It always comes down to the numbers, though. If we're advertising a small business on Facebook, and it generates more in revenues from sales than it costs in customer acquisition, it's still a net win. Is it the best place we could have invested those advertising funds? Maybe, maybe not, but it certainly becomes less attractive as their cost-per-whatever figures go up, and no matter how much they fudge the presentation, we still know how much we paid overall and how much revenue we got in return.
In any case, every time this comes up there are plenty of posters who have small businesses and make the above argument, but generate revenues in the 100-200% bracket, i.e., they're at least breaking even and maybe doubling their investment, but no-one's buying the private jet and yacht any time soon. It doesn't take anything shady-sounding like a bait and switch for Facebook to lose all of that business, it just takes increasing cost-per-whatever a bit more until the return on investment is no longer a safe bet. At that point, they lose to other options with either generally better returns (so you don't care about the odd few percent, because you know you're still comfortably winning overall) or a more predictable model (so you can still run it on tighter margins).
Businesses grew their followers on Facebook over the years with the intention of growing a user-base they could engage with. Now a substantially lower number of your followers see content you post due to algorithm changes. The way to increase your reach to your followers is by paying for ads to basically recapture the engagement you were once getting free.
It would be like if Twitter started charging businesses to display tweets to their own followers.
I can see where you're coming from. We've always assumed that Likes had no inherent value -- they are worth exactly the amount of extra revenue they ultimately generate through better reach and/or conversion rates -- so we never ran campaigns whose only goal was something that happens on Facebook. However, I accept that others might have had different expectations. In any case, nerfing posts so you have to pay to boost them if you want the same coverage you had before was clearly a hostile move on Facebook's part.
This statement ignores the marginal cost of sales. In your oil change example I have to deduct the cost of the oil from my revenue, before I compare it with customer acquisition cost.
(Of course, attribution of new customers to particular sources is not always easy, either, particularly if you might have gotten that customer even if you had ceased to advertise.)
Remember when apps came out and developers could spam the crap out of their user's walls and message all their user's friends? They let that slide for a while, probably to watch how people adopted the platform, then locked it down once they themselves had locked down tons of app developers on their platform.
Likewise with ads initially. You could get away with basically anything at first, running iffy ads to iffy landing pages, cloaking, buying cheap ass likes for fan pages you could then drop affiliate offers onto. They let that slide for a while until marketers became dependent on their platform, then yanked the rug out from under them and made it much harder to get away with any of that stuff.
He showed the usage of his page beforehand, with users clustered in Western countries, generally 20-40% of whom interacted with his page in some way. After paying for more views, they were all from developing countries, a profile of users he'd never seen before with very little (0-1%) engagement with his page.
It's worth checking out his videos if you want more detail on the patterns he found. It's pretty clear that it's fraudulent.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9ZqXlHl65g (explores problems he sees with FB as a marketing platform)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oVfHeWTKjag (massive influx of unengaged developing-world pageviews)If you go from a time point when there were 3 television channels to a point where there are 500, have the original 3 channels pulled a bait-and-switch on you by promising "national audience"?
If a social network user likes your page and your page only, he'll see 100%. As soon as another page enters the mix, your reach will drop correlated to that other page's posting frequency (local pizza shop - you'll likely still get user's eyeballs, New York Times or Reuters - your updates might get drowned in that other page's updates).
A year ago an average US user was following 70 pages http://allfacebook.com/how-many-pages-does-the-average-faceb... but the number was growing, no doubt inspired by ad campaigns on TV and in storefronts.
First the pages were free and great, then they started to reduce the number of people who'd see your posts (fair enough, not everyone can see every little thing)
Then they reduced the % of people seeing posts to 3% and less, and really focussed on getting those page owners to buy ads to maintain their previous view numbers.
Maybe page owners are paying for now, potentially reliant on traffic, but I don't think they're going to be happy paying forever when free alternatives will crop up again. The traffic quality is reported as being low (many mis-clicks on mobile). If the profit isn't there then business won't be able to afford to pay in the long run.
Maybe I don't want to see posts for 'Jim's oil change' every three seconds, but good content is getting cut away also making FB far more boring.