News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:_why is no more by dazmax on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @03:17PM (#773521)
Re:_why is no more by pol on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @03:39PM (#773593)
What a mean-spirited thing to do to someone who just wanted to stay anonymous. It makes me sad and angry.

If this is the reason _why decided to pick up and leave, I understand it. We have his code, it will live on. Perhaps he will return in another guise.

Re:_why is no more by KVFinn on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @05:56PM (#773881)
>>What a mean-spirited thing to do to someone who just wanted to stay anonymous. If this is the reason _why decided to pick up and leave, I understand it.

If that's why he quit though it's going to have the opposite effect. I doubt more than a handful of people cared to look into _why's identity before today. I've read the guide, watched his talks, and read probably 80% of his blog articles, and I never knew his identity was some kind of secret. But with the disappearance it's now on everyone's mind.

There's a name for this effect but I can't think of it. It often comes up when somebody sues somebody else to remove some bit of information. The suit becomes a news story, and suddenly where 10 people might have known the information, the info is on the daily news as they cover the suit.

Re:_why is no more by cpach on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @06:18PM (#773923)
Re:_why is no more by gjm11 on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @06:17PM (#773919)
Re:_why is no more by projecktzero on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @06:14PM (#773913)
Re:_why is no more by ekyuri on Friday August 28, 2009 @12:30AM (#790736)
>>But with the disappearance it's now on everyone's mind.

Yeah I totally agree with you!!

Re:_why is no more by imbaczek on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @03:53PM (#773620)
mean-spirited? he gave the internet a challenge and somebody took it up, that's all.

oh, and it doesn't have to be his real name, too.

Re:_why is no more by scott_s on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @04:01PM (#773641)
By using a pseudonym, he implied he'd rather not be known by his given name. Telling the world his real then goes against his wishes. It is, at the very least, rude.

That someone outed him is inevitable. But that doesn't excuse the act.

Re:_why is no more by Semiapies on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @04:34PM (#773707)
Rude, I'd agree. No more, though - we're certainly not talking about exposing where Salman Rushdie's sleeping tonight. How rude, even, is an open question. This doesn't exactly rise to the level of pestering J. D. Salinger at his house.

Trying to be anonymous is one thing. Trying to remain anonymous while writing books and blogs and making public appearances, all under one common identity, is downright quixotic and just a bit presumptuous. Simply saying his preference was to be anonymous doesn't really create much of an obligation upon the rest of the world. You can't actively be a public figure and avoid being public.

Re:_why is no more by scott_s on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @04:47PM (#773736)
I actually agree with all of that, but it still requires one person to say "I want to out him!" And that person is being rude.
Re:_why is no more by Semiapies on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @05:13PM (#773790)
I agree. I'm just not sure how rude.

When there's a picture of you in your Wikipedia article from a public event you chose to speak at, you've made yourself just a "Hey, I know that guy!" away from being outed. At that point, I don't think you can claim it's a major affront when someone puts public information together to identify you.

I think the "who is why the lucky stiff" blog is odd and a bit dickish, but I'm not appalled.

I'm also skeptical of that purported outing as the cause of all this; this is one story I think that a bunch of people chatting and commenting are precisely the least well-suited way to work out the truth.

Re:_why is no more by eli on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @05:44PM (#773847)
For what it's worth, Why actively campaigned at one point to have his wikipedia page deleted.

Say what you will, but I'm pretty sure he was genuine in his effort not to be identified or celebrated.

Re:_why is no more by Semiapies on Thursday August 20, 2009 @11:05AM (#775177)
It's possible to be truly unidentified and uncelebrated. It's not possible to do so while maintaining a specific identity, especially after it becomes well-known. That he maintained this identity well after it gained celebrity wasn't exactly forced on him.
Re:_why is no more by ahoyhere on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @04:54PM (#773750)
Except that this enigma was something just about everyone treasured about him. He's a Ruby community treasure, our slightly twisted crown jewels. And the reason nobody tried harder before, or if they did they kept quiet, was out of respect for that cherishing.

He has always seemed a bit delicate, and that's why the rest of us always treated him gently. And he repaid us ten-fold with his quirky gifts.

