News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by ggreer on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @03:39AM (#7665536)
I really don't want to be negative, but every browser update in the past year feels like a step back. This is true for Chrome and Firefox. Each update contains more "Sign in to your browser" stuff plastered everywhere. Eye candy is added. Useful configuration options are removed.[1] Many of these changes seem to be made with the goal of increasing revenue, not improving user experience.

Rule #0 of business is: Listen to your users. For browsers, one straightforward way to do this is to look at what extensions and addons users install. By far, the winner is adblock. Almost everyone who knows how to block ads does so. Therefore, if you are making a browser and you care about user experience above everything else, you will have ad blocking by default. That no major browser does tells us what their priorities really are.

Again, apologies for the negativity. This has frustrated me for some time.

Edit: I realize that if everyone suddenly started blocking ads, there would be darkness and chaos. But the current situation is only tenable because a small fraction of users have the know-how to get what they want. You can avoid ads if you are technically proficient or know someone who is. Everyone else has to put up with ads. Advertisers annoy millions if not billions of people, effectively subsidizing the usage of those with ad blockers. That doesn't seem fair to me.

1. Such as the old new tab page in Chrome: https://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=326788

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by scrollaway on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:09AM (#7665647)
Seeing how much backlash Mozilla got for even proposing to block third party ads by default, I can't imagine what would happen if they shipped adblock.

Just because adblock is popular doesn't mean everyone is using it, and as much as I don't like it, advertisers rely on that... it could seriously damage the web if they did that.

The French have an expression for this, they would say you can see no farther than the end of your own nose.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by coldpie on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @08:55AM (#7666589)
> as much as I don't like it, advertisers rely on that... it could seriously damage the web if [everyone used adblock]

I understand this. I gave the advertisers a fair shot. I didn't install any adblocking on my phone. I gave them a significant chunk of my limited mobile browsing bandwidth. I understand it's a compromise; I waste my page space and bandwidth, and the websites I like continue to exist.

Then my phone started talking to me about some TV show or some shit in the middle of the office last week. Firefox installed, adblock installed, scorched earth policy. I will never view another ad on mobile.

I'm willing to be reasonable and compromise here, but if they're not holding up their end of the bargain, I'm not going to carry that burden either. If this is the way the web is going to be, then the web needs a new business model and I'm happy to bring it about.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by userbinator on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @05:05AM (#7665811)
> Just because adblock is popular doesn't mean everyone is using it, and as much as I don't like it, advertisers rely on that... it could seriously damage the web if they did that.

The sites that suffer the most from adblocking are those that provide very little benefit for the user anyway: splogs, linkfarms, and other very contentless things built solely to lure users in for adverts. While I don't use adblock myself (I use a filtering proxy instead), seeing that part of the internet die off, and possibly a return to something closer to the noncommercialised web of the 90s where the signal-to-noise ratio was much higher, IMHO is a very good thing. Although there are some good ad-supported sites that may die off, in my experience the sites that contain lots of very good, detailed information are unlikely to contain ads too. It's a bit like chemotherapy...

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by nemof on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @07:01AM (#7666140)
really?

I frequently visit The Verge and The Guardian. I also happen to follow their journalists on twitter because they're often interesting to listen and talk to. On more than one occasion I've seen them express their frustration at ad blocking software and the problems it causes. As such, and because I love the sites, I've turned off adblock for them. (not trying to sound magnanimous here, it's not like I disabled adblock for every site.)

I'd rather have websites sell advertising space next to their content then gate their communities behind paywalls frankly.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by GrinningFool on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @08:57AM (#7666604)
I will be happy to view any static ad hosted on and by the owner of the content. That way I know I'm not giving my data to anyone else.

For me the annoyance factor is less of a problem than the privacy concern.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by nemof on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @09:16AM (#7666730)
I guess part of the problem of that is that companies who might want to advertise on someones site might, not unreasonably, want the kind of stats and control set the hosting website just can't provide, but that a third party advertising company can.

