Hope I don't get in career trouble later for saying this (it is under pseudonym though), but I think that a suitable form of organization would be beneficial for software people. Lawsuits like this one are an excellent case in point. We just have to make sure we don't make the same mistakes that the traditional (and especially automotive) unions did.
Anti-unionism is often as much about the authority as it is about saving money; the desire to retain arbitrary power over your employees and know you've given them the bad end of the deal, even if they're on a multi-hundred-thousand-dollar salary.
Food and shelter should only be supplied to the worker as condition of employment. Food should only be available through an FSO (food supply organization).
Also:
* transparency in compensation.
* protection against sharing of individual HR data (salaries, performance reviews) among companies, often used to keep pay down.
Those two things are in contradiction.For example, Tekna, the Norwegian Technical and scientific professionals' society, publishes annual (anonymized) salary surveys which are categorized by percentile, length of work experience and public vs. private sector. A software developers' "union" could easily provide similar statistics, perhaps organized by specialty. What you need to publish for transparency is enough information to ensure that new employees don't get a raw deal, not individualized information.
That being said, as an employee, I'm so afraid of unions screwing up that I can't make my mind between having an union vs. these periodic lawsuits/settlements in order to keep the balance. It seems every example of a union being a good thing (like the Norway example mentioned here) feels like a bug in the matrix.
Almost every time you comment, there's immediately a comment from an active Googler telling everyone how you see things in a completely different way.
For example, you casually mention here how you must be black listed because you have seen career problems since. Yet this is nothing to do with unions, and all about anti poaching agreements. I don't intend to slander you here, I just find it extremely hard to believe anything you say isn't delivered with an agenda.
Google has almost 50,000 employees. Not all of them are intelligent, well-adjusted people.
For example, you casually mention here how you must be black listed because you have seen career problems since.
I don't think I'm "blacklisted". I've definitely caught inappropriate communications behind my back, to the point that I've had to pursue litigation and have collected a couple of (small) tortious interference settlements. "Blacklisted" implies inability to get jobs, and it hasn't been nearly that bad for me because I'm ostensibly good at what I do. I've just had to deal with annoyances, like inappropriate questions on job interviews.
Yet this is nothing to do with unions, and all about anti poaching agreements.
The original purpose of shared blacklists was to shut out union risks ("troublemakers"). No-poach agreements are a similar, illegal, collusion among employers who are supposed to be competing. There are also HR departments in tech companies who share salary and performance reviews down to the level of the individual, and that's also (if not illegal) extremely immoral. Three heads of the same beast (no-poach lists, blacklists, salary databases) but the infrastructure of collusion is the same.
I just find it extremely hard to believe anything you say isn't delivered with an agenda.
I'd like to fix technology. That's an agenda. What's wrong with having "an agenda"? The alternative would be not having one. I wouldn't post on this forum if I didn't care about the future of this industry.
This is much much bigger issue to any employer than any union-forming issue. An employee who sues is a giant nightmare. (Which I will say right now can be unfair, because it's hard for an outsider to distinguish between the bogus lawsuit and the legit lawsuit, and there are plenty of both in the workplace.)
Lawsuits are just about as bad as comments about how you would declare war on your employer if they cross a line you have set. I've seen you make that comment at least twice.
A union agitator would need to get a critical mass of coworkers to go along with him to cause real trouble. A guy who sues or self-describes as declaring war can cause real trouble all by himself.
EDIT: I have some specific posts I could refer to, but I don't think linking to them follow the "Please add comments that make things better" rule. I'm not 100% positive that this comment so far follows the rule, so I'm quitting before I get too far behind.
However, even without deliberately asking, a company could learn, and it's not hard to imagine why an employer would be very wary of hiring someone who has sued a former employer. Being sued is an extremely stressful thing and lots of people go to great, even possibly irrational, lengths to avoid it.
Ask how you would feel working for a company that had sued former employees.
There are no good answers.
Their responses to you that I have seen show no indication of underlying issues. Indeed they almost all seem to indict you as being overly obsessed with showing your infallibility with regards to you leaving Google. This conversation has started off in a similar manner.
> "Blacklisted" implies inability to get jobs, and it hasn't been nearly that bad for me because I'm ostensibly good at what I do. I've just had to deal with annoyances, like inappropriate questions on job interviews.
This is incredibly vague and you use it to imply that Google employees have emailed potential employers of yours and 'poisoned the well'. Lets make this clear. Have you collected any tortious intereference settlements against Google relating to potential employers you have interviewed for?