This is like the rape of a beloved children's character. Not just learning that the Easter Bunny isn't real, but learning it when a drunken cop knocks out the kindly old man in the bunny costume, rips its furry head off, and pisses in it.

It's Just Not Done.

Just because the door is open, doesn't mean you have to walk through it. Adults consider the wider impact of their actions, rather than doing something just because "it's a challenge."

Re:_why is no more by Semiapies on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @05:20PM (#773803)
Personally, I like _why, "Jonathan Gillette", or whomever he actually is, because of his humor, talent, and kindly style.

As to the rest, it might be best not to assume we know what's going on in this situation.

Re:_why is no more by benjaminbooth on Thursday September 03, 2009 @11:54AM (#802709)
As a long-time Rubyist and admirer of _why, I completely agree with this.

The whole thing saddens me. I wonder how _why could ever repeat such a public endeavor, even under a new guise.

Re:_why is no more by petercooper on Thursday August 20, 2009 @10:54AM (#775155)
"Outing" is when you publish private information about someone. In this case the e-mail headers were both in public space. Highlighting something that's already public is not the same as breaking someone's confidentiality.
Re:_why is no more by astine on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @04:00PM (#773639)
Did he literally put out a challenge or do you actually see a person's privacy as a game?
Re:_why is no more by moe on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @09:13PM (#774210)
The wikipedia page shows an image of him apparently giving a public speech. If his privacy was so precious to him I don't think he would do things like that. Hence I would say this was just a little game - and he lost.
Re:_why is no more by astine on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @11:01PM (#774337)
If his privacy was so precious to him I don't think he would do things like that.

But you don't know, and neither do I. It looks like someone played this game, and we lost.

Re:_why is no more by watt on Thursday August 20, 2009 @03:31AM (#774598)
privacy must be respected, and actually should be enforced by everybody, including you. meaning: even if you know him, you should pretend that he is anonymous person, disconnecting the _why persona from the real-life person.

for example, if you know him, and you hire him, you still should ignore the on-line _why persona, because for privacy purposes, it is separate, anonymous entity, and you should not connect it to real person. that's what privacy should be.

Re:_why is no more by moe on Thursday August 20, 2009 @08:21AM (#774834)
I honestly don't get the futz about this.

Also the whole "if you hire him you're obliged to ignore any other identities you know about" is just completely out of this world.

Again: If he valued his privacy so much then why did he appear in public? You can't have your cake and eat it, too.

Re:_why is no more by Vitamin on Friday August 21, 2009 @12:42AM (#776991)
Uggh. If privacy must be protected by civic order it's already a lost cause. All these good people standing up for privacy--it only serves to increase the market value of violations.

Honestly, I think it's better to throw out the notion of digital privacy entirely and start pushing the notion of universal visibility, and accountability. Once everyone is naked, we'll stop obsessing over the naughty bits.

Re:_why is no more by csallen on Sunday August 30, 2009 @10:00PM (#795245)
The anonymity and lack of personal accountability provided by the internet rarely have good effects. What's interesting is how fervently people fight to protect this anonymity, even though it doesn't really exist when we interact with strangers in the real world.

I'm not saying that online privacy is worthless of course, just noting that it is quite unique.

Re:_why is no more by adambyrtek on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @06:54PM (#814136)
Privacy is not the same as anonymity.
Re:_why is no more by judofyr on Thursday August 20, 2009 @12:53PM (#775448)
Apparently, giving a public speech didn't reveal his identify, so why shouldn't he "do things like that"?
Re:_why is no more by Adam503 on Friday August 21, 2009 @02:01AM (#777094)
a public speech where? a programming language conference. No disrespect intended to anyone here, but making a presentation at the technical conference does not make one either a public figure.
Re:_why is no more by Keyframe on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @05:25PM (#773818)
I don't know why are you downvoting him - HACKERS of all people should understand the nature of challenges - be them called for or not.
Re:_why is no more by eli on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @05:48PM (#773864)
Even if I accept that explanation, posting the information online is no challenge. That's just being a jerk.
Re:_why is no more by lil_cain on Thursday August 20, 2009 @04:26AM (#774648)
Not every challenge is meant to be taken up.