I personally don't mind a certain level of information about my browsing being a bit leaky. I feel like it's a reasonable compromise to make for serving up content I want. Flagrant invasions of privacy are not ok, but I am more concerned with third parties serving malicious content through ads; Something I've seen enough to make me use an ad blocker by default.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by userbinator on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @08:31AM (#7666460)
I'd rather have websites sell advertising space next to their content then gate their communities behind paywalls frankly.

Those are not the only two choices. Many of the sites I like are personal ones either hosted on the author's own server+connection, or ones hosted by large institutions that would likely be able to afford the hosting anyway.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by nemof on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @09:24AM (#7666769)
> Those are not the only two choices.

absolutely, and I'm grateful to see people experimenting with different models for making money, but as it stands the most reasonable way for websites to make money is, probably in order of effectiveness:

1) advertising

2) charging for content

3) freemium, ie free content with paid extas

4) sponsorship

5) ???

generally when I talk about websites serving advertising, I'm speaking specifically about news/media websites. The cost of producing news is substantial, so earnings have to be commensurate. Either you charge people for it, or you give it away for free with advertising, and perhaps have added value services.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by dbdr on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @02:33AM (#7671912)
5) accept donations
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by mgkimsal on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @08:38AM (#7666491)
Hosting content is not the be-all-end-all of costs - people need to eat too.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by zak_mc_kracken on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @10:05AM (#7667018)
You turned off AdBlock, but do you actually click on these ads? Because no money changes hands unless there are clicks, at last if they're using Google for ads.

People who say "I turned off AdBlock to help support the sites I visit" but never click on any ad are not making a bit of difference.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by bovermyer on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @09:28AM (#7666786)
Speaking as someone who works for a newspaper, comments like this make me very uncomfortable. News websites don't make money off of the generosity of viewers. They make money off of advertising. Until the majority of people are willing to go behind a paywall to see content, news organizations must rely on advertising for survival. Not profit, survival.

I personally don't use ad blockers for this reason. I like supporting sites I visit, even if I hate the ads showing there.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by nfoz on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @09:47AM (#7666917)
Some news organizations have funding models that don't rely, or don't rely heavily, on advertising. I rather prefer that.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by nailer on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @08:16AM (#7666392)
> The sites that suffer the most from adblocking are .... splogs, linkfarms, and other very contentless things built solely to lure users in for adverts.

Doesn't adblock normally block all ads? Last time I used it was years ago, so maybe things have changed.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by itry on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:04AM (#7665629)
> one straightforward way to do this is to look at what extensions and addons users install

Oh God No! I do not use adblock. I use noscript and im happy with it. I also do not use "Video DownloadHelper" which is the second most used addon. And neither do I use Firebug which is #3. Please do not put all this stuff into my browser! And not everybody uses noscript which I use and which is #4. Im completely fine with installing it.

How about improving on the basic stuff? For example make FF use all cores of my machine and not just one?

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by claudius on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:13AM (#7665662)
> Please do not put all this stuff into my browser!

I was a very happy Opera user for years under the exact assumption that there is little need to install addons if your browser has all the features you need – and I didn’t use all of Opera’s features either, but somehow even with the included mail and bittorrent clients, it ended up being smaller than, say, Firefox.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by Jakob on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @05:19AM (#7665842)
> For example make FF use all cores of my machine and not just one?

They are working on it: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Electrolysis

This is already in the nightly version for some months: "File > New e10s Window" will open a new window in its own process.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by itry on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @11:18AM (#7667557)

    File > New e10s Window
Wow! Nice. Thanks for the info!
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by abus on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:20AM (#7665686)
They already built Firebug into the browser.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by scrollaway on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:19AM (#7665680)
I'd like to address your three separate points...

> Each update contains more "Sign in to your browser" stuff plastered everywhere. Eye candy is added. Useful configuration options are removed.

- First of all, each update cannot possibly contain more "sign in to your browser". Are you talking about Firefox Sync, of which similar-yet-poorer functionality used to be in an incredibly popular extension (by your own rules, that should go in the browser!)?

- Eye candy is nice. Not everyone lives in the 90s and wants a clickable version of Lynx.

