13AM (#7816601)
"like there is a decline of logic in the site votership itself"

I assume it's all the English majors.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by gr3yh47 on Thursday May 29, 2014 @02:13PM (#7817699)
xD
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by vehementi on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:18AM (#7816635)
This would be a legitimate critique if Bock were saying "Here's how I screen through 100,000 resumes". Your interpretation would serve as a good heuristic. But that's not what we're talking about: he implied that, all things being equal, he would hire a B student majoring in CS over an A student majoring in English because of "signalling" when comparing two candidates he had to choose from.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by tomp on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:47AM (#7816813)
But that's exactly what "signalling" means - and Bock has decided (presumably based on experience and statistics) that the positive signal of CS is and B student is stronger than the positive signal of A student of English.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by dkuntz2 on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:48AM (#7816815)
Define "all things being equal", because unless the CS major and English major have both taken exactly the same courses (in which case, why aren't they both double CS/English majors?), things aren't equal.

If you've got your two students, and they're both applying for a software development position, wouldn't you rather have the person who's taken formal CS courses? Even if the English major has worked on some software projects on the side, the CS major probably has some experience with data structures and algorithms, and being able to think about those.

I'm not saying an English major can't do the same things, or that because someone studied CS they're better than anyone else. What I'm trying to get at is that your average B student who studied CS is probably a better candidate for a technical position than your average A student who studied English.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by gefh on Thursday May 29, 2014 @01:14PM (#7817304)
I'm assuming this is about engineering hires. If they both interviewed well they'd both get hired. Of course, getting past the resume screening is not equally likely, but I'd expect an English major applying for an engineering role to have something more than their not-entirely-relevant degree on the resume to make up for it.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by nnq on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:25AM (#7816684)
How true and ironical. The author manages to prove exactly his inability to think logically by misunderstanding what Block was saying. And then he goes on being reactive instead of providing any meaningful arguments, even against his straw man...

I see this mode of thinking very often in people that I call "mud-minds" (shortly, people incapable of clear, cold, abstract and detached thinking, or at least incapable of performing thinking in a way that exhibits all these 4 attributes simultaneously, without loosing their intuition while they do this), even the well educated ones with probably high IQs: they totally fail to understand the real meaning of a message, and attack strawman ideas or follow dead-end reasoning paths, even if they do this with great skill and intelligence and the arguments they use may actually be very logical.

The sad thing is that seeing someone with a CS and math background think this way destroys my hope that exposing children early on to technical, abstract and logical thinking can prevent them from becoming "mud-minds". This even makes me pessimistic about humanity's future :(

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by williamcotton on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:04AM (#7816556)
> They were simply unprepared for the torrent of proofs, deductions, tautologies, De Morgan's laws, etc.

All of which I never see used in a professional capacity for the vast majority of software developers.

What I do see used quite often is the ability to communicate to customers or other engineers in a clear, succinct and enjoyable manner using the English language.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by radmuzom on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:25AM (#7816681)
Technical people often underestimate the value of good communication. Technical does not necessarily refer to programming, but also to other fields like statistical financial modelling (which I do). And complain about the fact that people less qualified than them are in management. I'm not suggesting that communication should be the sole criteria for management - a lot of software companies need programmers at the helm (as advocated by Joel Spolsky), but there are situations where an analytical liberal arts major with maturity and leadership skills will do much better than someone whose primary skills is technology.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by smtddr on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:31AM (#7816730)
>>Technical people often underestimate the value of good communication.

Not just underestimate, even outright condemn. Like the people who defend Linus's form of "communication" on the kernel mailing list as "to the point" or "efficient". Anyone who thinks that's an acceptable style of communication from/to any human being is wrong and a perfect example of why the tech companies in general should probably make their engineers attend a speech and/or social relationships class. Somewhere along the line, "engineering culture" decided any communication protocols outside of TCP, UDP and syscalls are a waste of time.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by philwelch on Thursday May 29, 2014 @12:30PM (#7817033)
Linus excels at communication. He makes it crystal clear what he's trying to convey and the standard he's setting, and has coordinated the development of the most widely-deployed kernel on earth entirely via email for decades. He communicates perfectly well.

He's an asshole on occasion, but that's not the same as communicating poorly.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by smtddr on Thursday May 29, 2014 @07:04PM (#7819170)
Completely disagree. I don't care how popular his kernel is; his communication style is ridiculous and the fact that there are so many devs that have no problem working for him isn't a sign that his communication is good.... it's a sign all the people working with him don't realize, or ignore, or accept his ridiculous behavior and is just an example of why the tech industry needs a communications/social relations course for a lot of engineers.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by philwelch on Thursday May 29, 2014 @09:31PM (#7819662)
Are you judging by results or by your own subjective taste? Because I find results more interesting (and persuasive).
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by smtddr on Thursday May 29, 2014 @10:05PM (#7819773)
Even if maximum efficiency is achieved by his style of communication, I still don't agree with it. Efficiency is not more important than being civil.

