> Of course, overtime a subreddit becomes a default or gets too many subscribers... but it's still a decent solution.
And then it spawns off one or more new subreddits, based on the desires of the users. I feel that's a pretty good way to handle the situation.
I think it'll be interesting to see how growth affects Hacker News. I'm still very impressed with the quality of the articles and comments (yes, there are some bad ones here and there, but compared to most sites HN is excellent)... I think the downvote threshold for HN has actually been quite successful in encouraging people to post useful comments. It gives a goal for people with low-karma to strive for, thus encouraging them to post better content. I think a more extensive reward system like this has potential for creating a better community.