- Configuration options are as useful as the users make it. There was a massive outrage on here when Firefox removed the javascript switch, yet that is one of the best decision they made for their userbase. Google sure did remove a lot of options over time, some of it has infuriated me as well (the removal of http: was a big one for me). But most of the time, users do not actually know what they want which is why they just want a bazillion options to be able to change their mind all the time, as if they're not using a browser but playing Wedding Tie Choice Simulator 2015. As Randall Munroe put it: https://xkcd.com/1172/

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by blueskin_ on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:54AM (#7665774)
>- Eye candy is nice. Not everyone lives in the 90s and wants a clickable version of Lynx.

Then why are Mozilla removing everything? I like eye candy too. A metro-ified, totally bare browser without even a status bar is the complete opposite.

Oh, and links has mouse support via GPM.

>- Configuration options are as useful as the users make it. There was a massive outrage on here when Firefox removed the javascript switch, yet that is one of the best decision they made for their userbase.

Because everyone switched to NoScript instead.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by lelandbatey on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @05:51AM (#7665924)
What do you mean by "without a status bar"? What change is that in reference to? Sounds important...
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by blueskin_ on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @06:00AM (#7665954)
This thread. Firefox is removing the <s>status bar</s>'addon bar'* in australis along with most of the rest of its customisability.

*Their preferred term even though everyone just installs Status4Evar and still has a status bar.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by untog on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @10:38AM (#7667249)
I'm pretty sure the number of people installing Status4Evar is pretty far away from "everyone".
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by makomk on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:23AM (#7665697)
Firefox Sync was in the browser before, you just didn't need to sign in to your browser online to use the previous version. (It also let you sync through your own server rather than Mozilla's which I don't think the new version does yet, but even if you used their server you still didn't need a Mozilla account of any kind.)
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by euank on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:26AM (#7665706)
I run my own firefox sync server, and have since it was introduced. It's working fine for the current version of sync. There's a rather helpful guide for setting it up and there were a handful of alternative server implementations which have unfortunately fallen by the wayside.

https://docs.services.mozilla.com/howtos/run-sync.html

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by rfk on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @07:46AM (#7666287)
Unfortunately this server is not compatible with the new sync protocol. It will continue to work while there is still old-sync support in the browser (a few versions after FF29 at least) but will eventually need to be upgraded to the new system.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by rfk on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @07:43AM (#7666281)
> It also let you sync through your own server rather than Mozilla's which I don't think the new version does yet

This is possible with the new version, but it's not (yet) as simple as it was with the previous one:

   https://docs.services.mozilla.com/howtos/run-fxa.html
   https://docs.services.mozilla.com/howtos/run-sync-1.5.html
(edit: actually IIRC there's an open bug around allowing android devices to use a custom sync server; desktop devices definitely work fine with it via some about:config settings)
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by exodust on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:25AM (#7665703)
As much as I like Adblock, did you know it blocks static jpeg images that contain the text "300x250px" or similar in the file name? I didn't know until it blocked one of the images I put into a site that has no ads.

I presume AdBlock's logic is that because promo ads often have the dimensions in the filename, that's good enough reason to block EVERY image on the web that has dimensions in the filename. Pathetic logic!

While you might be happy browsing away on the internet with Ad-Block, it could very well be blocking non-ad content, which is not something you want as core browser functionality.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by blueskin_ on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:56AM (#7665778)
What list are you using?

I've never noticed that with EasyList.

Edit: Quick optical grep confirms it, nothing to match image dimensions I could see in the filter rules.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by tombrossman on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @07:25AM (#7666220)
How do you not see all the image dimensions in the filter rules? Picking just the those mentioned I tried 'grep 300x250 easylist.txt' and got 478 results!

Many are very specific and look like useful filters, but here are just a small sample of rules that are problematic: -300x250- -300x250_ .300x250. .300x250_ /300x250- /300x250. /300x250/

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by blueskin_ on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @07:41AM (#7666270)
I see plenty along the pattern of "Ad300x250", but not general ones.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by exodust on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @09:08AM (#7666675)
There's this: -300x250_

looks like the culprit.

