News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by buro9 on Sunday April 27, 2014 @12:20PM (#7655655)
This has happened a few times recently.

It seems to be a new thing, that the front page is being editorialised.

An example of dang whitelisting something to get what he feels should be on the front page on there (and past the various things that would block it): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7634603

And the criticism of Sam Altman's Barack Obama fundraiser at YC was silently removed the moment it became apparent that nearly all comments were negative.

What we've seen in the last month is:

1) Things can be whitelisted and their place on the front page assured (skip filters and checks)

2) Things can be killed in a way that excludes them from the front page without leaving the item as [dead] (penalise in the placement algorithm)

3) Things can be silently removed (soft delete)

And all of those things are happening.

As a community we used to be able to rely on the fact that pg basically didn't get involved. And so we could trust that the front page reflected the community intent.

That trust is being broken.

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by dang on Sunday April 27, 2014 @02:40PM (#7656188)
This statement couldn't be more false:

> As a community we used to be able to rely on the fact that pg basically didn't get involved.

PG was heavily involved, right from the beginning. The HN front page has always been a blend of user voting and curation. At no time, ever, was it determined by voting alone. Had it been, HN's quality would have been lower—because quality is only one of the reasons why people upvote stories—and HN would never have been HN.

Other moderators, including me, worked with PG on this. I started in September 2012. One reason he took so long to hand over primary responsibility for HN, despite unsustainable demands on his time, is that he wanted to be sure that the moderators really grasped what he'd been doing all along. I'm thus in a position to assure you that we're not doing anything now that hasn't been done since basically forever—except that we're being a lot more transparent. Even that isn't a policy change (pg answered questions when he could) so much as a consequence of there being a dedicated team for the first time.

It never occurred to me when I started posting these transparency comments that we'd get accused of making insidious changes to (paraphrasing) "how HN has always been", "breaking trust", and so on. But I understand how it could seem that way. There's an upside to being unobtrusive. When stuff just works, people can rely on it and focus on the topics at hand. That goes a long, long way (though it doesn't do so well when stuff doesn't just work).

Edit: For some reason I didn't notice this earlier:

> the criticism of Sam Altman's Barack Obama fundraiser at YC was silently removed the moment it became apparent that nearly all comments were negative

That's not only completely false, it's a shameless misrepresentation that eats half the hope out of my soul. Nothing was "silent" [1] and nothing was "removed"—users flagged the posts and I personally rolled the penalty back at least four times. I said above that I could understand how one misconception might have arisen, but I can't understand this one; it seems devoid of even a grain of good faith.

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7612226 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7623254

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by swombat on Sunday April 27, 2014 @09:08PM (#7657712)
> That's not only completely false, it's a shameless misrepresentation that eats half the hope out of my soul. Nothing was "silent" [1] and nothing was "removed"—users flagged the posts and I personally rolled the penalty back at least four times. I said above that I could understand how one misconception might have arisen, but I can't understand this one; it seems devoid of even a grain of good faith.

I have no opinion on that thread, as I didn't see it, but let me just say that this is a result of lack of transparency... what I referred to in my post a while back when your involvement was announced.

When you care about a topic emotionally and it gets buried, and you don't know why, you tend to assume not the reasonable explanation, but the worst explanation. I've seen that reaction in myself, so it's not surprising to see it in others.

If there had been some sign that the post was heavily flagged (hey, how about a flag counter?) and perhaps even a sign that you were rolling back the flag counter manually, buro would not have felt this way.

I think one simple, obvious start to a solution might be to make the flag counter visible. Worth a try?

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by tptacek on Sunday April 27, 2014 @09:54PM (#7657845)
Making the flag count visible probably won't help, because you'd need to evaluate it in the context not just of the number of upvotes, but the number of upvotes within a window of time. Exposing it would probably just result in lots of unproductive subthreads about flagging conspiracies.

A suggestion I have, though: let's get rid of the guideline that says not to explain your flags.