Respect for people's wishes is important too. It's quite clear that _why didn't want people to know who he is. Fair enough, if you wanted to work that out. I don't think you should, but I could understand it. Telling the world? That's trying to wave your E-penis at the cost of one of the ruby world's best contributors.

Re:_why is no more by apotheon on Thursday August 20, 2009 @12:50AM (#774456)
I don't think it was mean-spirited. I do, however, think it's a crying shame.
Re:_why is no more by petercooper on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @03:52PM (#773618)
I'm sure someone in the know told me his real name a couple years back (he wrote the foreword to my book) and it certainly wasn't Jonathan Gillette. Of course, he might have changed him name again.. :)
Re:_why is no more by lylejohnson on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @04:08PM (#773655)
Ditto. Unless _why goes by multiple names in real life (which I suppose is possible), that's not him.
Re:_why is no more by maurycy on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @04:46PM (#773734)
It is possible that Jonathan Gillette and _why worked in the same company, and _why used Jonathan's computer, or so.
Re:_why is no more by petercooper on Thursday August 20, 2009 @08:51PM (#776760)
To update, I've received a few anonymous e-mails with significant proof that the Jonathan Gillette theory is sound (though I won't go far as to say it's 100% certain).
Re:_why is no more by jvdh on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @06:20PM (#773924)
This might also be the reason that _why just upped an ran. Staying anonymous is one thing, but letting someone else take the hit for you is quite another.

disclaimer: I don't know how long the blog has been trying to figure out who _why is.

Re:_why is no more by mosburger on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @03:47PM (#773609)
Something doesn't seem right about that detective work - there's a Jonathan Gillette online who is a web developer in Harrisburg, PA who doesn't seem to be _why. Obviously it's likely that there's more than one Jonathan Gillette on the internet, but it seems odd to me that this other guy is also a web developer, with a decent online presence, in (somewhat) the same geographic area where _why is suspected to live, that isn't him.

But I don't know enough about e-mail headers to provide an alternate explanation if there is one.

EDIT: This is that other guy's site, FWIW: http://jonathangillette.net/

And he's on twitter: http://twitter.com/jgillette

EDIT 2: The infamous Zed Shaw posted a link to another page which I'm more inclined to believe is the real _why. I'm not going to post the link here, but you can find it in Zed's twitter stream if you really want to.

Re:_why is no more by burke on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @03:59PM (#773638)
That Jonathan Gillette was also going to school in Pennsylvania (http://www.linkedin.com/in/jonathangillette) when _why wrote that message, supposedly from Salt Lake City, Utah.
Re:_why is no more by mosburger on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @04:02PM (#773642)
Nice find - you're a more thorough detective/stalker than I. :)
Re:_why is no more by burke on Thursday August 20, 2009 @05:01AM (#774673)
Yet more detective work:

http://javuh.cvs.sourceforge.net/viewvc/javuh/javuh/Model/Ps...

He seems to have been working on the same file, in the same day, as Jonathan Gillette. Probably poking around this repository a little more could lead to an almost-definitive answer.

Also, here: http://javuh.cvs.sourceforge.net/viewvc/javuh/javuh/Services... the @author is listed as:

       11  *  @author Why Carlisle ([email protected])

EDIT: Still going....

He talks about a 14-year-old sister here: http://www.advogato.org/person/whytheluckystiff/diary/14.htm...

This being written in 2001, that would make her ~21 now.

Searching for Jonathan Gillette, http://www.intelius.com/search-summary-out.php?ReportType=1&...

a few relatives are listed, presumably one of which would be his sister, however, none are in the right age range.

Right, back to work now, I promise.

Re:_why is no more by cl3m on Thursday August 20, 2009 @09:19AM (#774957)
I'm ended up on http://members.tripod.com/soccer_riot/ which seems to be some early stuff from _why..