I wasn't up to speed on the lists business. I will look into using a different list. I was just using adblock now and then at the default settings, I installed it and haven't touched settings.

I don't use it all the time because I don't want it interfering with testing and dev, messing with the document.

When it backfires and hides stuff you've just published, suddenly I'm cursing adblock because I know other default adblock users won't see the image.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by GrinningFool on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @09:00AM (#7666618)
Search further down, they're there.

This is actually frustrating, I had thought until now that easylist blocked only third party ads; this means they block self-hosted as well.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by tombrossman on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @07:14AM (#7666182)
Ugh, you're right. Checking the default list from https://easylist-downloads.adblockplus.org/easylist.txt confirms it. I'll have to look into this more and see if there is a better list to subscribe to.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by ASneakyFox on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:52AM (#7665767)
Image name should be describing the image any way. That's just good seo.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by exodust on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @08:36AM (#7666483)
Putting dimensions in image names is fine, it's quite useful for asset management.

Describing the image is the alt tag's job. Otherwise, consider the nightmare...

Britney_Spears_Red_Carpet_MTV_Awards_2012_834pm_Headshot.jpg

Which isn't great file naming for the web. Or am I too oldschool and this is how all the kool kids do it now?

Do search engines expect meta data in image names? I don't think they're counting on it, even if they are picking it up.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by herokusaki on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @09:44AM (#7666900)
>Which isn't great file naming for the web.

Why?

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by exodust on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @02:01AM (#7671841)
Because of standardized naming convention, or lack of.

In the Britney example, there's no naming convention, only a vague approximation of the image contents.

This may work for you personal blog, but in large production environments, you don't want editors just "making up" image names without consistent naming convention.

Remember that the original digital camera image has no mention of Britney! At best, when the RAW image is converted, the general image name might be appended with "mtv_awards", but nothing further.

Same for video file naming. You can't fit all the subject matter of the video into its file name, you would instead maybe put the reverse date in the name and an abbreviated title. But to expect that to be used for SEO is not a good strategy.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by VMG on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @03:58AM (#7665600)
I vividly remember the anger over omnicomplete and people vowing to switch to Opera, which didn't have that feature. I gave it a shot and found omnicomplete quite comfortable after a while.

Status quo bias is a powerful thing.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by blueskin_ on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:10AM (#7665650)
I gave Opera a shot, found it weird (and much harder to customise), then went back to firefox with https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/old-location-... .
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by ASneakyFox on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:59AM (#7665791)
Opera next is not meant to be customizable like opera 12 was. Now their focus is on streamining interface activities. Removing bookmark graveyards etc etc.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by talonx on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @07:02AM (#7666144)
+ for mentioning Useful configuration options. Prominent examples include Last tab close and hiding the Disable Javascript option in Firefox. In both these cases, the decision seems to be driven by the preferences of a specific group of developer(s) rather than informed decision making or listening to users.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by knusprig on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:08AM (#7665642)
The issue with pre-enabling adblock in a browser is that chrome is financed completely by google (runs on online ads) and mozilla is substantially financed by google and other search engines (who also rely on ad money).
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by kijin on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @04:13AM (#7665660)
Tough luck. The overwhelming majority of Mozilla's revenue is from their search partnership with Google, the Internet's largest advertising company. You don't bite the hand that feeds you.

Apple is the only major browser vendor that can afford to ship an ad blocker without strangling its own throat. If Jobs where still around, he might have actually done that, if only to stick a big middle finger at Google. Now I'm not so sure. Maybe MSFT will do it first with IE, if Bing's market share gets any lower than it already is (or if Yahoo finally folds).

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by userbinator on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @08:34PM (#7670861)
> Useful configuration options are removed.

This is IMHO a most disturbing trend; instead of leaving configuration options available (and possibly adding more), many "UX experts" seem to have the notion that all users are exactly the same and should therefore never need anything more or less than what these "experts" think they should need. Removing options also reduces the amount of learning-by-experimentation that is possible, but experimentation is one of the best ways of learning about things. The point is often made that this is so "users don't break things", but at the same time it denies them a valuable learning experience and takes away freedom.

