Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by InclinedPlane on Sunday May 18, 2014 @07:19PM
(#7764837)
This is just an interesting experiment, nothing more. It's already well established that high energy photons can create matter/anti-matter particle pairs, it's done all the time in the laboratory in a variety of conditions. However, there are some subtleties behind the process. A single photon in empty space won't necessarily spontaneously cause pair-production, you need a suitable environment for it to happen in. Typically this happens within matter, when high energy gamma rays travel through a physical material. And, indeed, this is an important process in stellar stability for extremely high mass stars. When extremely massive stars (130 to 250 solar masses) get old enough their cores heat up to such high temperatures that the glow from the hot matter includes photons with energies high enough to cause pair production. When enough of the thermal energy of the star's core gets dumped into photons of such energies the star becomes unstable, because the photon pressure is reduced due to the production of electrons and positrons (which re-annihilate and produce photons again, but there's a time gap). The instability results in a supernova/hypernova/gamma-ray-burst.
Anyway, in theory high energy photons should be able to cause pair-production even without interacting with matter, such as merely interacting with other photons. And that's what this experiment is designed to test.
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by jessriedel on Sunday May 18, 2014 @08:18PM
(#7765033)
> It's already well established that high energy photons can create matter/anti-matter particle pairs, it's done all the time in the laboratory in a variety of conditions.
Well yes, but the important thing here is that free (i.e. on-shell) photons are being collided with each other to create matter. (Think of one laser pointed at another laser.) This has been done before, but only relatively recently and certainly not routinely. Here's one place:
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by jds375 on Sunday May 18, 2014 @04:10PM
(#7764214)
Apparently the embargo for this paper has not yet been lifted. It says: "Once embargo has lifted, the paper can be downloaded at : http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphoton.2014.95 "[1]
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by stephengillie on Sunday May 18, 2014 @03:07PM
(#7763962)
When the photons collide, the researchers believe that a significant number of them will turn from light to matter — more specifically, into an electron and a positron.
So we could use this within our warp core to power our warp field generators?
How much energy would we have to expend to separate the positron from the electron and keep them separated? What does that give us in terms of energy storage efficiency, compared to storing electrical charge within a lithium battery?
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by noobermin on Sunday May 18, 2014 @04:57PM
(#7764395)
In this case the energy that goes into creating the e+e- pairs far outweighs the energy you get out. For example, given that this is Quantum Mechanics, there is a non-zero but not necessarily close to one probability of creating a pair from a given pair of photons. One could imagine the other light that didn't interact would just escape to the environment. You can conceptualize this as an photon produced to pair created efficiency, and I don't see it for any reason being very big.
Then again, I'm not sure I understand the experiment, for example, I'm not sure how a blackbody spectrum helps in the breit-wheeler process. I think that the light colliding at a perpendicular incidence helps, but other than that, I can't see how the spectrum of radiation matters...like how is using a blackbody spectrum is better than, say, a monochromatic laser? I think I'd have to look at the paper once it gets out.
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by sitkack on Monday May 19, 2014 @12:47AM
(#7765749)
I am going to cite Clarke's [0] first law.
| When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong.
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by stephengillie on Sunday May 18, 2014 @04:09PM
(#7764209)
That's an extremely pessimistic reaction! I think such a device will at least be possible, and that we'll eventually engineer the energy density of it down to be comparably efficient.
And we've got to power the warp field with something, so what are our most energy-dense options?
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by darkmighty on Sunday May 18, 2014 @05:52PM
(#7764569)
Storing antimatter is an engineering nightmare. It's hard enough to store chemicals that react with lots of things, imagine storing something which reacts releasing insane energies with all matter. You have to confine it perfectly using external fields. In other words, not an easy task. (CERN has a trap that was demonstrated to have formed just a few antihydrogen atoms)
Not that we have any applications for it with the current production efficiency.
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by jessriedel on Sunday May 18, 2014 @08:11PM
(#7765014)
To my understanding, this isn't correct. Storing anti-matter isn't really that hard. The Tevatron would store anti-protons in the recycler for hours, and I'm sure if it was important we could engineer much more efficient mechanisms.
No, the hard part is creating the anti-matter in the first place and then cooling it down to a reasonable temperature at which it can be stored. All of our mechanisms for creating anti-matter generate anti-particles traveling at fantastic, highly relativistic speeds (and also consume much, much more energy to create then they contain in mass energy). Cooling them down without loosing them all to annihilation is very difficult. But once they're cool, it's not so bad.
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by darkmighty on Monday May 19, 2014 @09:14PM
(#7770758)
Oh I'm sure you're right, didn't know that (my knowledge comes from years of exaggerated Scientific American articles :) ).
