Costs always increase -- staying the same size costs more next year.
Even so, due to older staff retiring or leaving and newer staff joining at lower salaries, even if all staff have steadily increasing pay rates above inflation the overall payroll budget may still be in a steady state.
You mean, grow?
But that setup only applies if you're paying at the bottom of the scale and not giving out benefits. Bennies have been increasing by much more than inflation, and the type of jobs giving bennies typically expect a 4% raise, minimum, if you're doing acceptably at it.
The cost? An ever increasing chasm between powerful and powerless, a chasm which itself goes through periodic crashes which tend to be significantly more violent... e.g. the fall of Rome, the French Revolution, and WWII.
If growth is so important and defines success then eventually is will plateau due to limited resources and no longer be successful which is obviously not true.
To place both of those ideas into one, the most important characteristic of a successful business is a positive return on investment. Profits and growth can account for a positive return on investment.
For public companies, growth is important, because people who buy a share of stock for $X do so because they think that share of stock will someday be worth an amount more than $X. And growth is seemingly a very clear indicator of such an outcome. So the markets put pressure on public companies to always be growing.
That is why stock buy-backs only make sense if the shares are priced too low.
(That said, I do understand companies usually overpay for their own stock, so the move is not necessarily the best one for any given company or companies in general unless the stock is, in fact, undervalued. But it is still one way to deliver returns into the pockets of shareholders, anyway.)
If a company buys back stock that is overpriced, it actually destroys shareholder value. If the stock is priced correctly the outcome will be neutral for the shareholders. Only in the case where the stock is cheap relative to its value, is value created for the shareholders.
In reality these corporate actions are value neutral if the current share price is at fair market value.
The value of ongoing profit is reduced if a company has fewer liquid assets to invest.
That is actually untrue.
One theory says that a business should grow with GDP.
Comparing to GDP gets tricky. Is GDP growing due to actual output growth and wealth generation or due to inflation?
I suppose we need to first agree on what were looking at defining what a successful business based on a non moving target or defining success based on comparing it to other businesses.
Do I think a businesses revenue should grow with GDP? Yes. Does the profit margin need to? Not necessarily. To be more successful at investing you definitely want businesses that have higher ROIs. However, are we discussing successful investing or successful businesses?
Edit: typos
"True" GDP should be inflation-adjusted, hence you'll see real GDP growth in adjusted statistics.
Measuring inflation is its own kettle of worms.
The more relevant challenge IMO is that GDP is a highly flawed measure. NNP (net national product) corrects for some of this via accounting for externalities, but both are still cash flow measures, when what would be more appropriate as a net measure of wealth would be a capital growth account -- equivalent to a businesses balance sheet.
Sadly, this is one area in which macroeconomics has been stubbornly and persistently lacking.
Growth depends on resources AND technology. Its quite possible to have growth without any change in resourcing.
> Comparing to GDP gets tricky. Is GDP growing due to actual output growth and wealth generation or due to inflation?
It doesn't make a difference. In this case we are definitely talking nominal growth.
My bottom line would be that a business would generally(!) not be classed as successful if it is not growing.
Of course there are other factors that might make a stationary business considered a success.
That presumes that 1) GDP can grow without limit and 2) that GDP is itself an accurate measure of real economic growth.
Being technical about it, a business may keep up with inflation by raising prices, and show nominal growth.
Look at the revenue of a liquor store, insurance business, or tv / radio station, in a healthy but smaller settled market. No market growth, little to no business growth, but the businesses aren't likely to disappear either. This is a very common scenario, there are millions of US businesses in this situation.
More accurately: they're earning normal economic profits. This assumes that economic activity is normally profitable, which isn't unreasonable in certain circumstances, though it's not guaranteed.
There are natural monopolies which grow without apparent limit, or rather, whose growth is constrained only by the total size of the market, rather than some lower bound. For these, there's always the capability of adding additional profitable production.
For other businesses, there are natural constraints on scale: a regional market or operation which can only sustain so much business, high scale-related costs, etc.
As two canonical examples, telecommunications scales quite well with scale, and in the history of telecoms we find a long history of monopolies: Western Union in the telegraph age, AT&T in the telephony age, and now Comcast in the broadband era. Once you've got cables strung, your primary limitation is last-mile wiring. But it's the long-distance and total bandwidth capacities which give you maximum value.
Concrete is a counterexample: there's a limited local market (whatever local building activity will support), and your transport costs are very high: concrete is heavy stuff. Concrete tends to be a pretty localized industry, though it might be possible for a single firm to develop out of what are essentially multiple regional markets.
Growth, where possible, profitable, and sustainable for a business, is often pursued, but it's not a necessary condition for success.
Individuals working there are always excited about personal empire building of course, but if the stated community need is being met, well, that's good enough, in fact if that need is dropping that can sometimes be awesome.
Stereotypical orphanage or red cross or homeless shelter.
Churches are another business that often is fairly steady state plus or minus population changes and inflation.
Of course non profits can experience explosive growth, my credit union is a non-profit coop and since the nationwide banks have gone into decline with exploding fees and imploding services, the CU has recently had exploding growth rates. Which admittedly has a lot more to do with external societal factors than internal goals.
When a tech company demonstrates declining growth, there are usually negative murmurs that seem to get amplified in the news. It's still positive growth... but the growth derivative is negative. A flat, zero derivative seems to be as concerning to those in the press as a negative one.
For example, see stocks in utility companies. Particularly before recent deregulation in utilities, there were no prospects for growth in these companies, so their share prices were essentially based upon their bond-like characteristics of yielding a reliable dividend. Their price settles to a place where their dividend yield reflects the underlying "default risk" of the company, relative to the risk free rate.
At the risk of oversimplification, stocks usually fall somewhere on this spectrum. A high growth stock's price can be held afloat via rosy predictions of future growth, and a low or non-growth stock's price can be held afloat by a steady dividend stream. Take away the growth prospects of the former or increase the risk of losing the dividend stream of the latter and you will see the price drop precipitously.
Like our local taxi company basically has a monopoly on the city, and has no real reason to grow. But here comes UberX, a growth startup, throwing around free rides and cheap rates. If the local company loses market share or profits to UberX, they have nowhere else to pick it up.
I hope this doesn't come across as nitpicking, but the lead sentence of the article is incorrect. It should be:
One of the most important characteristics of a successful STARTUP is that it's growing.
Businesses which successfully serve their owners, employees, customers and larger surrounding community, can easily be steady-state.
I realize HN is startup-focused, but I think in the interest of productive conversation it's important to make the distinction and use precise terms.