Nobody ever said hellbanning would go away, or that users wouldn't lose privileges.
If people believe themselves to be "rankbanned" or "slowbanned", they can mail [email protected] and be virtually assured that they'll get a personal, candid answer from the mod squad about what's going on. That's not as gratifying as snarking about it in public, though.
That is not correct. Fairly often pg responded to questions about whether a post was getting flagged.
Anyway, you're right that my comment wasn't really related to your original comment. I guess just the defensive tone of your comment set me off, because I keep seeing rampant censorship on HN, perhaps even more than before, and that irks me.
> they can mail [email protected] and be virtually assured that they'll get a personal, candid answer from the mod squad about what's going on. That's not as gratifying as snarking about it in public, though.
So, the problem with jacquesm -- who has been publicly complaining about his inability to submit articles for a long time now, is that he just never emailed hn@ycombinator? That is a _necessary_ step to regain the ability to make submissions? I think in a healthy community it would not have been. I've known jacquesm for a long time now, he's a genuinely nice guy who's always willing to spare time to give tips on everything from programming to startups, he should not have had his submitting privileges revoked in the first place.
I think it's totally inappropriate for me to discuss 'jacquesm, or really most other HN commenters, with random people on HN.