> The original purpose of shared blacklists was to shut out union risks
That is utterly irrelevant. This is not about union problems in any way, this is about a different illegal agreement.
> I'd like to fix technology. That's an agenda. What's wrong with having "an agenda"
This is pretty deliberately obtuse, you know exactly what I am stating, that you appear to have an anti-Google agenda in your comments, regardless of the actual topic of discussion.
However, I can't see how at all this is relevant and why it's taken into account in evaluating michaelochurch's comment.
For example, one of his statements is:
> The Valley is fucking terrified of unions. So terrified that if you even seem like you might be leaning that way, executive-level people in major companies will go out of their way to fuck up your career. A lot of the back-channel reference checking that goes on in the Valley is to avoid taking on a potential unionist. No one cares if you were a mediocre performer 3 jobs ago.
We surely could question the anecdotal nature of OP's experience and call for more evidence, yet commenters start implying that the person is writing this out of mental instability or evil agenda.
> you appear to have an anti-Google agenda in your comments
IMHO it seems natural that pro-Google comments from other employees of the company, which you mention as answering to OP elsewhere, too might likely have an agenda of their own.
I just think the whole 'Google fired me' angle Michael always brings to the discussion irrelevant.
These anti poaching agreements were seriously immoral and they have literally nothing to do with Unions.
In contrast all the active Google employees who follow him around are anon posters. Anon posters who never worked with Michael and are only repeating office gossip or pointing out differences in perspective.
Edit: Anon people sign up to hn simply to try and discredit MichaelOChurch by attacking his (admittedly a little rough around the edges) reputation. See shanterer's post below for evidence in this thread.
Without taking any side here, this isn't indicative of much. One has to work very hard to be able to actually lose a libel or slander lawsuit in the US. And while it would be very easy for Google to start a lawsuit it knows it can't win just to pressure some guy to shut up, Google probably understands the Streisand effect very well.
I think it does up the ante. If a Google employee (or anyone who doesn't like him really) could catch him in a lie his reputation would be damaged as he is a "public figure".
On the other hand if you caught me in a lie... well only around 5-6 people know who I am and I copied this nick off another bloke on a different forum because I thought it was cool. So it wouldn't really bother me.
IANAL.
What stuff?
This is a very old game, and the original reason for employers to share all that data was to blacklist "troublemakers" who might unionize the workforce. Now, it's more often used to verify compensation (lest people lie and big themselves up) and enforce no-poach pacts, but it's every bit as unethical.
wikipedia sockpuppets: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Isomorphic/Minions_of_the_...
blatant sockpuppetry on quora: http://qr.ae/rPxvn http://qr.ae/rPxCq
his obsessive anti-google and anti-startup posting on hackernews speaks for itself.
Naturally, if working in our field yields pretty good money to most of us—regardless of how fairly we are treated—then why unionize? surely that must be just some weirdo's twisted communist ideals or some competitor's money behind.
I found out last March why my manager at Google was adverse to me. I knew someone was pulling strings on him and I had thought that he was taking orders related to my criticism of the G+ direction (in fact, the G+ executives were, as far as I know, innocent) but it was actually because an executive (who's since been disciplined) flagged me as a union risk. I said something to the effect of "decisions would be better if made on the floor" and that was taken to mean far more than I actually meant. (I was talking about G+ Games, not unionizing the Valley. Small difference.)
However, that ordeal and the career problems I've faced since then have convinced me that we need to unionize software development and the Valley ecosystem.
The Valley is fucking terrified of unions. So terrified that if you even seem like you might be leaning that way, executive-level people in major companies will go out of their way to fuck up your career. A lot of the back-channel reference checking that goes on in the Valley is to avoid taking on a potential unionist. No one cares if you were a mediocre performer 3 jobs ago. That stuff is there to black-list potential unionizers.
Now, do I think we want or need a factory-style union where promotions and pay are based on seniority? Hell no. That's a terrible idea. Engineers who work their asses off to become the best they can be, and to advance their respective fields, should be rewarded. I think that the top engineers would make more with a properly-designed union structure than they do now (since, currently, they top out at 1.5 times the pay of mediocre ones). I think our model needs to be more like the Hollywood unions (writers' and actors' guilds). Those do not curtail the financial upside for their members (there are still actors making millions per year) nor do they produce mediocrity. (Say what you want about Hollywood's product, but it's immensely commercially successful and the envy of the pop-culture world.)
Specific union protections we need include:
These are all things that we can have, and that we deserve, that bring none of the negative side effects associated with unions.