News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by cup on Sunday May 25, 2014 @09:30PM (#7798297)
I think the author has made a number of errors in there post and seems to gloss over the numerous social problems that arise from alcohol consumption. Th reason Alcohol is consumed by a significant portion of the population is because its a drug that society doesn't perceive as a drug. It carries all the negative physiological and social effects other drugs have but it doesn't carry the negative association of being what we consider 'a drug'.

Yes It's a form of social lubrication and it might be pleasant to consume but its efficacy as a form of verifying trustworthiness is tenuous as best. Most high functioning alcoholics would be able to maintain an air of trustworthiness which is why alcohol itself can be such a destructive force.

It's interesting that alcohol is explicitly banned in Islam You could use the approximately 1.1 billion muslim(probably closer to 500-800 million practicising) population as a control abstaining group and look at whether communities that consume alcohol have a higher propensity to trust each other or not.

Edit: At the end of the day I think regardless of any philosophical debates the simplest answer might be that people consume alcohol because being drunk feels good.

Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by nemothekid on Sunday May 25, 2014 @09:42PM (#7798324)
>Th reason Alcohol is consumed by a significant portion of the population is because its a drug that society doesn't perceive as a drug.

Thats a rather modern view for a practice that may be as old as humanity itself. Your comment doesn't explain why Alcohol was popular when cocaine and other opiates didn't carry negative associations.

Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by nl on Sunday May 25, 2014 @10:47PM (#7798470)
Alcohol (in the form of beer) was - for some periods in history - more safe than drinking water. The beer making process (boiling water as well as the alcohol in it) was good at killing bacteria[1]. Bacteria in water was a pretty significant problem for towns without a proper sewage system.

(Note that you'll find some internet sites claiming this is a myth. I don't find their arguments compelling at all: most seem to argue that water was drunk as well - which is no doubt true.)

[1] http://www.westsussextoday.co.uk/news/county-news/latest-new...

Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by nikatwork on Monday May 26, 2014 @02:23AM (#7798909)
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by nl on Monday May 26, 2014 @02:53AM (#7798950)
Boiling water before drinking it does have a positive effect on safety. That's beyond dispute.

I'm not one of those who claim beer was drunk instead of water - I'm just pointing out that the more positive association of alcohol compare to other drugs does have some kind of possible historic and scientific basis.

Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by chimeracoder on Sunday May 25, 2014 @10:36PM (#7798444)
> why Alcohol was popular when cocaine and other opiates didn't carry negative associations

We've rewritten history to help ignore this, but they were quite popular.

Laudanum used to be heavily used in the US, and even Sherlock Holmes was written to be a regular, casual user of cocaine (Dr. Watson viewed it as "his only vice", such as a smoker of tobacco pipes, but had no medical objection to it).

Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by pdonis on Monday May 26, 2014 @12:47AM (#7798734)
> had no medical objection to it

Actually, he did. Watson tells Holmes early on (in The Sign of the Four, I think) that using cocaine might damage his powers of observation and deduction; and in the stories after Holmes' return, Watson mentions several times that he felt obliged as a medical man to wean Holmes from the drug, and that he gets worried when there is a long period without Holmes having a case because Holmes might be tempted to start using the drug again.

Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by cup on Sunday May 25, 2014 @10:14PM (#7798394)
Cocaine and other opiates have been popular, only recently have they been sidelined.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by downer73 on Monday May 26, 2014 @03:04AM (#7798968)
Yeah, gee, I wonder why? Maybe it's because one has a tendency to induce heart attacks, and the other group is treacherously addictive.

But, consider that cocaine is a "new world" drug, specific to the South American continent, as an indigenous herbal extract, mostly until the 19th century, when highly purified extacts became a popular part of western society.

Meanwhile use of opiates dates back to ancient times, given that Opium is dead simple to produce. But again, it was really in the 19th century when good equipment, and precise measuing tools permitted chemists and drugists to purify highly addictive perparations of the wider variety of drugs. Prior to that, the poppy's medicinal qualities were known and used, but expertise and well-crafted instruments which could readily facilitate powerful extracts weren't as widespread. Otherwise, people were limited to whatever was grown locally, and would be required to cultivate and harvest their own supply, instead of relying on trade.

Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by adrianN on Sunday May 25, 2014 @10:15PM (#7798398)
Alcohol is super simple to obtain. You just need some carbohydrate and time.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by collyw on Monday May 26, 2014 @02:59PM (#7801032)
Was alcohol cheaper / easier to produce?
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by chrischen on Sunday May 25, 2014 @09:45PM (#7798330)
The other drugs are addictive.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by rosser on Sunday May 25, 2014 @09:55PM (#7798353)
It turns out, alcohol is actually more addictive than nearly all of the "other drugs", and it's one of the only drugs for which the withdrawal symptoms can be fatal.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by chrischen on Monday May 26, 2014 @02:42PM (#7800971)
I'd love to read the research on this.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by bignaj on Sunday May 25, 2014 @09:53PM (#7798348)
Not sure if you are being serious but... ever seen http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcoholism ?
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by ekianjo on Sunday May 25, 2014 @09:36PM (#7798307)
> banned in Islam You could use the approximately 1.1 billion muslim

It's not because it's banned Muslims don't drink it. At least in some places. I have a friend who made numerous trips to Saudi Arabia, where the Muslim Law is supposed to be at its strictest form, yet you just need to drive out of town to find alcohol and access to other forbidden forms of pleasure.

It's just like if you said "so they banned prostitution so it does not exist anymore". People always find ways to access things they want to get.

Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by cup on Sunday May 25, 2014 @10:15PM (#7798399)
I'm confused. Muslims don't drink because it is banned. Some Muslims drinking doesn't distinguish from the fact that its banned, just like some Muslims who murder people doesn't mean Murder isn't banned.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by ekianjo on Sunday May 25, 2014 @10:21PM (#7798409)
I don't think you understand what I'm saying. I was referring to the fact that in Saudi Arabia, it's not a super niche minority drinking alcohol. It's readily available, and everyone knows where it is.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by cup on Sunday May 25, 2014 @10:35PM (#7798440)
Everyone who wants to know where it is does. Alcohol in Saudi is like cocaine in America.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by ekianjo on Sunday May 25, 2014 @10:43PM (#7798457)
Look, have you been in Saudi Arabia? If you know everything better than anyone else, then there's no point to comment on anything.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by cup on Sunday May 25, 2014 @10:54PM (#7798486)
Well yeah I used to live there. I'm just sharing opinions and ideas thats all. I'm not intending to offend.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by dang on Monday May 26, 2014 @12:19AM (#7798681)
Please don't be rude on Hacker News.
Re:Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthine... by ekianjo on Monday May 26, 2014 @12:54AM (#7798748)
I didn't mean to be rude, but point noted.