Meanwhile the focus is on adding eye candy and using plenty of doublespeak (some of my favourite examples of this are "decreased clutter", "simplification", "streamlining", "user-oriented") to make the users think that they're being offered an improvement. The goal of designing a browser for a novice user, which may be initially simple to use, but is "layered" so that it grows with the user's knowledge, is slowly eroding away. Instead, the expectation seems to be that the average user is one who knows little more than how to turn on a computer, and one who intends to remain ignorant --- the model of the "perfect consumer". The customisation features are gradually relegated to extensions, and advanced configuration is not a gradual learning curve, but a big jump, creating a gap that users have to cross - a gap that is widening. Maybe this is a reflection of a general societal trend, but I have no doubt that it is also contributing to it.

In consideration of this, Mozilla also has a rather curious description: "Mozilla is a global non-profit dedicated to putting the user in control of their online experience..."

Although I disgaree with making adblock a default; I think the concept of what constitutes an advert is too ill-defined to add this complexity to a browser. Personally I don't mind anything that is not intrusive or too distracting.

The title of the article is pretty indicative too: "A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming". The first thing that comes to mind is "Beauty is only skin deep."

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by bruceboughton on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @09:08AM (#7666670)
How do you propose that our industry pay for the servers then? Magical pixie dust?

I don't mind seeing ads on free services that have some marginal value for me.

Don't force your intolerance for ads upon me.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by amatheus on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @07:23AM (#7666214)
I would guess most of the users simply don't install any plugins or addons. So in that case listening to them would simply mean not changing anything.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by cookiecaper on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @10:18AM (#7667106)
Rule #0 is not a good rule at all. People are never happy. When Firefox was focusing on utilitarian concerns, people reamed Mozilla incessantly for "ugliness" and "user hostility". They vowed to switch to Chrome which supposedly cared more about these things because its tab bar background was blue (or plug in your pet issue here). Now Firefox releases something that focuses on fluffy prettiness concerns like "native look and feel" or "non-distracting tab bars" and suddenly Mozilla is vain and silly, and people vow to switch to Chrome because they implemented Real Feature X.

The point isn't that either side is necessarily wrong, just that "listen to your users" is not the #0 rule of business. Users can provide good feedback, but it must be tempered, because there are always going to be detractors, and detractors will always be louder than supporters.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by mike-cardwell on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @09:25AM (#7666771)
Chrome came out and lots of people started using it because it was faster than Firefox and because Google spammed it all over their search engine. Chrome is developed by an ad company. Chrome exists in order to create a web which can serve ads to you in a manner which is more profitable to that ad company.

That's fair enough. Chrome users sow what they reap. If they want a web which develops under the control of an ad company, or several ad companies (Microsoft too), then that's what they'll get.

The trouble is, it affects the rest of us who don't want a web to evolve according to the profit interests of ad companies; Mozilla got scared by the sudden migration of people from Firefox to Chrome, so they've now started copying Chrome in many ways that probably aren't as good as they think they are for the future of the web.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by scrollaway on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @10:56AM (#7667377)
Blocking ads doesn't hurt the revenues of ad companies. It hurts the revenues of the sites relying on those ad companies.

That's your mog & pog blog.

Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by mike-cardwell on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @03:59AM (#7672104)
I think the web is important. Important enough that making the technology behind it worse, either by not implementing tech that is bad for ads, or by implementing tech just because it is good for ads, so that ad funded sites can continue to be ad funded sites, is a mistake. I don't care who is behind those ad funded sites.
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by DCKing on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @03:55AM (#7665583)
Maybe it's exactly rule #0 they're upholding, but maybe most users want something different than you?
Re:Firefox and Flux: A New, Beautiful Browser is Coming by andreasklinger on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @03:56AM (#7665589)
With all love to focus on what users want…

Currently online ads are one of the few standard business models that finance the internet ecosystem.

It would be a step back to remove them without a replacement.