I suppose the cooling is electromagnetic, the whole process must be really difficult! Cool it while keeping those atoms from interacting from stray particles if the vacuum isn't perfect.
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by al2o3cr on Sunday May 18, 2014 @07:11PM
(#7764805)
Perhaps more importantly, there's the messy consequence that those external fields only work on charged particles.
You could (in principle) keep positrons and antiprotons together in a very hot plasma under magnetic confinement, but every pair that binds together into a neutral hydrogen atom can immediately escape and annihilate - turning carefully-stored fuel into gamma rays...
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by BugBrother on Sunday May 18, 2014 @07:01PM
(#7764778)
Antimatter production/storage is an old subject.
This is a book from 1988 by a favorite author Robert L Forward (the worst author from which I regularly bought books in hardcover; I just read them for the physics).
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by al2o3cr on Sunday May 18, 2014 @07:21PM
(#7764848)
Van de Graff generators are certainly useful for the first 20 MeV or so, but the source photons generated by the electron beam in this case are >500 MeV.
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by im3w1l on Sunday May 18, 2014 @04:10PM
(#7764215)
Because earth is overpopulated and we will have to settle new worlds. Because sooner or later earth will go FUBAR, and it'd be nice if not ALL humanity dies.
Because it's safer if we find the Aliens before they find us.
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by smtddr on Sunday May 18, 2014 @04:14PM
(#7764231)
You think that's the only, or even main, reason we explore the universe?
What if we do it because it's in our nature to explore? Just pure curiosity? To increase our understanding of existence and evolve into something more? Also, this concept of it's safer to find aliens before they find us sounds like you're already of the mindset of war and you want a tactical advantage over something that you've never seen or know anything about. I really hope not everyone thinks of exploring the universe as just another military mapping of strategic attack/defense positions. If the human race is still being driven by fear and war when star-trek-style travel becomes possible, then maybe it's better we just die right here rather than export our madness throughout the galaxy.
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by BugBrother on Sunday May 18, 2014 @07:16PM
(#7764825)
Uhh... I voted you up for the first part.
The second part was simply naive. Please consider game theory.
Yours (and mine) moral is from a society with a functioning police force, rule of law and state violence monopoly. Without that, there is a clan society, where your only security is that others (generally relatives) will revenge you. A form of terror balance. Out moral just doesn't work there, since to avoid violence you have to make people believe you are ready to inflict it.
(I am unaware of a third alternative to state violence monopoly and clan societies. There are obviously places in between, with organized crime (south Italy, Mexico?). Please educate me if I miss something basic?)
Let me take an example:
There is no world police since Obama seems to be abdicating USA's partial role, countries now live in an analogue of a clan society (e.g. do alliances for protection from aggression).
Consider how Russia and China are starting the jingoism garbage again. How do you know other countries/species won't?
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by BugBrother on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:08AM
(#7766481)
I assume you're trolling, but will waste a few more minutes:
Game theory is used for evolution too, so you're a creationist?
A longer answer would be along the lines of:
Humans have a wide range of possible behaviours, the trick is to organize society so we get a "nice" place (i.e. it is not "paying" to be non-"nice", please note quotes for complex PhD thesis definitions). If you're not able to see the world, your decision will have harmful effects according to your own morals. In short, your absolute moral judgements is a problem as much as Putin...
(I just wish that there were some way of educating away moral condemnation of people which refuse to understand stuff which goes against their ideology.)
Knowing idealists, in some generations people like you will want to genetically modify people to follow your morals -- Socialist "new human" style. We know how that goes, not only from science fiction.
But I already wrote an answer and got a non sequitur.
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by BugBrother on Monday May 19, 2014 @08:13AM
(#7767014)
On consideration, I was probably trolled.
I pointed out that without rule of law, societies generally becomes clan societies. Out of pure game theory. And discussed why and how we know to avoid that.
You quote part of my description of clan societies -- and condemned humanity.
If you're not a teenager, that is too stupid to be anything but bad trolling.
Re:Scientists propose collider that could turn light into ma...
by stephengillie on Sunday May 18, 2014 @03:03PM
(#7763948)
How sure are you? What kinds of matter? What exceptions are there on the process? Is this a more effective form of 3d printing? Can pizza be created from light, and if so, how? Can we turn the matter back into light? Can we turn organic material into light?
We're definitely a long way from "Tea, Earl Grey, Hot", but it's cool to see people looking into these sorts of things.
Anyway, in theory high energy photons should be able to cause pair-production even without interacting with matter, such as merely interacting with other photons. And that's what this experiment is designed to test.