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by swombat on Monday April 28, 2014 @03:28AM (#7658664)
That could be a good solution too.
Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by dang on Monday April 28, 2014 @12:05AM (#7658175)
I can't agree that lack of transparency is the explanation here. The comments I posted to those threads at the time (and made sure were visible) contained more than enough information to make such an interpretation impossible.
Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by swombat on Monday April 28, 2014 @03:27AM (#7658663)
Buro9, did you see dang's explanations on that thread?
Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by buro9 on Monday April 28, 2014 @03:33AM (#7658680)
On the Barack Obama thread? No, as I was unable to find the thread again and still cannot find it.
Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by dang on Monday April 28, 2014 @01:57PM (#7661703)
There were two threads. I linked to both of them in the comment you've already replied to.
Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by buro9 on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @01:24AM (#7665127)
Now that I've read them, those responses are great.

But... a moderation policy that relies on all users having read all comments on all stories is unrealistic.

Just create a page somewhere and say "these are the moderators, they do this when necessary, but most of the time it's not necessary as the community is largely moderated by users, and these are roughly the switches that the users have to control things".

I now know, as you've said. But I really wouldn't have guessed that people flag stories as much as they must do, nor that it carries such a penalty. And I'm a fairly heavy user and hadn't seen your comments and responses before.

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by buro9 on Monday April 28, 2014 @04:23AM (#7658812)
> That's not only completely false, it's a shameless misrepresentation that eats half the hope out of my soul.

This is not my intent, I moderate forums too and I know it's hard but I'm trying to explain something to you about what happens when one is merely an observer of the witnessed behaviour and not privy to any information to explain the behaviour.

Bear in mind that as a user I have a different view on HN than you do. I do not see flags alongside stories, and do not know the workings of the algorithms and moderation tools put in place.

There are many examples of people trying to observe and divine the behaviour of HN, mostly focused on "How does the front page ranking algorithm work?".

Observed behaviour: A story about YC appears to take a strong politic position and received many extremely negative comments. I could not then find this story, thus it has been removed.

Guess (because moderation is not transparent, visible, and searchable after the event) of what happened:

1) Was it flagged? Possibly, but would expect to see a [dead] text much like how comments show [dead]

2) Did it just not have ranking attributes? No, it was highly upvoted and had only been on the site a short while when I saw it.

3) Was it likely to have been removed by some other mechanism? Given that I can't see it's #1 and don't believe it's #2, yes.

This is what I mean by lack of transparent moderation.

I cannot see anywhere that says: "When a load of people flag it, the result of the collective flagging will penalise the story". Except, of course, in your comments here. This means that anyone (the majority) who hasn't read the comments of this story may also not know this is the case.

Without understanding what can happen and why, the behaviour of HN is subject to people attempting to make their own sense of what they observe.

What I observed and remarked on are three things:

1) Things can be whitelisted and their place on the front page assured (skip filters and checks)

Confirmed, you state that you have done this.

2) Things can be killed in a way that excludes them from the front page without leaving the item as [dead] (penalise in the placement algorithm)

Confirmed, but you've clarified that this is a consequence of collective flagging rather than an editorial moderation policy

3) Things can be silently removed (soft delete)

Seems to be a dupe of #2, a harsher penalty.

The key question that transparency would answer is this one: Are the adjustments the result of the community collectively deciding what content to show, or is the result of an editorial policy within YC?

The lack of transparency meant that there is little awareness of how the moderation tools work, how they effect things. Without that understanding it cannot be a great surprise that people (including me) are considering the latter of the two explanations.

> it seems devoid of even a grain of good faith

This is what I mean by trust being broken. I'm personally sorry my posts appear this way to you.

The more that unexplained behaviour is observed, the more the observer is going to be left with what unanswered questions sowing uncertainty and doubt.

Perhaps my view is biased as beyond the technical, the stories I am interested in include the set of stories that cover politics around startups. It's likely that many other stories were affected, but I didn't observe those. And perhaps my being on a different timezone means I don't see explanations you (or others) make at the time, we see a story placement be modified in our afternoon, but miss your explanation in your afternoon.

I love this place and spend more time on here than is probably healthy. I certainly want to believe and I question things so that I can. Your responses in this thread help a lot.

I am not someone who wants HN to change in any great way (a bit more towards the quality, but nothing seismic), but that's precisely my concern when behaviour I have never noticed before I now notice frequently enough for me to comment publicly on it (and risk whatever social penalty comes from questioning something people love).