"Ends don't justify the means" kinda thing... but I know I'm not going to convince you in this thread; and you're definitely not going to convince me otherwise. There are too many rude people in tech that don't know how to communicate properly with people. Rudeness has somehow become acceptable in the tech-industry so they can't see the problem they have.... and it _is_ a problem.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by philwelch on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:07PM (#7820023)
I'm trying to draw a distinction between effective communication and not being an asshole. They are different problems. One is a problem of ability and the other is a problem of temperament.

Conversely to Linus, someone can be perfectly polite and pleasant but fail to communicate effectively because they don't convey any meaningful information. Such a person would have poor communication skills, but not be an asshole. Linus has good communication skills, but is an asshole.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by lloeki on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:23AM (#7816666)
> All of which I never see used in a professional capacity for the vast majority of software developers.

Anecdotal irony: not 24 hours ago a colleague and I had to reverse engineer a hairy mess of deeply nested if/then/else clauses that should not exist that turned out to be composed mostly of tautologies. I definitely wish to throw books at some people, preferably of the steel-bound, razor sharp edged kind.

Conclusion: you're not drawing Karnaugh tables daily in front of you, but having manipulated the fundamental rules of logic has trained your neural net and makes you much more effective at solving logic problems in a wink and not write crap code, and also simply able to debug stuff efficiently, if at all. I am regularly aghast at people drawing completely invalid conclusions from broken "common sense" logic propositions (A=>B therefore B=>A, or various other syllogisms).

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by godzilla82 on Thursday May 29, 2014 @02:51PM (#7817894)
I feel, that no amount of manipulation of fundamental rules of logic can help the people you are aghast at. The ones who infer the broken "common sense" logic propositions(a=>b implies b=>a). Also, I know a lot more of non CS people who have excellent analytical skills than the ones with a CS background.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by philwelch on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:29AM (#7816712)
It's easier to find CS majors who can communicate effectively than English majors who have the logic skills to read, write, and debug code. Especially at the level demanded by a company like Google.

If you're a consultancy that writes CRUD apps I can see emphasizing communication skills over technical skills but you're not Google.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by PhasmaFelis on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:43AM (#7816795)
> It's easier to find CS majors who can communicate effectively than English majors who have the logic skills to read, write, and debug code.

Is it? I've met quite a lot of coders who think they're good communicators but really, really aren't.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by philwelch on Thursday May 29, 2014 @12:23PM (#7817000)
And I've met--and work with--many developers who do communicate effectively. The only English majors I've met with any technical chops were CS double majors though.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by dkuntz2 on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:50AM (#7816825)
Great, but they're not the ones evaluating if they have good communications skills, the people hiring them are...
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by mathetic on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:14AM (#7816610)
That is simply because the top of the stack in our field is full of application developers and not computer architects. I fail to see how quantity becomes more important than quality.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by thathonkey on Thursday May 29, 2014 @12:00PM (#7816875)
What is your point exactly? It sounds like what you're suggesting is simply not practical (that all developers should be well-versed in all facets of software development, even those skills only employed by a minority of developers).
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by delinquentme on Thursday May 29, 2014 @12:07PM (#7816910)
A screaming example of academic signaling, but where the "signal" is only _just_ stronger than the noise.

Karnaugh Maps: While I love vocab as much as any other kid out there. We're not calling them " colored-truth-tables " which is what the fuck it is. You're advocating that one is more rigorous than the other. However the only thing which is actually being conveyed is usage OF A TRUTH TABLE!

Academics gleefully accept this more specific vocabulary as a proxy for context knowledge.

Its a (fucking) shit workaround.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by gr3yh47 on Thursday May 29, 2014 @02:15PM (#7817705)
how so?

CS is rooted entirely in the qualities he is looking for. English isn't.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by Iftheshoefits on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:37AM (#7816763)
> you don't hear CS folks claiming they're well suited for writing poetry.

It may be technically true, but the dismissive "english/humanities is easy" narrative that is (or, in my day, was--it seems it still is) extremely popular in the STEM undergraduate community carries a kind of implicit claim of exactly that sort. Stating that something is easy necessarily implies the person making the statement thinks he could, with some relatively lesser effort than he applies to his current focus, achieve comparable results to those who focus on that something.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by jonnathanson on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:32AM (#7816733)
I was with you until the last sentence, which packed a low and somewhat unfair punch. There's plenty to do with an English degree besides writing poetry. Law is a typical exit path. So are lucrative positions in media, entertainment, publishing, journalism, and public policy. To excel at these fields, one needs to be pretty smart. It's a different kind of smart from the kind you need in technology jobs. No question about that. But one is not inherently superior to the other. And practitioners of one path are not incapable of pursuing the other.