From "Collected by Why the Lucky Stiff", http://members.tripod.com/soccer_riot/famous.htm

Re:_why is no more by burke on Thursday August 20, 2009 @01:34PM (#775578)
Well look at that, it was him: http://imgur.com/yq9o1

dolphins.ram has "Jonathan Gillette" as the author. Yet another reason to hate Real Player.

I would feel bad about posting this, but since everyone's apparently going to go around assuming it with almost-proof already, I guess it can't do much harm.

Re:_why is no more by byrneseyeview on Thursday August 20, 2009 @11:41AM (#775279)
In your second link, at the end, quoting from a response to an email sent by _why:

say are you related to francis gillett who wrote that play about the kids who never slept and lived in wyoming.

Re:_why is no more by infodig on Thursday August 20, 2009 @02:28PM (#775745)
Kylie is a relative. He hosts a site by one Kylie Gillette using the alias Whytheluckystiff. If he is NOT Jonathan Gillette he has very, very close ties to him.
Re:_why is no more by sl33p3r on Thursday August 20, 2009 @03:18PM (#775877)
Another one: http://ftp.df.lth.se/pub/scene.org/music/groups/starving_but...

look at the .txt file : both Jonathan Gillette and Kylie Gillette are present ...

Re:_why is no more by cxvii on Thursday August 20, 2009 @05:05PM (#776253)
The text file mentions another band, The Child Who Was a Keyhole. On their Myspace page (http://www.myspace.com/thechildwhowasakeyhole) it lists the band member Jonathan as guitar/vocals. Here is a picture of them from 2004. http://b7.ac-images.myspacecdn.com/00457/75/36/457046357_l.j... Here is a picture of _why as we know him. http://www.flickr.com/photos/scottlaird/31366517/ Those guitars look oddly similar...
Re:_why is no more by infodig on Thursday August 20, 2009 @06:04PM (#776442)
Wow check this out: http://www.ewrecs.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=...

Parents divorcing and family members committing suicide._why has written a lot about both topics and the band description matches up with his tastes and quirkiness quite well I think. So Kylie is in fact JGs wife.

Re:_why is no more by cxvii on Thursday August 20, 2009 @05:14PM (#776291)
And if that isn't enough, here is their CD. http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/tcwwak

Note the familiar figure on the cover.

Re:_why is no more by sl33p3r on Friday August 21, 2009 @02:18AM (#777108)
And here we are: Miss Trudy (who I definitively know being _why's wife, as I uncovered this some years ago, and _why asked me to not say anything), is definitively saying she belongs to "The Child Who was ..." :

http://www.e6townhall.com/archive/index.php/t-2187.html

Re:_why is no more by mustDeref on Friday August 21, 2009 @02:41PM (#778162)
Re:_why is no more by sl33p3r on Friday August 21, 2009 @02:15AM (#777105)
And in this one (sorry google cache), hosted on hobix.com, both "The Child who .." and the "Starving but Happy" are mentioned: http://74.125.77.132/search?q=cache:A9WqFnIuA04J:b2thefroth....
Re:_why is no more by infodig on Thursday August 20, 2009 @05:16PM (#776298)
This thread, combined with others combined with the javuh repository on sourceforge combined with all of the friend hosting create enough to bear it out. So there we have it.
Re:_why is no more by sl33p3r on Friday August 21, 2009 @07:22AM (#777328)
Hi Gents,

I've just created a blog and posted an entry regarding the "_why is Jonathan Gillette" path ...: http://whereintheworldiswhy.wordpress.com/

According to me _why is Jonathan Gillette.

Re:_why is no more by sl33p3r on Thursday August 20, 2009 @03:06PM (#775838)
Another hint, perhaps going in the same direction: this thread (http://listlibrary.net/ruby-talk/2002/06/00iG41gy) on ruby-talk, where Jonathan Gillette is both using the wgy@riza account and another one ...
Re:_why is no more by byrneseyeview on Thursday August 20, 2009 @09:45AM (#775011)
Kristin Marie Gillette is 21 now. She's on Intelius.
Re:_why is no more by burke on Thursday August 20, 2009 @01:11PM (#775501)
But only Kristin C Gillette was listed as a relative. Could be though.
Re:_why is no more by burke on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @06:36PM (#773961)
Also (too late to edit):

Why apparently went to the University of Utah in Salt Lake City: http://web.archive.org/web/20010518151731rn_1/deathstar.eng....