Well yes, but the important thing here is that free (i.e. on-shell) photons are being collided with each other to create matter. (Think of one laser pointed at another laser.) This has been done before, but only relatively recently and certainly not routinely. Here's one place:
http://www.desy.de/~telnov/ggtesla/
[1] http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2014-05/icl-sdh051514...
So we could use this within our warp core to power our warp field generators?
How much energy would we have to expend to separate the positron from the electron and keep them separated? What does that give us in terms of energy storage efficiency, compared to storing electrical charge within a lithium battery?
Then again, I'm not sure I understand the experiment, for example, I'm not sure how a blackbody spectrum helps in the breit-wheeler process. I think that the light colliding at a perpendicular incidence helps, but other than that, I can't see how the spectrum of radiation matters...like how is using a blackbody spectrum is better than, say, a monochromatic laser? I think I'd have to look at the paper once it gets out.
| When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong.
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarke's_three_laws
And we've got to power the warp field with something, so what are our most energy-dense options?
Not that we have any applications for it with the current production efficiency.
No, the hard part is creating the anti-matter in the first place and then cooling it down to a reasonable temperature at which it can be stored. All of our mechanisms for creating anti-matter generate anti-particles traveling at fantastic, highly relativistic speeds (and also consume much, much more energy to create then they contain in mass energy). Cooling them down without loosing them all to annihilation is very difficult. But once they're cool, it's not so bad.
I suppose the cooling is electromagnetic, the whole process must be really difficult! Cool it while keeping those atoms from interacting from stray particles if the vacuum isn't perfect.
You could (in principle) keep positrons and antiprotons together in a very hot plasma under magnetic confinement, but every pair that binds together into a neutral hydrogen atom can immediately escape and annihilate - turning carefully-stored fuel into gamma rays...
This is a book from 1988 by a favorite author Robert L Forward (the worst author from which I regularly bought books in hardcover; I just read them for the physics).
http://books.google.ro/books/about/Mirror_matter.html?id=GS4...
It was based on his report for NASA. I read the review: "He took the giggle factor out of antimatter"(!).
The main point was that if machines were built to create antimatter (instead of Nobel prizes), it wasn't so crazy to produce.
But as people are explaining to you, storage [of "large" masses like microgram] is still not solved. Afaik, at least.
The most energy to mass ratio is antimatter, which is why it is chosen as the substance for Star Trek TNG to power the warp core.
Second place is helium-3 if you count helium-3 fusion.
What if we do it because it's in our nature to explore? Just pure curiosity? To increase our understanding of existence and evolve into something more? Also, this concept of it's safer to find aliens before they find us sounds like you're already of the mindset of war and you want a tactical advantage over something that you've never seen or know anything about. I really hope not everyone thinks of exploring the universe as just another military mapping of strategic attack/defense positions. If the human race is still being driven by fear and war when star-trek-style travel becomes possible, then maybe it's better we just die right here rather than export our madness throughout the galaxy.
The second part was simply naive. Please consider game theory.
Yours (and mine) moral is from a society with a functioning police force, rule of law and state violence monopoly. Without that, there is a clan society, where your only security is that others (generally relatives) will revenge you. A form of terror balance. Out moral just doesn't work there, since to avoid violence you have to make people believe you are ready to inflict it.
(I am unaware of a third alternative to state violence monopoly and clan societies. There are obviously places in between, with organized crime (south Italy, Mexico?). Please educate me if I miss something basic?)
Let me take an example:
There is no world police since Obama seems to be abdicating USA's partial role, countries now live in an analogue of a clan society (e.g. do alliances for protection from aggression).
Consider how Russia and China are starting the jingoism garbage again. How do you know other countries/species won't?
tl;dr: Don't take your moral instinct for logic.
So basically... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Butter_Battle_Book
If this is truly all the human race is capable of; living in a perpetual stalemate of attack-power then we should just stay on our earth and perish.
Game theory is used for evolution too, so you're a creationist?
A longer answer would be along the lines of:
Humans have a wide range of possible behaviours, the trick is to organize society so we get a "nice" place (i.e. it is not "paying" to be non-"nice", please note quotes for complex PhD thesis definitions). If you're not able to see the world, your decision will have harmful effects according to your own morals. In short, your absolute moral judgements is a problem as much as Putin...
(I just wish that there were some way of educating away moral condemnation of people which refuse to understand stuff which goes against their ideology.)
Knowing idealists, in some generations people like you will want to genetically modify people to follow your morals -- Socialist "new human" style. We know how that goes, not only from science fiction.
But I already wrote an answer and got a non sequitur.
I pointed out that without rule of law, societies generally becomes clan societies. Out of pure game theory. And discussed why and how we know to avoid that.
You quote part of my description of clan societies -- and condemned humanity.
If you're not a teenager, that is too stupid to be anything but bad trolling.