Additionally, I think the need for maximization and edge-snapping in Windows is something that OSX handles very elegantly with Spaces.
No, I always want to maximize when I want to maximize. When I want to make text more readable, I have other options like zooming, snapping to an edge (in Windows or with an add-on to OS X) or using an application specific function such as "reading mode" or "print layout" (in Word).
Apple got window management completely wrong in my opinion. I mean, here's an example of a situation where an open window is orphaned from keyboard access of any kind:
http://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/128720/how-to-switc...
Does anybody know how to maximize a window with OS X?
You can bind a single keyboard shortcut to cycle through different possible positions for a single window size. For example, let's say you want a window to take up half the screen. In my case I press F2 once or twice depending if it's on the left or right half.
Another tool to script the GUI is Keyboard Maestro[1]. Almost any GUI action is possible such as closing a specific application on open or moving mouse to x,y. In my case, I set up a keyboard shortcut to activate iTerm (a almost terminal.app) and enter %run<up arrow><enter> to run a python script.
Both cost money but I couldn't live without it after the free trial ended.
[0, 1]:(I'm on mobile otherwise I would post a link; use google).
Agreed. Optimal layout is great, I can't recommend it highly enough. Watching the video on the site gives you a good idea of all the things you can do with it. Also the developer is very responsive to support questions and feature requests.
I have cmd+period set to activate moom, then just period (when moom is activated) set to maximize.
I use that key sequence dozens of times a day (I also have many others, and custom layouts, configured.. but that alone makes it worthwhile.)
Apple simply refuses to fix this basic stuff and I avoid interacting with the GUI bits of OS X as much as possible. At least you can finally resize windows from more than just the bottom right corner, that's a win I guess.
But you only need it if you're constantly resizing windows--which is not something most people do. Most people just set the window size they want once, because OS X remembers it per app.
Or, if the user wants the app full screen, they use the "full screen" button.
I love my OSX setup now, but if I was a "non-power-user", I think it would be completely unusable. Watching a typical Windows user try to maximize a window in OSX is pure pain.
Hit the + button: window gets a bit bigger, but not full screen.
Drag the window to the top: nothing happens.
Try to get to the edge of the window, and drag it out: RSI inducing frustration.
Windows seems to dominate as far as basic user usability goes on the windowing front. I would still find it completely unusable without the help of a windowing app like spectacle[1] or slate[2].
[1] http://spectacleapp.com/
[2] https://github.com/jigish/slate