Re:_why is no more by codekitchen on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @06:58PM (#774015)
Intresting! Also that implies his real name is K. Roford (I went to the University of Utah as well, so I'm familiar with their naming scheme).
Re:_why is no more by burke on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @07:43PM (#774092)
Googling "kroford" returns a few results related to Star Wars, and the server is named "deathstar". I thought that at first too, but now I doubt it.
Re:_why is no more by samfoo on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @10:26PM (#774300)
http://www.facebook.com/search/?q=roford&init=quick#/pro...

Ken Roford has an account on facebook, but no details revealed to the outside world.

Re:_why is no more by lylejohnson on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @04:49PM (#773741)
The person that Zed is linking to is an art professor who was at Union University in Jackson, TN, now apparently a visiting professor at Lipscomb University in Nashville. You can see that Jonathan Gillette's photo in some faculty photos from a year or so ago (http://www.uu.edu/centers/faculty/faculty/new/0607newfaculty...). It's not _why.
Re:_why is no more by mmaaxx on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @04:38PM (#773718)
http://jonathangillette.net/ is defiantly not him. The site runs on PHP.
Re:_why is no more by doki_pen on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @05:11PM (#773782)
http://www.advogato.org/person/whytheluckystiff/ There are a few PHP apps there. Apparently he did PHP work before. There is also a Java project called javuh that he maintained. Archive.org for these projects reveals that the outing previously mentioned was in fact correct.
Re:_why is no more by lylejohnson on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @05:44PM (#773848)
Please see the information posted by "burke", a couple of posts up from here. There was a Jonathan Gillette who graduated from Parkland High School in Allentown, PA, then went on to Kutztown University (also in PA). All of this around the time that _why was apparently posting from a company in Salt Lake City.
Re:_why is no more by bowman on Thursday August 20, 2009 @10:33PM (#776878)
He mentions his friend Dustin in: 12 Oct 2002 http://www.advogato.org/person/whytheluckystiff/diary.html?s... This furthers the belief he is Jonathan Gillette as the band Jonathan Gillette was in contains a Dustin. With all the other evidence I am calling this a case closed. It is interesting to note how different he seems from _why. Maybe the Fight Club analogy (read above) is not too far from the truth.
Re:_why is no more by infodig on Thursday August 20, 2009 @02:25PM (#775733)
I am posting this because I feel it is worthwhile information. It is within _why's rights to yank his sites off the Internet at a moments notice. I will not begrudge him that. However, I do think when people come to rely on your tools and software you should at least respect that people rely on you, if informally.

Also, I think that, since he was hosting a lot of other sites on hobix, not just his personal stuff something could actually be wrong. So I am sharing this information. Please be responsible.

I dug up a Kylie Gillette who is the owner of snapd.net, Snapdragon Jewelry. A quick whois on that domain: Registrant: Layered Technologies TheLuckyStiff Why 1647 Witt Rd. Ste. # 20 Frisco, TX 75034 US +1.9723987998 [email protected]

So there is also this: http://www.assessor.slco.org/test/cfml/Query/valuationInfo.c...

What are the chances that a Jonathan Gillette hosting a website for Kylie Gillette who posted to a ruby mailing list as _why and Jonathan Gillette in 02 and 03 are different people? If something is wrong or something has happened to him IRL people would rest a little easier knowing what is going on.

Re:_why is no more by UncleOxidant on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @05:40PM (#773840)
but that was over a month ago, why would he wait that long?
Re:_why is no more by blasdel on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @09:24PM (#774222)
misuba on HN said his first name is Michael: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=683061
Re:_why is no more by jpeterson on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @04:30PM (#773699)
Nope, whoever created this site was trolled.
Re:_why is no more by scorpion032 on Thursday August 20, 2009 @04:24AM (#774645)
Ok, Now, who did this?
Re:_why is no more by sabat on Friday August 28, 2009 @03:02AM (#790908)