There's a trend towards convergence, however, and formal logic has had a profound effect on the English curriculum in the last several decades. Hofstadter, Tarski, Quine, Levi-Strauss, et al., are becoming required reading in forward-thinking English curricula. Your typical English course isn't going to touch the type of logic discussed in your typical CS course. But advanced linguistics is, more or less, formal systemics. Unfortunately, you can encounter a fair amount of fluff on the way there.

English education is in need of an overhaul, and it's starting to get one. But there should be no battle between the humanities and the sciences. Instead, we should do a better job bringing the average in the humanities up to par and rigor.

We should also do a better job coaching students on career paths before we ask them to choose majors. If you're studying English because you like reading books, and you have no clue what you want to do when you graduate, you're in for a tough road ahead. If you're studying English because you want to get into Yale Law School, or write for the New York Times, or become the next Michael Lewis, that's great. (But in that case, you'd better be good.)

Ultimately, what matters isn't the content of the two paths, but the application of them. CS is a directly practical degree. You can put to work what you learn almost immediately and unambiguously. You can trace a more or less direct path between the input (education) and the output (skill). English is more indirect. You can learn extremely valuable skills in an English program, but those skills aren't immediately applicable to any particular job. That's because English is a really old curriculum, which predates the modern job market. If you want to make something of an English degree, you'll need to develop skills above and beyond what you learn in the classroom. Generally speaking, schools don't do a great job teaching those ancillary skills. And so the English degree is not, in itself, sufficient for positions to which it's very well suited.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by StavrosK on Thursday May 29, 2014 @12:07PM (#7816911)
I think you're reading too much into it. I took it to mean that writing poetry (or, at least, doing it well) is something that requires many years of practice, and that isn't something anyone can just pick up.

I didn't perceive a slight at all, it seemed like a very fair analogy to me. "Writing a novel" would be the same.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by justindz on Thursday May 29, 2014 @01:43PM (#7817505)
I read it the way you apparently intended to write it. In college, getting to where I could write and get published poems that weren't a personal embarrassment took more or less the same amount of study and practice as getting my CS degree. I think mastering either craft would be a comparable endeavor and accomplishment (though one would pay much better).

The nice thing about compilers is they tell you when your code has a problem. There's no equivalent barrier to posting awful poetry-drivel on Facebook ;-)

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by enraged_camel on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:23AM (#7816668)
>>Not that one is better than the other, but you don't hear CS folks claiming they're well suited for writing poetry.

Just wait until you see the headline: "Join our startup to disrupt the poetry industry!"

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by tlogan on Thursday May 29, 2014 @12:08PM (#7816916)
It is interesting article. But I think that it emphasizes one thing which hurts companies growth. Let's put Google aside - because this is not about Google.

The companies end up having hiring techniques and processes (and subconscious biases for hiring as result of these) which might work well before but they might do not work for today. This is very hard thing to solve and problems becomes obvious to outside world when companies try to get into new field / area.

Some companies have head of recruiting reporting directly to CEO to fix these kind of problems. Some companies will do acquisitions.

Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by api on Thursday May 29, 2014 @10:57AM (#7816518)
I'm not sure about typical English majors vs. CS majors, but in a cognitive sense there is quite a bit of overlap in certain areas. Writing and high-comprehension reading involves the deep understanding and manipulation of language. So does programming.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by stuki on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:22AM (#7816657)
All "language" is not the same. To be reliably and consistently machine executable, a language needs to facilitate manipulations that are logically rigorous. While in a language for general human communication, emphasis needs to be on manipulations that are more fluid and aesthetic in nature. Facility with one does not necessarily translate well to another. Particularly in the English -> Programming direction, which makes it doubly dangerous to assume it does, when hiring for STEM type jobs. Extreme aspies and savants aside, most good programmers can communicate well in English, in the sense they can formulate their intent precisely. While the converse is much, much rarer.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by Alupis on Thursday May 29, 2014 @11:18AM (#7816634)
Yes, but CS majors come out of school with some level of understanding about how computing works... not just how to write code.
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by radmuzom on Thursday May 29, 2014 @10:51AM (#7816484)
I sort of agree with your overall sentiment, but the reason you found the average student from humanities inept is because the good students generally opt for STEM courses - presumably because these courses allow you to make much more money after you pass out. I also happen to believe that the world would be a much better place if a larger number of bright students study humanities subjects - especially history and literature.
[deleted]
Re:What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand Abou... by bigdubs on Thursday May 29, 2014 @10:49AM (#7816474)
Yours is "oh noetry".