Perhaps this could all just be solved by someone updating this page: http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Make it clear on there that collective flagging introduces penalties. Explain how flagging and downvoting changes things. Encapsulate pg's "Stay out of the controversial" policy.

Transparent moderation does not necessarily mean that you need to create software that lists every single thing that happened and why, it merely means that the users shouldn't be left guessing when a story they're reading vanishes on them or suddenly takes a dive down the front page.

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by tptacek on Sunday April 27, 2014 @12:43PM (#7655745)
The front page is better than it's been in years. If the trust is being broken, please, keep hitting it with whatever hammer it's being hit with.

Your comment, on the other hand, is not so great. For instance, you've decided to put an inaccurate spin on Daniel's actions. What you call "whitelisting", Daniel calls "overriding the voting ring detector that you had no control over in the first place, and that you only know about because he told you it was there".

This is all metadrama, of course, but this story is also worthless so a bit of meta here isn't going to kill us.

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by buro9 on Sunday April 27, 2014 @12:50PM (#7655780)
I'm not against anything that continues to change how and why things are placed on the front page in an effort to increase quality.

But without transparency how are people going to learn from it and adapt (in what they upvote, submit, etc).

If it happens silently, then those who comment on things as well as those who submit things are going to be left wondering why. You may consider this a positive on the line that "They're creating the wrong type of content", but not all of the content should be removed, sometimes the discussions are insightful and valuable even when the story itself wasn't.

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by tptacek on Sunday April 27, 2014 @01:01PM (#7655832)
Moderation on HN is more transparent now than it has ever been.
Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by selmnoo on Sunday April 27, 2014 @01:24PM (#7655911)
Not really. Rankbanning is still happening (from what I hear and observe from several high-profile HN users), slowbanning is still happening, hellbanning is still happening. That would all be fine, but this is increasingly happening with people who are not trolls. For example, jacquesm can't submit articles... we both know he's not a troll, and has no bad intentions, yet he's always getting dinged by HN.
Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by tptacek on Sunday April 27, 2014 @01:25PM (#7655914)
No part of your comment responds to mine. Moderation under Paul Graham was entirely, completely, absolutely opaque.

Nobody ever said hellbanning would go away, or that users wouldn't lose privileges.

If people believe themselves to be "rankbanned" or "slowbanned", they can mail [email protected] and be virtually assured that they'll get a personal, candid answer from the mod squad about what's going on. That's not as gratifying as snarking about it in public, though.

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by selmnoo on Sunday April 27, 2014 @01:28PM (#7655930)
> Moderation under Paul Graham was entirely, completely, absolutely opaque.

That is not correct. Fairly often pg responded to questions about whether a post was getting flagged.

Anyway, you're right that my comment wasn't really related to your original comment. I guess just the defensive tone of your comment set me off, because I keep seeing rampant censorship on HN, perhaps even more than before, and that irks me.

> they can mail [email protected] and be virtually assured that they'll get a personal, candid answer from the mod squad about what's going on. That's not as gratifying as snarking about it in public, though.

So, the problem with jacquesm -- who has been publicly complaining about his inability to submit articles for a long time now, is that he just never emailed hn@ycombinator? That is a _necessary_ step to regain the ability to make submissions? I think in a healthy community it would not have been. I've known jacquesm for a long time now, he's a genuinely nice guy who's always willing to spare time to give tips on everything from programming to startups, he should not have had his submitting privileges revoked in the first place.

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by tptacek on Sunday April 27, 2014 @01:30PM (#7655938)
I see Daniel and Nick working their assess off to improve quality on the site, and I see quality actually improving. Whatever they're doing, it's working, and I appreciate it.

I think it's totally inappropriate for me to discuss 'jacquesm, or really most other HN commenters, with random people on HN.

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by kens on Sunday April 27, 2014 @01:00PM (#7655828)
The front page has never been the raw "community intent". It's not just upvotes and time that control ranking. Other factors are sites that get automatically penalized, title words that get penalized, flagged articles, controversy penalty (which is likely to hit this article soon), articles that get marked as "fluff", and probably other factors.

From my measurements (in 2013 before the latest changes), at least 20% of front-page articles and 38% of second-page articles were penalized, so there have always been a lot of invisible ranking changes.

I wrote up details at http://www.righto.com/2013/11/how-hacker-news-ranking-really...